The Crosstrek uses a cartridge-style filter that sits on top of the engine
Your Subaru Crosstrek's oil filter is not a spin-on canister like you might find on other vehicles. Instead, it's a cartridge filter housed in a plastic cap on the top of the engine. The filter element itself is a pleated paper cylinder that you replace during each oil change, while the cap and housing stay in place. This design is common across Subaru's lineup and costs less to replace than traditional spin-on filters, but the process is slightly different from what you may have done on other cars.
The filter location makes it straightforward to access without getting under the vehicle or reaching into tight engine compartments. You'll find it near the center-top of the engine, typically on the driver's side. The plastic cap has a large hex nut on top that you turn to remove the entire assembly, then you swap out the old filter element for a new one and reinstall the cap.
Key Takeaways
- Crosstrek oil filters are cartridge-style elements housed in a removable plastic cap, not spin-on canisters.
- You will need a filter wrench (usually 74mm or 86mm depending on model year) to remove the cap, plus a new filter element and a replacement crush washer.
- The filter element costs between $8 and $15, while the crush washer is typically $2 to $4, making the parts significantly cheaper than spin-on alternatives.
- Replacement takes 5 to 10 minutes once you have the correct wrench size and understand the cartridge design.
What size filter your Crosstrek needs by model year
Subaru changed the filter housing size between model generations. The first-generation Crosstrek (2013–2017) uses a smaller 74mm filter cap, while the second generation (2018 and newer) switched to an 86mm cap. Using the wrong size wrench will round off the hex nut and make removal difficult or impossible, so confirm your model year before buying tools.
You can verify your exact model year on your vehicle's door jamb sticker or in your owner's manual. If you're unsure, most auto parts stores can look it up by your VIN. The filter element itself is the same across both generations—a Subaru OEM part number 16510AA051 or equivalent aftermarket cartridge—but the cap size determines which wrench you need.
Tools and parts you'll need
Beyond the new filter element and crush washer, you need a filter wrench sized to your Crosstrek's cap. A 74mm wrench fits 2013–2017 models, and an 86mm wrench fits 2018 and newer. These wrenches are available at any auto parts store for $10 to $20 and will last through dozens of oil changes. Some people use a strap wrench or even a rubber grip if they don't want to buy a dedicated tool, but a proper filter wrench gives you the leverage and grip you need without damaging the cap.
You'll also want an oil drain pan, fresh engine oil (check your owner's manual for the correct grade and capacity), and a clean rag or paper towels. A torque wrench is optional but helpful—the cap should be tightened to 18 foot-pounds, which prevents over-tightening and damage to the plastic housing.
Step-by-step replacement process
Start with a warm engine (not hot—warm enough that the oil flows easily but cool enough to touch). Locate the filter cap on top of the engine and position your drain pan underneath it. Use your filter wrench to turn the cap counterclockwise and remove it completely. The old filter element will come out with the cap; set it aside in your drain pan to catch any remaining oil.
Inspect the rubber gasket (crush washer) on the underside of the cap. If it's cracked, hardened, or stuck to the engine, replace it with a new one. Clean the seating surface on the engine with a clean rag to remove any debris or old gasket material. Insert the new filter element into the cap, making sure it sits flat and fully inside the housing. Thread the cap back onto the engine by hand first, then use your filter wrench to tighten it snugly. Do not over-tighten; hand-tight plus a quarter turn is usually sufficient, or use a torque wrench set to 18 foot-pounds if you have one.
Once the filter is installed, refill the engine with fresh oil through the oil filler cap on top of the engine. Check your owner's manual for the correct capacity—most Crosstreks hold between 4.2 and 4.5 quarts depending on whether you're also replacing the drain plug. Start the engine and let it run for 30 seconds, then turn it off and wait a minute for the oil to settle. Check the dipstick or use the electronic oil level display in your instrument cluster to confirm you're at the full mark.
OEM versus aftermarket filter elements
Subaru's original equipment filter element (part number 16510AA051) costs $10 to $15 at most dealers and online retailers. Aftermarket options from Fram, Bosch, and Mobil are typically the same price or slightly cheaper and perform equally well for standard driving. The main difference is that OEM filters come with Subaru's warranty backing, while aftermarket filters rely on the manufacturer's reputation.
For most owners, either choice is fine. If you're doing your own oil changes and want to keep costs down, a quality aftermarket filter is a reasonable choice. If you prefer the assurance of factory parts or plan to have the work done at a Subaru dealer, the OEM element is worth the small premium. Avoid the cheapest no-name filters; they often have lower-quality media that doesn't filter as effectively.
Common mistakes to avoid
The most frequent error is forgetting to replace the crush washer. This rubber gasket seals the cap to the engine and prevents oil leaks. If you reuse the old washer, it hardens over time and loses its seal, leading to slow leaks that can go unnoticed until you've lost significant oil. Always install a new washer with each filter change—they cost just a few dollars and take seconds to swap.
A second mistake is over-tightening the cap. The plastic housing can crack if you crank the wrench too hard, and a cracked cap will leak oil and require replacement of the entire assembly. Hand-tight plus a quarter turn is the right amount of force; if you have a torque wrench, use it set to 18 foot-pounds. Finally, don't forget to refill the engine with fresh oil after installing the new filter. Running the engine without enough oil, even for a few seconds, can cause serious damage.
Where to buy Crosstrek filter elements and washers
Auto parts chains like AutoZone, O'Reilly, NAPA, and Advance Auto Parts stock Crosstrek filter elements and crush washers in-store and online. Subaru dealerships carry OEM parts and can order them if they're not in stock. Online retailers like Amazon and RockAuto often have lower prices, though you'll need to wait for shipping. Most stores can look up the correct part by your VIN if you're unsure which size you need.
Buying the filter element and crush washer together as a kit is sometimes cheaper than buying them separately. Some retailers bundle them with a small bottle of oil for a slight discount. Compare prices across a few sources before ordering, especially if you're buying online—shipping costs can offset a lower per-item price.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I reuse the old crush washer?
No. The rubber gasket hardens after one oil change and loses its ability to seal. Reusing it will cause oil leaks around the filter cap. Always install a new washer—they cost $2 to $4 and are essential to prevent leaks.
What happens if I use the wrong size filter wrench?
Using a wrench that's too small or too large will round off the hex nut on the cap, making it impossible to remove without damaging the plastic housing. Confirm your model year and buy the correct size (74mm for 2013–2017, 86mm for 2018 and newer) before starting.
How often should I replace the oil filter?
Subaru recommends replacing the filter with every oil change. For most Crosstreks, that's every 6,000 miles or 6 months, whichever comes first. Check your owner's manual for your specific model's maintenance schedule.
Is it normal for a little oil to spill when I remove the filter cap?
Yes, some oil will remain in the cap and filter element. Position your drain pan directly under the cap before removing it, and let the old filter drip into the pan for a minute or two before setting it aside. This minimizes mess and prevents oil from spilling onto the engine.
Do I need to prime the new filter before installing it?
No. Unlike spin-on filters, cartridge filters don't need to be filled with oil before installation. straightforward insert the dry element into the cap and install the assembly. The oil will flow through the new filter once the engine starts.