Getting a rental car on Block Island requires planning ahead because the island has limited rental options and high seasonal demand

Block Island, located 12 miles off the Rhode Island coast, has only a handful of car rental companies operating year-round or seasonally. Unlike mainland rental hubs, you cannot walk off the ferry and find a major chain desk. Most renters book before arriving, either online or by phone, and pick up their car at the ferry terminal or a nearby location in Old Harbor. Prices are significantly higher than mainland rates, and availability shrinks quickly during summer weekends and holidays.

The island itself is small — about 7 miles long and 3 miles wide — so a rental car is optional for many visitors who stay in one area. However, if you plan to explore multiple beaches, restaurants, or the northern end of the island, a car makes the trip much easier than relying on taxis or the limited shuttle services.

Key Takeaways

  • Block Island has only two or three active rental companies, so book your car at least one to two weeks before your trip, especially in summer.
  • Most rentals must be picked up at or near the ferry terminal in Old Harbor, and you should arrange this when you book, not upon arrival.
  • Daily rates on Block Island run roughly 50 to 100 percent higher than mainland Rhode Island rates because of limited supply and ferry logistics.
  • You will need a valid driver's license and a credit card in your name; some companies require you to be at least 25 years old.
  • The island's roads are narrow and often unpaved, so a compact or mid-size car is more practical than a large SUV.

Which rental companies operate on Block Island

The two main rental companies serving Block Island are Olitsky's Car Rental and Block Island Car Rental. Both operate year-round, though hours and availability vary by season. Olitsky's has been on the island for decades and maintains a fleet of standard sedans and small SUVs. Block Island Car Rental is smaller and often has limited inventory during peak season.

A third option, Island Moped & Car Rental, rents both cars and scooters but typically has fewer vehicles available. Seasonal operators may also appear during summer months, but they are not reliable year-round options. Do not assume a company will be open when you arrive; call or check their website before booking your ferry ticket.

None of these companies are affiliated with national chains like Enterprise, Hertz, or Avis. You are renting from local, independent operators, which means their policies, vehicle conditions, and customer service vary. Read recent reviews on Google or TripAdvisor before committing, and ask about their cancellation policy in writing.

How to book a car before you arrive

Contact your chosen rental company by phone or their website at least one to two weeks before your trip. Provide your arrival date, ferry time, departure date, and the number of days you need the car. Ask whether they will deliver the car to the ferry terminal or whether you need to pick it up at their office. Some companies include ferry terminal delivery; others charge an extra fee or require you to walk to their location.

Confirm the total price in writing, including any fees for ferry terminal delivery, insurance, or mileage. Ask what documents you need to bring — most require a valid driver's license and a credit card in your name. Some companies require a second form of ID or proof of insurance. Clarify their age policy; many require renters to be 25 or older, though some allow drivers as young as 21 with an additional fee.

Request a confirmation email with your reservation number, pickup location, pickup time, and the vehicle details (make, model, color, license plate). Do not rely on a verbal confirmation alone. If you need to cancel, do so as soon as possible; many Block Island rental companies charge cancellation fees if you cancel within 48 to 72 hours of your reservation.

What to expect when you pick up your rental

Arrive at your pickup location at least 15 to 30 minutes before your scheduled time. Bring your driver's license, credit card, and any other ID the company requested. The rental agent will show you the vehicle, point out any existing damage, and ask you to inspect it. Take photos or video of the car's exterior and interior, including the odometer reading, before you sign anything. This protects you if the company later claims you caused damage you did not.

Review the rental agreement carefully before signing. Confirm the daily rate, total cost, fuel policy (whether you return it full or empty), mileage limits, and damage liability. Ask about their insurance coverage and whether your personal auto insurance or credit card covers rental cars. Many credit cards offer rental car coverage, but you must decline the rental company's insurance to use yours — make this decision before you sign.

Ask for a phone number to call if you have problems with the car during your rental. Block Island has no major repair shops, so if the car breaks down, the rental company is responsible for getting you a replacement or a refund. Get this in writing or take a photo of their emergency contact information.

Driving on Block Island roads and parking

Block Island's roads are narrow, winding, and often unpaved, especially away from Old Harbor and the main beaches. Many roads are one-lane with pull-offs for passing. Speed limits are low — typically 25 to 35 mph — and enforced by Block Island Police. Rental companies often recommend compact cars or small SUVs over full-size vehicles because larger cars are difficult to maneuver and park.

Parking is free at most beaches and attractions, but spaces fill quickly in summer. Popular spots like Crescent Beach and Mansion Beach have small parking areas that reach capacity by mid-morning on sunny weekends. Arrive early or plan to visit less popular beaches like Mohegan Bluffs or Scotch Beach. Parking in Old Harbor near shops and restaurants is limited and sometimes metered during peak season; ask locals or your rental company for current parking rules.

Fuel is available at one or two gas stations on the island, and prices are higher than mainland Rhode Island. Fill up before you leave the ferry terminal area if possible, or budget extra for fuel costs. Some rental companies charge a fuel surcharge if you return the car with less than a full tank.

Costs and what to budget

Daily rental rates on Block Island typically range from $60 to $150 per day for a compact or mid-size sedan, depending on the season and how far in advance you book. Summer weekends and holidays are at the high end; off-season rates (November through April) are lower. Weekly rates are usually discounted, but the discount is smaller than on the mainland.

Additional costs to budget include fuel, parking (usually free but sometimes metered), and optional insurance. If your personal auto insurance or credit card does not cover rental cars, the rental company's insurance typically costs $15 to $25 per day. Ferry tickets are separate and cost roughly $30 to $40 per person round-trip, depending on the ferry service and season.

Some rental companies charge extra fees for ferry terminal delivery, drivers under 25, or returning the car late. Ask about all fees upfront and confirm the total price before you book. Do not assume the quoted daily rate is the final price.

Alternatives if you cannot rent a car

If rental cars are sold out or too expensive, you have other options. Taxis and ride-sharing are available through local services like Block Island Taxi, though wait times can be long during peak season and fares add up quickly for multiple trips. Scooters and mopeds are rented by Island Moped & Car Rental and other shops; they are cheaper than cars but require a valid motorcycle endorsement on your license and are risky on narrow, unpaved roads.

Bicycles are a popular option for visitors staying near Old Harbor or Crescent Beach. Several shops rent bikes for $15 to $30 per day, and the island has some bike-friendly routes. However, hills and unpaved roads make biking difficult for exploring the entire island. Walking is practical if you stay in one area; Old Harbor is walkable, and several beaches are within a mile of town.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to book a rental car before I arrive on Block Island?

Yes, you should book at least one to two weeks in advance, especially during summer. The island has only two or three rental companies with limited fleets, and they often sell out on weekends and holidays. Booking after you arrive risks finding no cars available.

Can I rent a car for just a few hours?

Most Block Island rental companies require a minimum of one full day. Some may negotiate shorter rentals during off-season, but this is not standard. Call ahead if you need the car for only a few hours; a taxi or scooter rental may be more practical.

What happens if the rental car breaks down while I am on the island?

Contact the rental company when ready using the emergency number they provided. They are responsible for providing a replacement vehicle or refunding your rental fee. Block Island has no major repair shops, so the company will either send a replacement by ferry or arrange for you to use a different vehicle.

Is my personal auto insurance or credit card coverage valid for a Block Island rental car?

Many personal auto insurance policies and credit cards do cover rental cars, but coverage varies. Check your policy or call your credit card company before your trip. If you have coverage, you must decline the rental company's insurance to use yours. If you are unsure, purchase the rental company's insurance to avoid disputes later.

Can I return the rental car to a different location than where I picked it up?

No. Block Island rental companies require you to return the car to the same location where you picked it up. There is only one island, so one-way rentals do not explore. Plan your return time to allow enough time before your ferry departure.