Discount Tire sells used tires alongside new ones, but the selection, warranty, and pricing vary by location

Discount Tire (now operating under the Discount Tire and America's Tire brands) carries used tires at most locations, though not all stores stock them equally. Used tires cost less than new ones—typically 40 to 60 percent of new tire prices depending on tread depth and condition—but come with shorter or no tread-wear warranties. Before you buy, you need to know what condition the tire is actually in, what the store's return policy covers, and whether the price difference justifies the shorter lifespan.

The used tires Discount Tire sells come from trade-ins when customers buy new tires, or from fleet returns. The store inspects them for damage, patches, and tread depth before putting them on the shelf. Tread depth is measured in 32nds of an inch; most states require a minimum of 2/32 inches for legal driving, but safety experts recommend replacing tires at 4/32 inches, especially in wet conditions. Discount Tire's used inventory changes constantly, so availability depends on what customers have traded in recently.

Key Takeaways

  • Used tires at Discount Tire typically cost 40 to 60 percent less than new tires but come with limited or no tread-wear warranty coverage.
  • Tread depth determines how much life remains in a used tire; ask the store to measure it in 32nds of an inch before you commit to a purchase.
  • Not every Discount Tire location stocks used tires, so call ahead or check online inventory to confirm your store carries them.
  • Discount Tire's return policy for used tires is shorter than for new tires, usually 30 days instead of 60, so inspect the tires when ready after purchase.

How Discount Tire prices and inspects used tires

Discount Tire prices used tires based on brand, size, tread depth, and overall condition. A used tire with 6/32 inches of tread remaining costs more than one with 4/32 inches, even if both are legal to drive. The store's staff should be able to tell you the exact tread depth using a penny test or a tread-depth gauge; ask them to show you the measurement rather than taking their word for it. Tires with visible patches, cracks in the sidewall, or uneven wear are typically marked down further or removed from inventory.

Before you leave the store, inspect the tires yourself. Look for bulges, cuts, or puncture repairs on the sidewalls—these are signs the tire has been damaged and may fail. Check that the tread is even across the tire's width; uneven wear suggests an alignment problem on the previous owner's vehicle, which could happen to yours too. If you notice damage after you get home, Discount Tire's return window for used tires is usually 30 days, compared to 60 days for new tires, so act quickly.

Warranty coverage on used tires from Discount Tire

Used tires sold by Discount Tire come with limited or no manufacturer warranty, depending on the tire's age and condition. Some used tires carry a prorated tread-wear warranty—meaning the manufacturer covers defects for a portion of the tire's remaining life, but you pay a percentage of the replacement cost based on how much tread you've used. Other used tires are sold as-is with no warranty at all. Always ask the store in writing what warranty, if any, covers the specific tires you're buying.

Discount Tire itself typically offers a road-hazard warranty on new tires it sells, which covers punctures and impact damage for a set period. This warranty is rarely included with used tires, though some locations may offer it for an additional fee. If you drive in areas with rough roads or construction zones, the cost of adding road-hazard coverage to a used tire purchase might be worth it—ask the store what they charge.

When buying used tires makes financial sense

Used tires are worth considering if you need a temporary solution while you save for a full set of new tires, or if you're replacing a single damaged tire and want to avoid the cost of a new one. They also make sense if you drive a vehicle you plan to sell soon and don't want to invest in new rubber. However, if you drive frequently on highways, in heavy rain, or in snow, the shorter lifespan of a used tire means you'll be back at the tire shop sooner, which can offset the initial savings.

Compare the per-mile cost, not just the upfront price. A used tire with 6/32 inches of tread remaining might last 15,000 to 20,000 miles before it reaches the 2/32-inch legal minimum. A new tire in the same size might last 40,000 to 60,000 miles. If the used tire costs $40 and the new tire costs $120, the used tire costs roughly $2 to $2.67 per 1,000 miles, while the new tire costs $2 to $3 per 1,000 miles. The difference narrows when you factor in installation, balancing, and the hassle of another trip to the shop.

How to find and check used tire inventory at your local store

Not all Discount Tire locations carry used tires, and inventory changes weekly. Call your local store directly and ask whether they have used tires in your vehicle's size in stock. Some stores list used inventory online through their website or app, but the online listing may not be current, so a phone call is more reliable. Ask the staff how often they receive new used tires and whether they can hold a specific tire for you if you're planning to visit later.

When you visit, bring your vehicle's tire size, which you'll find on the driver's-side door jamb or in your owner's manual. The size looks like this: 225/65R17. Tell the staff your budget and ask them to show you all used tires in that size within your price range. Ask to see the tread-depth measurement for each one, and ask about the condition of the sidewalls and any repairs. If the store doesn't have what you need, ask when they expect new inventory or whether they can order a used tire from another location.

Comparing used tires to other budget options

Used tires aren't your only low-cost option. Budget tire brands—such as Westlake, Kumho, or Laufenn—are new tires that cost significantly less than premium brands like Michelin or Goodyear, often $50 to $80 per tire less. These tires carry full manufacturer warranties and last longer than most used tires, even though they may not perform as well in extreme conditions. For many drivers, a new budget tire is a better value than a used premium tire.

Another option is to buy a single new tire to replace a damaged one, rather than replacing all four at once. This works if your other three tires still have adequate tread and are the same brand and model. Mixing tire brands or models can affect handling and traction, so ask Discount Tire's staff whether your existing tires are compatible with a replacement. If you need to replace all four tires, buying four new budget tires often costs less than buying four used tires plus installation and balancing.

What to do if a used tire fails after purchase

If a used tire goes flat, develops a bulge, or fails within Discount Tire's return window (usually 30 days), return it to the store with your receipt. The store will inspect it to determine whether the failure was a manufacturing defect or caused by road damage or improper maintenance. If it's a defect, Discount Tire will typically replace it or refund your money. If the failure was caused by road hazard and you didn't purchase road-hazard coverage, you'll likely pay for a replacement.

After the return window closes, your options depend on the warranty that came with the tire. If the tire carried a prorated tread-wear warranty, contact the tire manufacturer directly with your receipt and proof of purchase from Discount Tire. The manufacturer will assess the tire and may cover part of a replacement cost. If the tire was sold as-is with no warranty, you're responsible for the full cost of a replacement.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if a used tire is safe to buy?

Ask the store to measure the tread depth in 32nds of an inch and show you the number. Inspect the sidewalls for bulges, cracks, or multiple patches. Uneven tread wear across the tire's width is a red flag. If you're unsure, ask the staff to explain any damage they see and whether they would put that tire on their own vehicle.

Can I return a used tire if I change my mind?

Yes, but the return window is shorter than for new tires—usually 30 days instead of 60. You'll need your receipt and the original tires must be in the condition you purchased them. If you've driven on them and they show wear, the store may refuse the return or charge a restocking fee.

Do used tires need to be balanced and aligned?

Yes. Used tires should be balanced when installed, just like new ones, to prevent vibration and uneven wear. Balancing typically costs $15 to $25 per tire. Alignment is separate and depends on your vehicle's condition, not the tire's age, so ask whether your vehicle needs it before you buy.

What's the difference between a used tire and a refurbished tire?

A used tire is a tire that was previously driven and traded in. A refurbished tire has been inspected, cleaned, and had its tread restored through a process called retreading. Refurbished tires are less common at Discount Tire but may carry a warranty. Ask the store whether a tire is used or refurbished before you buy.

Should I buy four used tires or mix used and new?

Mixing used and new tires can cause handling problems and uneven wear. If you need to replace tires, buy either four used tires of the same brand and model, or four new tires. If budget is tight, four new budget-brand tires often cost less than four used premium tires and last longer.