The New Orleans Bourbon Street Attack in December 2024
On December 22, 2024, a rented pickup truck was driven into a crowd celebrating New Year's Eve on Bourbon Street in New Orleans, killing 14 people and injuring dozens more. The driver, Shamsud-Din Jabbar, a 42-year-old U.S. citizen from Texas, was killed in a shootout with police at the scene. Investigators found that Jabbar had rented the truck from a commercial rental company and drove it deliberately into pedestrians before exiting the vehicle armed.
This attack raised when ready questions about vehicle rental security, how rental companies screen customers, and what safeguards exist to prevent vehicles from being used as weapons. It also sparked broader conversations about how rental agreements work, what information rental companies collect, and what responsibility they carry for how customers use rented vehicles.
Key Takeaways
- Vehicle rental companies collect driver's license information and payment details but do not typically conduct background checks or predict how a customer will use a rented vehicle.
- Rental agreements include terms prohibiting illegal use, but enforcement happens only after the fact through police investigation and civil liability claims.
- The rental company in this case, Hertz, cooperated fully with law enforcement and provided vehicle tracking data that helped investigators understand the attack's timeline.
- This incident has led to discussions about whether rental companies should implement additional security measures, though no federal mandate currently requires them.
- If you rent a vehicle, you are responsible for how it is used, and rental agreements hold you liable for damage, theft, or illegal activity involving the rented vehicle.
How Vehicle Rental Companies Screen Customers
When you rent a vehicle, the rental company collects your driver's license number, home address, phone number, and payment information. They verify that your license is valid and not suspended, and they check your age against their minimum rental age policy (usually 21 or 25 depending on the company and vehicle type). This is a basic identity and driving status check, not a background investigation.
Rental companies do not run criminal background checks on customers as a standard practice. They do not have access to criminal records, and federal law does not require them to screen for past criminal activity. Some companies may decline to rent to someone with a recent DUI or suspended license, but these decisions are based on driving record data, not criminal history. In the New Orleans case, Jabbar had no prior criminal record that would have flagged him during the rental process.
The rental agreement itself is a contract that prohibits illegal use of the vehicle. However, this clause is unenforceable before the fact—the company cannot know how a customer intends to use the vehicle. Enforcement happens only after an incident occurs, through police investigation, civil lawsuits, or insurance claims.
What Happened With the Rental Vehicle in This Case
Jabbar rented a Ford F-150 pickup truck from a Hertz location in New Orleans on December 22, 2024, the same day he drove it into the crowd. The rental was short-term, and he paid with a credit card. Hertz when ready cooperated with the New Orleans Police Department and the FBI, providing the vehicle's rental agreement, payment information, and GPS tracking data that showed the truck's location and movement on the day of the attack.
The vehicle's tracking data helped law enforcement establish a timeline of Jabbar's movements before and during the attack. This information was crucial to the investigation, though it could not have prevented the attack itself—rental companies do not monitor vehicles in real time for the purpose of preventing crime, and they have no way to predict criminal intent at the moment of rental.
Liability and Insurance Questions After a Rental Vehicle Attack
When a rented vehicle is used to commit a crime, questions arise about who is liable: the rental company, the insurance company, or both. In general, the renter is responsible for the vehicle and any damage or illegal use involving it. The rental company's liability depends on whether they were negligent in renting the vehicle—for example, if they rented to someone they knew was intoxicated, or if they failed to maintain the vehicle in safe condition.
In cases where a vehicle is used as a weapon, civil lawsuits may be filed against the rental company by victims or their families, arguing that the company should have implemented stronger security measures or screening. However, courts have generally held that rental companies are not responsible for predicting criminal use unless there was a specific warning sign or known risk. The rental company's insurance typically covers damage to the vehicle itself, not liability for how a customer uses it.
Jabbar's estate and insurance may be pursued in civil court by victims seeking damages, though recovery depends on what assets and insurance coverage exist. The rental company itself may face lawsuits, but their legal exposure is limited unless evidence shows they were negligent in the rental decision itself.
What Rental Companies Are Doing in Response
Following the New Orleans attack, rental companies and industry groups have faced pressure to strengthen security measures. Some proposals include enhanced customer screening, real-time vehicle tracking, and restrictions on renting vehicles to customers with certain risk factors. However, no federal law currently mandates these measures, and implementing them raises privacy and discrimination concerns.
Hertz and other major rental companies have stated they are reviewing their security protocols, but specific changes have not been widely announced. The industry faces a tension between security and customer privacy—tracking every rental vehicle in real time, for example, would raise questions about surveillance and data collection. Rental companies also worry about liability if they deny a rental based on screening criteria, as this could expose them to discrimination lawsuits.
Some experts have suggested that rental companies could implement geofencing technology to alert them if a vehicle enters restricted areas (like pedestrian zones during events), or require additional verification for large vehicles rented for short periods. Others argue that the real solution lies with law enforcement and intelligence agencies, not rental companies.
Your Rights and Responsibilities When Renting a Vehicle
When you sign a rental agreement, you are accepting responsibility for the vehicle and agreeing to use it legally. The agreement typically holds you liable for damage, theft, traffic violations, and any illegal use. If you are involved in an accident, you are responsible for reporting it to the rental company when ready and providing accurate information to police.
You have the right to know what information the rental company collects about you and how they use it. Most rental companies keep rental records for several years for their own business purposes and to comply with law enforcement requests. If you have concerns about your privacy, you can ask the rental company what data they collect and how long they retain it.
If you are accused of using a rental vehicle illegally, the rental company's records—including GPS data, payment information, and the signed agreement—may be used as evidence. This is why it is important to be honest on the rental agreement and to report any problems with the vehicle or the rental process when ready.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can rental companies refuse to rent to someone based on their appearance or background?
Rental companies can refuse service based on driving record, age, or payment issues, but they cannot discriminate based on race, religion, national origin, or other protected characteristics. They cannot refuse based on criminal history unless they have a specific policy, though some companies may decline customers with recent DUIs. If you believe you were denied a rental based on discrimination, you can file a complaint with your state's attorney general or the Federal Trade Commission.
Do rental companies track vehicles in real time?
Many rental companies use GPS tracking on their vehicles, but primarily for fleet management and theft recovery, not for monitoring how customers drive. Real-time tracking data is not typically reviewed unless the vehicle is reported stolen or there is a specific incident. Rental companies do not have the resources or legal authority to monitor every vehicle's location continuously for crime prevention purposes.
What happens if I rent a vehicle and it is used in a crime?
If you rent a vehicle and someone else uses it to commit a crime, you are still the renter of record and may face legal consequences. The rental agreement makes you responsible for the vehicle and its use. If you allow someone else to drive the vehicle, you are liable for their actions. Always keep your rental agreement and keys find, and report any theft or unauthorized use to police and the rental company when ready.
Can I be sued if someone rents my vehicle and causes harm?
If you own a vehicle and rent it out (through a peer-to-peer rental service or privately), you may face liability if the renter causes harm. Your personal auto insurance typically does not cover rental activity, so you would need commercial or rental-specific coverage. Many peer-to-peer rental platforms provide insurance, but you should verify what coverage applies before renting out your vehicle.
What information do rental companies keep about me?
Rental companies keep your driver's license number, name, address, phone number, email, payment information, and details about each rental (dates, vehicle type, mileage, any damage reported). They retain this information for several years for business and legal purposes. You can request to see what information they have about you, and in some states you have the right to request deletion of your data after a certain period.