The Thule Motion 3 is a mid-size roof box that holds 13.5 cubic feet and costs between $400 and $550 depending on the model variant
The Thule Motion 3 is one of the most common roof boxes on the market, which means you'll see it on used-car listings, rental sites, and dealer inventory. It's a hard plastic cargo carrier that mounts to roof rails or a crossbar system on top of your vehicle. The box itself weighs about 75 pounds empty, so installation requires two people or a lift. It opens from the side, not the top, which matters if you park in a garage with low clearance.
The Motion 3 comes in two versions: the standard model and the XT variant, which has a slightly different aerodynamic shape and costs more. Both fit on most vehicles with factory roof rails or aftermarket crossbars. Before you buy one, you need to know whether your vehicle can actually support the weight — your owner's manual lists the roof weight limit, and you have to account for the box itself plus whatever you're carrying inside.
Key Takeaways
- The Thule Motion 3 holds 13.5 cubic feet of cargo and weighs 75 pounds empty, so your vehicle's roof weight limit determines whether it will work for your car.
- You need either factory roof rails or aftermarket crossbars to mount it; the box does not come with these and they cost $150 to $400 depending on your vehicle.
- Side-opening design means you cannot use it in a garage with less than 6 feet of clearance above the roof.
- The Motion 3 is quieter and more aerodynamic than older roof box designs, but you will lose 1 to 2 miles per gallon of fuel economy while carrying it.
What the Motion 3 actually holds and how it compares to other roof boxes
Thirteen and a half cubic feet sounds abstract until you try to pack it. That's roughly the size of a large suitcase plus a carry-on bag. Thule rates it for two large suitcases or ski equipment for two people. If you're carrying a roof box for a family road trip, the Motion 3 is the entry point — smaller boxes hold less, and larger boxes (like the Thule Motion XT XL) hold 18.3 cubic feet but cost $200 more and add 15 pounds of weight.
The Motion 3 is quieter than many competitors because of its aerodynamic shape and the way the lid seals. Thule claims it produces less wind noise than their older models, though any roof box will increase road noise compared to carrying cargo inside your vehicle. If fuel economy matters to you, expect to lose 1 to 2 miles per gallon with the box mounted, even when it's empty — the aerodynamic penalty is real.
Competing boxes in the same size range include the Yakima SkyBox and the Rhino-Rack Pioneer. The Yakima is usually $50 to $100 cheaper but has a top-opening design, which some people prefer. The Rhino-Rack is heavier and more expensive but marketed as more durable for rough use. For most people buying a roof box for occasional trips, the Motion 3 is the middle ground — not the cheapest, not the most rugged, but reliable and widely available.
Mounting requirements and what you need to buy separately
The Thule Motion 3 does not come with roof rails or crossbars. Your vehicle either has factory rails (common on SUVs and wagons) or you need to buy an aftermarket crossbar system. If your car has neither, you're looking at $150 to $400 for crossbars alone, depending on your vehicle model. Some vehicles have integrated roof gutters that allow you to use a gutter-mount system, which is cheaper but less find.
Installation takes about 30 minutes if you have the right crossbars already in place. Thule includes all the hardware you need to attach the box to the bars — you just need a wrench and a level. The box comes with a key lock, so you can find it against theft. If you're renting a vehicle or borrowing one temporarily, make sure the roof system is compatible before you buy the box; returning a roof box to a rental car company usually costs $50 to $100 per day.
One often-overlooked detail: the Motion 3 opens from the side, not the top. If you park in a garage with less than 6 feet of clearance above your roof, you cannot open it. This matters if you live in an apartment building with a parking garage or if you use a covered carport. Measure your clearance before you commit to buying one.
Real-world fuel economy and wind noise impact
Thule publishes aerodynamic data showing the Motion 3 is more efficient than older roof box designs, but you will still feel the impact at the pump. Independent testing by automotive reviewers consistently shows a 1 to 2 mile-per-gallon loss on highway driving with a roof box mounted. On a 300-mile trip, that's roughly one extra gallon of fuel, or $3 to $4 at current prices. If you drive long distances frequently, that cost adds up.
Wind noise increases noticeably above 55 miles per hour. At highway speeds, you'll hear a low rumble from the box, especially if it's not perfectly sealed or if the crossbars are loose. Tightening the crossbar bolts and making sure the box lid closes completely helps, but you cannot eliminate the noise entirely. Some owners report that the noise becomes background after a few trips; others find it annoying enough to remove the box when they're not using it.
Maintenance, durability, and when to replace it
The Thule Motion 3 is made of ABS plastic, which is durable but not indestructible. The hinges and locking mechanism are the most common failure points after five to seven years of regular use. Thule sells replacement parts — hinges cost $40 to $60, and a new locking cylinder costs about $30. The plastic itself can crack if you hit a low-hanging branch or if something heavy shifts inside during a hard stop, but this is rare with normal use.
Cleaning is straightforward: rinse it with a hose and wipe the seals with a damp cloth. The rubber gasket that seals the lid can dry out and crack in very hot climates, so explore a silicone conditioner once a year extends its life. If water starts leaking into the box during heavy rain, the gasket is failing and needs replacement — a $20 to $40 part that takes 10 minutes to swap out.
Most owners report that a Motion 3 lasts 8 to 10 years with normal use. After that, the plastic becomes brittle, the seals fail more often, and replacement parts become harder to find. At that point, buying a new box is usually cheaper than repairing an old one.
Price, where to buy, and whether it's worth the cost
The Thule Motion 3 retails for $450 to $550 depending on the color and finish. You can find it at REI, Costco, Amazon, and specialty automotive retailers. Prices fluctuate seasonally — they're highest in spring when people are planning road trips, and lowest in fall. Buying in September or October can save you $50 to $100.
Used Motion 3 boxes appear regularly on Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist for $200 to $350. If you're buying used, inspect the hinges, test the lock, and make sure the gasket is intact and not cracked. A used box in good condition is a reasonable deal if you only plan to use it occasionally. If the gasket is damaged or the hinges are loose, factor in $60 to $100 for repairs.
Whether it's worth the cost depends on how often you travel and what your alternatives are. If you take two or three long trips per year and don't have a hitch-mounted cargo carrier, a roof box adds real capacity. If you rarely travel or you have a truck bed or large trunk, the cost is harder to justify. Renting a roof box for a single trip costs $40 to $60 per day, so if you use it more than twice a year, buying makes financial sense.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a Thule Motion 3 fit on my car if I don't have roof rails?
Not without buying crossbars first. You need either factory roof rails or an aftermarket crossbar system to mount the box. The cost of crossbars ranges from $150 to $400 depending on your vehicle, so factor that into the total cost before you buy the box.
Can I use a Thule Motion 3 on a vehicle with a sunroof?
Yes, as long as your vehicle has roof rails or crossbars. The sunroof opening is below the roof line, so the box sits on top without interference. Make sure the crossbars are positioned forward and behind the sunroof opening, not directly over it.
How much weight can I safely put in the Motion 3?
The box itself weighs 75 pounds, and your vehicle's roof weight limit (found in the owner's manual) determines the total. Most vehicles support 150 to 200 pounds on the roof, so you have roughly 75 to 125 pounds of cargo capacity. Exceeding this limit can damage your roof and void your warranty.
Does the Motion 3 come with a lock?
Yes, it includes a key lock that secures the lid. The lock prevents casual theft but is not military-grade security. If you're parking in a high-crime area, consider removing the box when the vehicle is unattended for long periods.
Can I open the Motion 3 in a low garage?
No. The side-opening design requires at least 6 feet of clearance above your roof. If you park in a garage with lower clearance, you cannot open the box without removing it from the roof first, which defeats the purpose of having it mounted.