Import cars often cost more to insure than domestic models, and some insurers limit coverage or charge higher premiums based on the car's origin, parts availability, and repair costs
An import car — whether a Japanese sports car, European luxury sedan, or Korean compact — is insured the same way as any other vehicle: through liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. But the price and availability of that insurance can differ significantly. Insurers see imported vehicles as higher-risk or higher-cost to repair, which means you may pay more for the same coverage, face stricter underwriting, or find that some companies won't insure the car at all.
The reason is practical: repair shops may need to order parts from overseas, specialized technicians may be harder to find, and the insurer's claims history for that specific model may be limited. A 2015 Honda Civic costs less to insure than a 2015 Porsche 911, even though both are imports — because the Porsche is rarer, parts are expensive, and repair shops charge more for the work.
Key Takeaways
- Import cars typically carry higher insurance premiums than comparable domestic vehicles because parts, labor, and repair informed cost more.
- Some insurers exclude certain import brands or models entirely, so you may need to contact multiple companies to find coverage.
- The car's age, rarity, and market value in the United States all affect how much an insurer will charge and whether they will cover it.
- Aftermarket modifications common on import cars (turbochargers, suspension upgrades, body kits) can void coverage or trigger rate increases if not disclosed.
- Insuring an import through a specialty insurer that focuses on imported vehicles may cost less than going through a mainstream carrier.
Why Import Cars Cost More to Insure
Insurers set rates based on the cost to repair or replace a vehicle after a claim. For import cars, that cost is often higher than for domestic models. Parts for a Japanese sports car may need to be ordered from Japan or a limited U.S. distributor, adding weeks to repair time and shipping fees to the bill. A European luxury car may require a technician certified by the manufacturer, and those shops charge premium labor rates.
Rarity also matters. If an insurer has claims data on thousands of Honda Accords but only a handful of Subaru WRXs, they price the WRX higher to account for uncertainty. The same logic applies to older or discontinued models — a 1990 Nissan Skyline GT-R, for example, is nearly impossible to find parts for in the United States, so insurers either refuse to cover it or charge rates that reflect that risk.
Theft risk plays a role too. Some import models are targeted more often by thieves, either for parts or for export. If your car is on that list, comprehensive coverage (which covers theft) will cost more. Ask your insurer whether your specific model carries a theft surcharge.
Which Insurers Cover Import Cars
Most major insurers — State Farm, Geico, Progressive, Allstate — will insure common import brands like Honda, Toyota, Nissan, and Hyundai at rates only slightly higher than domestic equivalents. But less common brands, high-performance imports, or older models may be declined or restricted.
Specialty insurers focus on imported vehicles and often offer better rates and fewer restrictions. Companies like Hagerty (which covers classic and collector cars, including imports), Grundy, and some regional carriers understand the repair ecosystem for imports and price accordingly. If you own a modified import, a performance-focused insurer may be your only option for full coverage.
Before you buy an import car, contact insurers and ask whether they cover that specific year, make, and model. A car that is cheap to buy but impossible to insure becomes expensive fast. Some dealers can tell you which insurers they work with most often for that model, which is a useful starting point.
How Modifications Affect Import Car Insurance
Import cars, especially Japanese sports cars and European performance models, are frequently modified. Turbochargers, lowered suspension, body kits, engine tuning, and custom wheels are common. These modifications can void your coverage entirely if you don't disclose them, or they can trigger a rate increase of 10 to 50 percent depending on the change and the insurer.
Some modifications are seen as safety improvements (better brakes, upgraded suspension geometry) and may lower your rate slightly. Others — like engine tuning that increases horsepower — are seen as increasing accident risk and will raise your premium. A few modifications, like removing airbags or disabling safety systems, will cause most insurers to cancel your policy.
The key is honesty. Tell your insurer about every modification before you have a claim. If you modify the car after you buy it, contact your insurer and ask them to update your policy. If you don't disclose and then file a claim, the insurer may deny it based on the undisclosed modification.
Import Cars and Salvage Titles
Imported vehicles sometimes arrive in the United States with salvage titles or branded titles (titles that indicate the car was previously damaged, flooded, or declared a total loss). Some insurers will not cover a car with a salvage title at all. Others will cover it but at a much higher rate, or they will refuse to offer collision or comprehensive coverage — only liability.
If you are buying an import with a branded title, check with insurers before you complete the purchase. A car that is cheap because of its title may be uninsurable or so expensive to insure that the savings disappear. Ask the seller for the vehicle history report (Carfax or AutoCheck) and bring it to your insurer's office to discuss coverage options.
Comparing Quotes for Import Cars
Because rates vary widely for imports, getting multiple quotes is essential. Contact at least three insurers — one major carrier, one specialty insurer if your car qualifies, and one regional carrier. Provide the exact year, make, model, trim level, and any modifications. Small differences in how you describe the car can change the quote significantly.
When you compare quotes, make sure the coverage limits are the same across all three. A quote with lower liability limits will look cheaper but leave you underprotected. Most states require a minimum of 25/50/25 (25,000 dollars bodily injury per person, 50,000 dollars per accident, 25,000 dollars property damage), but many insurers recommend 100/300/100 or higher, especially for an expensive import.
Ask each insurer about discounts. Multi-policy bundling, good driver discounts, and safety feature discounts (anti-theft devices, backup cameras) can reduce your rate by 10 to 25 percent. Some insurers offer discounts for completing a defensive driving course, which may be worth the time for an import owner.
What to Do If You Can't Find Coverage
If mainstream insurers decline your import car, you have a few options. First, contact specialty insurers that focus on imported, classic, or performance vehicles. Second, ask your state's insurance commissioner's office about the assigned risk pool (also called the insurer of last resort). This is a program that requires insurers to cover drivers who cannot find coverage elsewhere, though the rates are typically higher and coverage may be limited.
Third, consider whether modifications or the car's condition are the barrier. If you own a heavily modified import, removing or reversing some modifications may make you insurable at a mainstream carrier. If the car has a salvage title or serious damage history, some insurers will cover it if you agree to a higher deductible or accept liability-only coverage.
Finally, talk to an independent insurance agent who represents multiple carriers. Agents have relationships with insurers and sometimes can negotiate coverage for vehicles that the insurer's website says they won't cover. It costs nothing to ask.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my insurance be cheaper if I buy a domestic car instead of an import?
Usually, yes — but it depends on the specific models you are comparing. A Toyota Camry and a Honda Accord (both imports) cost about the same to insure as a Ford Fusion or Chevy Malibu (both domestic). But a Porsche 911 will always cost more than a Dodge Charger, regardless of where it was built. Compare quotes for the exact cars you are considering before you decide.
Do I need special insurance for a car I imported myself?
No — once the car is registered in your state, it is insured like any other vehicle. But you will need to provide proof of ownership and a title. If the car came from overseas, you may need to provide customs documentation or an import inspection report. Contact your insurer before you bring the car home to confirm what paperwork they need.
What happens if I modify my import car after I buy the insurance?
Contact your insurer when ready and tell them about the modification. They will either approve it (and possibly adjust your rate), require you to remove it, or cancel your policy. If you have a claim and the modification was not disclosed, the insurer may deny the claim entirely, so do not wait.
Can I insure an import car that is not yet registered in the United States?
No — you need a valid U.S. registration and title before an insurer will cover the car. If you are importing a vehicle, complete the customs and EPA import process first, register it with your state's DMV, and then contact insurers. Some insurers will provide temporary coverage while you complete registration, but you must ask before you drive the car.
Are import cars more likely to be stolen?
Some are. Japanese sports cars and luxury European models are targeted more often than mainstream domestic vehicles, either for parts or for export. If theft is a concern for your model, ask your insurer about the theft rate and whether comprehensive coverage (which covers theft) is worth the cost. Installing a visible anti-theft device may lower your comprehensive premium.