Where to get a replacement key depends on your car's age and whether you need just a physical key or a programmed fob

You have three main routes: a dealership, a locksmith, or a big-box retailer like Home Depot or Ace Hardware. A dealership can make any key your car needs, including programmed fobs and transponder keys, but charges the most — typically $200 to $500 for a fob, $100 to $200 for a basic key. A locksmith costs less (usually $50 to $150 for a basic key, $100 to $300 for a fob) and comes to you, but not all locksmiths can program every car model. A hardware store can cut a basic key for $5 to $15 but cannot program fobs or transponder keys.

The right choice depends on what your car actually needs. If you drive a 1990s car with a straightforward metal key, any locksmith or hardware store works. If you have a modern car with a key fob or push-button start, you need either a dealership or a locksmith who specializes in your car's brand. Before you call anyone, check your owner's manual or search your car's year, make, and model online to find out whether your key is programmable and what type it is.

Key Takeaways

  • Dealerships charge the most but can program any key your car needs, while locksmiths are cheaper and often come to you, but not all can handle every car model.
  • Basic metal keys cost $5 to $15 at a hardware store, but fobs and transponder keys require a locksmith or dealership and cost $100 to $500.
  • You will need proof of ownership (title, registration, or insurance card) at a dealership, but a locksmith may only need your ID and proof you own the car.
  • If you are locked out and need a key when ready, a locksmith is usually faster than a dealership, which may require an appointment days ahead.
  • Some newer cars allow you to program a spare key yourself using a sequence of button presses, so check your manual before paying for programming.

What information and documents you need to bring

At a dealership, bring your vehicle title, current registration, or insurance card — anything that proves you own the car. The dealership will not make a key without proof of ownership because they need to verify you are not trying to make a key for a stolen vehicle. Bring your driver's license as well. Some dealerships also want the vehicle identification number (VIN), which is on your registration or visible on the dashboard at the base of the windshield on the driver's side.

At a locksmith, bring your ID and the same proof of ownership. Many locksmiths are more flexible than dealerships and will make a key if you can show you own the car, even if your documents are not perfect. If you are locked out of your car and do not have your registration with you, call ahead and ask whether the locksmith will come anyway — many will, especially if you can show them your ID and describe the car accurately.

At a hardware store, you typically need nothing except the old key or a photo of it, since they are only cutting a blank and not programming anything. However, if the key is worn or damaged, bring the car itself so they can test the fit.

The difference between a basic key, a transponder key, and a key fob

A basic key is a straightforward metal key with no electronics. It opens the door and turns the ignition. Any hardware store or locksmith can cut one for $5 to $15. Most cars made before 2000 use basic keys, and some newer cars still have them as a backup.

A transponder key has a computer chip inside the plastic head that communicates with your car's ignition system. The car will not start if the chip is not present or not programmed to that vehicle. Cutting the physical key is cheap, but programming the chip costs $75 to $250. Only a dealership or a locksmith with the right equipment can program it. Most cars made after 1995 have transponder keys.

A key fob is a remote control that locks and unlocks the car from a distance and may also open the trunk or set up panic mode. It contains a transponder chip and costs $100 to $500 to replace, depending on the car. Some fobs are separate from the physical key; others are built into it. A dealership can always program a fob, but a locksmith may not have the equipment for every brand.

If you are not sure which type your car uses, check your owner's manual or search your car's year, make, and model plus "key type" online. You can also call a locksmith and describe your key — they can usually tell you what you need over the phone.

How long it takes to get a replacement key

A hardware store can cut a basic key while you wait, usually in 5 to 15 minutes. A locksmith can cut and program a transponder key or fob in 30 minutes to an hour if they have the right equipment and you are at their shop; if they come to you, add 15 to 30 minutes for travel time. A dealership typically requires an appointment and may take several days, though some dealerships offer same-day service if you arrive early in the morning.

If you are locked out and need a key when ready, a mobile locksmith is your fastest option — they come to you and can usually arrive within an hour in urban areas, though rural areas may take longer. A dealership will not help you if you are locked out unless you can prove ownership, which is difficult when your keys are inside the car. In that situation, call a locksmith first.

What it costs at each type of provider

Costs vary widely by location, car brand, and key type. Here is what you can expect:

ProviderBasic KeyTransponder KeyKey Fob
Hardware Store$5–$15Cannot programCannot program
Locksmith$50–$150$100–$250$100–$300
Dealership$100–$200$150–$300$200–$500

Dealerships are most expensive because they use factory parts and have higher overhead. Locksmiths are cheaper because they use aftermarket blanks and have lower costs. Hardware stores are cheapest but only work for basic keys. Some locksmiths charge extra for mobile service (coming to your car), usually $50 to $100 on top of the key cost. Ask for a quote over the phone before committing, and ask whether the price includes programming if you need it.

If you need multiple spare keys, ask about a discount. Some locksmiths will cut a second key for half price if you order it at the same time as the first. Dealerships rarely discount, but it is worth asking.

Whether you can program a spare key yourself

Some cars allow you to program a spare key yourself using a sequence of button presses or turns of the ignition. This is most common in Honda, Toyota, Ford, and Nissan vehicles made between 2000 and 2015. The process usually takes 5 to 10 minutes and costs nothing beyond the blank key.

To learn about your car supports self-programming, search your car's year, make, and model plus "self-program spare key" or "DIY key programming" online. You will find step-by-step instructions if it is possible. If your car does not support it, you will need a locksmith or dealership.

Self-programming only works if you already have at least one working key. If both your keys are lost or broken, you must go to a locksmith or dealership.

What to do if you have lost both keys

If you have lost all your keys, you cannot drive the car until you get a replacement, and you cannot self-program a spare because you need a working key to do it. Your only options are a locksmith or a dealership. A locksmith can usually make a new key by reading the locks on your car or by using your VIN to order a blank that matches your car's code. A dealership can do the same but will require proof of ownership.

This situation is more expensive than replacing one lost key because the locksmith or dealership has to verify the car's code without a working key to test against. Expect to pay $150 to $300 at a locksmith or $200 to $500 at a dealership, depending on your car's age and key type.

To prevent this, keep a spare key in a safe place at home — not in the car, not in your wallet, and not with someone you see every day. A spare at home costs $50 to $150 to make and can save you hundreds if you lose your main keys.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a locksmith make a key if I do not have my registration?

Most locksmiths will make a key if you show a driver's license and can describe the car accurately or show them the vehicle. Some require a registration or insurance card, so call ahead and ask. A dealership is stricter and usually requires a title or registration.

How do I know if my key is programmable?

Check your owner's manual or search your car's year, make, and model plus "key type" online. If your key has a plastic head with a chip inside or a fob with buttons, it is programmable. A straightforward metal key is not. You can also call a locksmith and describe your key — they can tell you over the phone.

Is it cheaper to buy a blank key online and have a locksmith program it?

Sometimes, but not always. A blank key costs $10 to $30 online, but you still pay the locksmith's programming fee, which is usually $75 to $150. The total may be the same or higher than buying a key from the locksmith directly. Ask the locksmith whether they will program a key you bring in and what they charge.

What if my car is very old and the locksmith says they cannot program my key?

Older cars with basic keys do not need programming — any locksmith can cut one. If the locksmith says they cannot help, they may be confused about your key type. Call a dealership or a different locksmith who specializes in older vehicles.

Can I get a key made from a photo of my old key?

A hardware store can cut a basic key from a photo, though the fit may not be perfect. A locksmith can usually do better by looking at the actual key or the car's locks. For a transponder key or fob, a photo is not enough — the locksmith needs to program it, which requires the car itself or the car's code.