Badger State Used Tires is a Wisconsin-based retailer that buys, sells, and installs used tires at lower prices than new ones
Badger State Used Tires operates multiple locations across Wisconsin, primarily in the Milwaukee and Madison areas. The company specializes in used tires that have been inspected and graded by tread depth and condition. You can buy tires by the piece, have them mounted and balanced at their shop, or order online for pickup or delivery depending on location.
The main appeal is cost: used tires typically run 40 to 70 percent less than new ones, which matters if you need a quick replacement or want to extend the life of a vehicle you plan to sell soon. The trade-off is tread life — a used tire with 6/32 of an inch of tread remaining will wear out faster than a new tire with 10/32, even if both are the same brand and model.
Key Takeaways
- Badger State Used Tires grades tires by tread depth and condition, so you know what you are buying before purchase.
- Used tires cost significantly less than new ones but have less remaining tread life and a shorter warranty period.
- The company operates in Wisconsin only, with locations in Milwaukee, Madison, and surrounding areas.
- You can buy tires in-store, online for pickup, or have them shipped to your address depending on your local store's policies.
- Installation, mounting, and balancing are available at their shops for an additional fee.
How Badger State Grades and Prices Used Tires
Used tires are sorted into grades based on remaining tread depth and visible wear. Tread depth is measured in 32nds of an inch — new tires start at 10/32, and most states require a minimum of 2/32 before they become unsafe. Badger State typically stocks tires in the 4/32 to 8/32 range, meaning they have several thousand miles of life left but less than a new tire.
Pricing varies by tire size, brand, and grade. A used all-season tire in good condition might cost $25 to $50, while a premium brand or larger size could run $60 to $100. You can check current inventory and pricing on their website or by calling your nearest location. Prices change as inventory turns over, so what is available today may not be in stock next week.
When Used Tires Make Sense for Your Situation
Used tires work best if you need a temporary solution, are on a tight budget, or own a vehicle you do not plan to keep long-term. They are also reasonable if you have a flat or blowout and need a replacement quickly without waiting for shipping. Many people buy used tires for winter driving in Wisconsin, since winter tires wear faster and replacing them with new ones every season becomes expensive.
Used tires are not the right choice if you drive long distances regularly, need maximum safety margin, or plan to keep the vehicle for several more years. A tire with 4/32 of tread will need replacement sooner than one with 8/32, so factor that into your decision. If you finance a vehicle through a loan or lease, check your agreement — some lenders require new tires or tires above a certain tread depth.
Installation and Mounting at Badger State Locations
Badger State offers mounting, balancing, and installation at their physical locations. Mounting and balancing typically costs $15 to $25 per tire depending on size and whether you need valve stems replaced. Installation includes removing your old tires, mounting the new ones on your wheels, balancing them, and reinstalling them on your vehicle.
You can bring your own wheels or have Badger State mount the tires on your existing wheels if you remove them first. Turnaround time is usually same-day or next-day depending on how busy the location is. Call ahead to confirm availability, especially during busy seasons like fall and spring when people prepare for weather changes.
Warranty and Return Policies
Used tires come with a limited warranty that is shorter than what new tires carry. Badger State typically offers a 30-day return or exchange period if you find a defect or the tire does not perform as described. The warranty does not cover normal wear, punctures from road hazards, or damage from improper installation or maintenance.
Keep your receipt and ask about the specific warranty terms when you buy. Different tire grades may have different coverage periods, so confirm what applies to the tires you purchase. If a tire fails prematurely due to a manufacturing defect, Badger State will usually replace it or issue a credit toward a new purchase.
Comparing Used Tires to Other Options
| Option | Cost per Tire | Tread Life Remaining | Warranty | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Badger State Used Tires | $25–$100 | 4/32–8/32 inches | 30 days to 1 year | Budget buyers, temporary fixes, short-term vehicles |
| New Budget Brand | $60–$120 | 10/32 inches | 3–5 years | Cost-conscious buyers keeping the vehicle long-term |
| New Mid-Range Brand | $120–$200 | 10/32 inches | 5–7 years | Most drivers; balance of cost and durability |
| Tire Discounters or Costco | $80–$180 | 10/32 inches | 3–10 years | Bulk buyers, members seeking discounts on new tires |
Used tires from Badger State are cheapest upfront but require replacement sooner. New budget tires cost more initially but last longer and carry longer warranties. If you plan to keep your vehicle for more than two years, the per-mile cost of a new tire often beats a used one, even though the initial price is higher.
How to Find and Contact Badger State Locations
Badger State Used Tires operates locations in Wisconsin, with the largest presence in the Milwaukee and Madison metro areas. You can find your nearest store, check hours, and view current inventory on their website. Most locations are open Monday through Saturday, with limited Sunday hours at some shops.
You can call ahead to confirm they have your tire size in stock, ask about pricing, or schedule an installation appointment. If you order online, confirm shipping costs and delivery timeframes for your zip code before checkout. Some locations offer local delivery for a fee, while others require you to pick up in-store.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if a used tire is safe to drive on?
Badger State grades tires by tread depth, which is the primary safety measure. Tires with 4/32 or more tread are legal and reasonably safe for normal driving. You can also do a penny test: insert a penny into the tread with Lincoln's head upside down — if you can see the top of his head, tread is too low. Ask the store staff what grade the specific tire is before you buy.
Can I return a used tire if it goes flat or gets damaged?
That depends on the cause and Badger State's warranty terms. Manufacturing defects are usually covered within 30 days. Road hazards like nails or potholes are not covered — those are considered normal wear and tear. Ask about coverage before you leave the store, and keep your receipt as proof of purchase.
Do I need to buy all four tires at once, or can I buy just one or two?
You can buy as many or as few tires as you need. However, for best handling and safety, most mechanics recommend replacing tires in pairs (front or rear) or all four if possible. If you buy just one tire, make sure it matches the tread depth of the tire opposite it on the same axle.
What if Badger State does not have my tire size in stock?
Call your nearest location to check availability. If they do not have what you need, they may be able to order it from another Badger State location or suggest when new inventory is expected. You can also ask if they can special-order a specific brand or model, though this may take longer than buying in-stock tires.
Is it cheaper to buy used tires online or in-store at Badger State?
Prices are typically the same whether you order online or visit in person. The main difference is convenience: in-store lets you see and inspect the tires before buying, while online ordering saves a trip if you know your size and are comfortable with the grade. Factor in shipping or delivery costs if ordering online.