The Dieselgate scandal and what it changed
Volkswagen installed software in millions of diesel vehicles worldwide that detected when the car was being tested for emissions and switched the engine into a low-emissions mode. During normal driving, the engine ran in a higher-emissions mode that produced up to 40 times the legal limit of nitrogen oxides. The company admitted to this in September 2015, and the discovery triggered recalls, lawsuits, buyback programs, and permanent changes to how Volkswagen vehicles are built and tested.
If you own a Volkswagen diesel from 2009 to 2015, this scandal directly affects your car's value, your maintenance obligations, and what you can legally do with it. If you own a newer Volkswagen—diesel or petrol—the scandal changed the engineering and testing standards your car was built to meet. Understanding what happened and what it means for your specific vehicle helps you make informed decisions about repairs, resale, and long-term ownership.
Key Takeaways
- Volkswagen diesel vehicles from 2009 to 2015 were equipped with defeat devices that reduced emissions during testing but not during normal driving, violating U.S. and European environmental law.
- Owners of affected vehicles were offered buyback programs, lease termination, or engine software updates and hardware repairs, depending on the model and market.
- Emissions control systems on all Volkswagen vehicles now undergo more rigorous testing, and the company faces ongoing regulatory oversight in multiple countries.
- Maintenance of emissions equipment—catalytic converters, diesel particulate filters, and exhaust gas recirculation systems—is now more critical and more expensive if repairs are needed.
- Resale value of affected Volkswagen diesels dropped significantly and has not fully recovered, even after repairs or buybacks.
Which Volkswagen models were affected
The scandal involved Volkswagen and Audi diesel vehicles sold in the United States, Europe, and other markets. In the U.S., the affected models included the VW Jetta, Golf, Passat, and Beetle with 2.0-litre diesel engines, plus the Audi A3 with the same engine. Model years 2009 to 2015 were the primary range, though some 2016 models were also caught up in later investigations. Volkswagen also sold larger diesel engines in other markets that were later found to have similar software.
Petrol-engine Volkswagens were not part of the original scandal, but the company later admitted that some petrol models also used defeat devices or other emissions-cheating software. If you own a Volkswagen diesel from the affected years, you can check whether your specific vehicle is on the recall list by entering your Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) on the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) website or your country's equivalent regulatory body.
Buyback, trade-in, and repair options for owners
Volkswagen offered three main paths for U.S. owners of affected vehicles: a full buyback at a price set by an independent appraiser, lease termination with no penalties, or a free software update combined with hardware repairs. The buyback program ran from 2016 onwards, and the company purchased hundreds of thousands of vehicles. Owners who chose buyback received the vehicle's pre-scandal market value, though that value was lower than it would have been without the scandal.
Owners who kept their vehicles received a software update that reduced engine performance and fuel economy slightly but brought emissions into legal range. Some models also received hardware upgrades, such as improved catalytic converters or diesel particulate filters. These repairs were performed free of charge at Volkswagen dealerships. In Europe, the remedies varied by country and were often less generous than the U.S. program, with some owners receiving only software updates and no buyback option.
If you own an affected vehicle today, the buyback window has largely closed in most markets, though some regional programs may still be active. Check with your local Volkswagen dealer or your country's environmental regulator to confirm whether your vehicle is still covered by any remedy program.
How emissions control systems work and why they matter
A diesel engine produces nitrogen oxides (NOx) as a byproduct of combustion. To meet legal limits, Volkswagen vehicles use an exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) system that routes some exhaust back into the engine to cool combustion and reduce NOx formation. They also use selective catalytic reduction (SCR), which injects a urea-based fluid called diesel exhaust fluid (DEF) into the exhaust stream to convert NOx into harmless nitrogen and water.
These systems work, but they reduce engine performance and fuel economy. The defeat device allowed Volkswagen to disable or reduce the effectiveness of these systems during normal driving, improving performance and economy while keeping emissions low only during the standardised test cycle. The result was a car that felt more powerful and efficient than competitors but was actually polluting far more on the road.
Modern Volkswagen vehicles, and all new cars sold in regulated markets, now undergo real-world driving emissions (RDE) testing in addition to laboratory testing. This means the car is driven on public roads with portable emissions-testing equipment, making it much harder to cheat. Volkswagen's newer vehicles are also subject to more frequent audits and stricter penalties for violations.
Maintenance costs and long-term reliability of affected vehicles
Owners who kept their repaired Volkswagen diesels often report higher maintenance costs than they expected. The diesel particulate filter (DPF) and catalytic converter are expensive to replace if they fail—typically £800 to £2,000 or more depending on the model and region. The software update and hardware repairs performed under the recall program were designed to last the life of the vehicle, but some owners have experienced premature failures of these components.
The urea system (SCR) also requires regular refilling of diesel exhaust fluid, which costs money and requires access to a dealer or specialist. If the DEF tank fails or the injection system malfunctions, repairs are costly and often require dealer service. Some owners have reported that their repaired vehicles consume more fuel and produce less power than before the scandal, which affects the total cost of ownership over time.
Long-term reliability data for repaired vehicles is still being gathered, but early reports suggest that vehicles with the repair package have not experienced significantly higher failure rates than unaffected models. However, the emissions control systems themselves are more complex and more expensive to repair than older systems, so budget accordingly if you own one of these vehicles.
Resale value and market impact
The scandal permanently reduced the resale value of affected Volkswagen diesels. A vehicle that might have been worth £12,000 before the scandal was worth £6,000 to £8,000 after the news broke, even if it had been repaired. Some of this value loss reflects the cost of repairs and the reduced performance after the software update, but much of it reflects buyer distrust and the stigma attached to the scandal.
Vehicles that were bought back by Volkswagen were supposed to be scrapped or exported, but some ended up being resold in secondary markets, further complicating the market. Owners who kept their vehicles and later tried to sell them often found that buyers were reluctant to purchase a car known to have been cheating on emissions tests, regardless of whether it had been repaired.
If you are considering buying a used Volkswagen diesel from the affected years, expect to pay significantly less than a comparable petrol model or a diesel from a different manufacturer. The lower price reflects the scandal's impact, but it also means you are taking on the risk of expensive repairs to emissions equipment and the uncertainty of resale value.
Regulatory changes and what they mean for new Volkswagens
The scandal prompted governments worldwide to tighten emissions testing and oversight. The EPA and European regulators now conduct unannounced audits of manufacturers' testing facilities and require real-world emissions data before vehicles are approved for sale. Volkswagen was fined billions of dollars across multiple jurisdictions and placed under enhanced monitoring by regulators.
Volkswagen's newer vehicles are engineered to meet these stricter standards without defeat devices. The company has also invested heavily in electric vehicles as a way to move away from diesel engines entirely, which were the focus of the scandal. If you buy a new Volkswagen today, it has been tested under more rigorous conditions than vehicles before 2015, and the company faces severe penalties if it is caught cheating again.
However, the scandal also revealed that other manufacturers had used similar tactics. Regulators now scrutinise all diesel vehicles more closely, and the cost of compliance has risen for the entire industry. This has contributed to the decline of diesel engines in passenger cars, as manufacturers have found it cheaper to invest in petrol engines and electric powertrains.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my Volkswagen is affected by the scandal?
Check your Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) on the EPA website (in the U.S.) or your country's environmental regulator. You can also contact a Volkswagen dealer with your VIN, and they will tell you whether your vehicle is on the recall list and what remedies are available.
Should I buy a used Volkswagen diesel from 2009 to 2015?
Only if the price reflects the scandal's impact and you are comfortable with the risk of expensive emissions repairs. Have a pre-purchase inspection performed by an independent mechanic who specialises in diesel engines, and ask specifically about the condition of the DPF, catalytic converter, and SCR system. Budget for potential repairs.
What happens if I don't maintain the emissions equipment on my repaired Volkswagen?
If the emissions equipment fails and is not repaired, your vehicle will likely fail emissions testing and may not pass roadworthiness inspections in your country. In some places, you cannot legally drive a vehicle that does not meet emissions standards. Repairs are expensive, so preventive maintenance—regular servicing and DEF top-ups—is cheaper than waiting for failure.
Can I remove or disable the emissions equipment after the recall repair?
No. Removing or disabling emissions equipment is illegal in most countries and can result in fines, vehicle impoundment, and criminal charges. It also voids your warranty and makes the vehicle unsellable in regulated markets. The repair package was designed to meet legal standards while maintaining drivability.
Are newer Volkswagen diesels safe from another scandal?
Newer Volkswagen diesels are subject to much stricter testing and oversight than pre-2015 models, and the company faces severe penalties if caught cheating again. However, no manufacturer is immune to regulatory violations. Real-world emissions testing and unannounced audits make large-scale cheating much harder than it was before 2015.