Where to get a replacement key depends on your car's age and what broke
You have three main routes: a dealership, a locksmith, or a big-box retailer like Home Depot. Which one works depends on whether you need a basic metal key, a key fob that unlocks the car remotely, or a key with a chip inside that talks to your car's computer. Dealerships charge the most but handle every type. Locksmiths are usually cheaper and faster for older cars. Big-box stores cut straightforward keys on the spot but cannot program fobs or chip keys.
The year your car was made matters a lot. Cars made before 2000 usually have straightforward keys with no electronics — a locksmith or hardware store can replace these in minutes for $5 to $15. Cars from 2000 onward often have fobs or chip keys that need programming, which costs more and takes longer no matter where you go.
Key Takeaways
- Dealerships can replace any type of key but typically charge $200 to $500 for fobs or chip keys, plus the cost of the key itself.
- Locksmiths usually cost 30 to 50 percent less than dealerships and can handle most cars, but some newer models require dealer-only programming.
- Home Depot and Ace Hardware cut basic metal keys for $2 to $10 but cannot program fobs or chip keys.
- You will need your car's VIN (on your registration or dashboard) and proof of ownership to order a replacement from a dealership.
- If you are locked out and need a key when ready, a mobile locksmith can come to you, though the cost is higher than visiting a shop.
Dealership replacement: highest cost, widest capability
A dealership can replace any key your car uses, from a straightforward metal key to a fob with multiple buttons to a key card. They have your car's exact specifications on file and can program the new key to your specific vehicle. This is the only route that works for every car, including luxury brands and newer models with advanced security systems.
The trade-off is cost and time. A dealership typically charges $150 to $300 just for labor, then adds the cost of the key itself — $50 to $200 depending on the type. A full fob replacement can run $200 to $500 total. You will need your VIN and proof of ownership (registration or title). Most dealerships order the key and have it ready in one to three business days, though some can program it same-day if they stock the part.
Call ahead and ask whether they stock the key or need to order it. Some dealerships will not replace a key without an appointment, and some require you to bring the car in for programming. A few will mail you a key if you provide your VIN and proof of ownership by phone or email.
Locksmith replacement: faster and cheaper for most cars
A licensed locksmith can cut and program keys for most vehicles at 30 to 50 percent less than a dealership. A basic key costs $10 to $25, and a fob or chip key runs $75 to $200 total. Many locksmiths offer mobile service — they come to your car and cut or program the key on-site, which is useful if you are locked out or stranded.
The limitation is that some newer cars, especially luxury brands like BMW, Mercedes, and Tesla, use encryption or security systems that only the dealership can access. Before you call a locksmith, ask whether they can handle your specific make and model. A reputable locksmith will tell you upfront if your car requires a dealership.
Find a locksmith through your insurance company (many roadside information plans cover locksmith calls), your car manufacturer's roadside information program, or a local search. Avoid locksmiths who quote prices over the phone without asking your car's year, make, and model — that is a sign they may not know what they are doing. Ask for their license number and verify it with your state's licensing board if you are unsure.
Hardware store key cutting: only for basic metal keys
Home Depot, Ace Hardware, Lowe's, and similar stores cut basic metal keys while you wait for $2 to $10. This works only if your car uses a straightforward key with no electronics — typically cars made before 2000. You bring your original key, they scan it or match it by eye, and cut a new one in minutes.
This route does not work for fobs, key cards, or keys with chips. If your key has a plastic head with buttons, or if your car unlocks when you press a button on your keychain, a hardware store cannot help. They also cannot program a key to your car's computer, so even if they cut the right shape, it will not start the engine on newer vehicles.
What to do if you are locked out and need a key now
If you need a key when ready and cannot wait for a dealership order, a mobile locksmith is your fastest option. They arrive at your location and cut or program a key on-site, usually within 30 minutes to an hour. The cost is higher — typically $100 to $300 depending on your car and location — because you are paying for the trip and the urgency.
Call your roadside information program first. Most insurance companies and car manufacturers (Ford, GM, Toyota, etc.) offer roadside information that covers locksmith calls. AAA members also get locksmith coverage. If you have coverage, your out-of-pocket cost may be just a small deductible or nothing at all.
If you do not have roadside information, search for "mobile locksmith near me" or "24-hour locksmith [your city]." Ask for a quote before they arrive, and confirm they can handle your specific car. Some mobile locksmiths work only on older vehicles and cannot program chip keys.
Documents and information you will need
No matter which route you choose, have these items ready: your car's VIN (found on your registration, insurance card, or the dashboard on the driver's side), your proof of ownership (registration or title), and your driver's license. Some dealerships and locksmiths will ask for your car's year, make, model, and trim level to confirm the key type.
If you are ordering from a dealership by phone or online, you may need to provide a photo of your registration and driver's license. Locksmiths typically just need your VIN and a photo ID in person. Hardware stores need only your original key to match against.
Comparing cost and time across all three routes
| Route | Basic Key Cost | Fob/Chip Key Cost | Time to Get Key | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dealership | $50–$150 | $200–$500 | 1–3 days (or same-day) | Newer cars, luxury brands, any key type |
| Locksmith | $10–$25 | $75–$200 | Same day (mobile available) | Older cars, budget-conscious, locked out |
| Hardware Store | $2–$10 | Not available | 15–30 minutes | Basic keys only, pre-2000 cars |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I program a key myself, or do I have to pay someone?
Most cars made after 2000 require professional programming with specialized equipment. A few older models and some Toyotas allow you to program a key by turning the ignition on and off in a specific sequence, but this is rare. Check your owner's manual or call a locksmith to ask whether your car supports self-programming before you buy a key.
What if I lost both my keys?
You can still get a replacement, but it costs more because the locksmith or dealership has to reprogram your car's security system. A dealership typically charges an extra $100 to $200 for this. A locksmith may charge similarly or may refer you to a dealership if your car's security system is too advanced. Bring your proof of ownership and VIN.
Will my car insurance cover the cost of a replacement key?
Standard car insurance does not cover lost or broken keys. However, roadside information coverage (often bundled with insurance or available as an add-on) covers locksmith calls. Check your policy or call your insurance company to see whether you have this coverage and what the deductible is.
How long does it take to program a new key?
Programming usually takes 15 to 30 minutes once the locksmith or dealership has the key in hand. If they need to order the key first, add one to three business days. Mobile locksmiths can program on-site, so the total time is just the programming time plus their travel time.
Can a locksmith program a key for a car I just bought used?
Yes, but you will need proof of ownership (title or registration in your name). Some locksmiths may ask for a bill of sale or other documentation if the title transfer is very recent. Call ahead and ask what documents they need before you visit.