A battery that won't hold charge usually means the battery itself is failing, but it could also be a charging system problem
When your car battery drains faster than it should—or won't start the car even after a recent charge—the cause is most often a battery that has reached the end of its life. Car batteries typically last three to five years. But the problem could also be your alternator (which recharges the battery while you drive), a parasitic drain (something drawing power when the car is off), or a bad connection at the battery terminals.
The first step is to figure out whether the battery itself is dead or whether something else is preventing it from charging. A battery that holds a charge for weeks but drains in days points to a parasitic drain. A battery that won't hold any charge at all, even right after charging, usually means the battery has failed. A battery that charges fine while driving but dies overnight might be an alternator problem.
Key Takeaways
- A battery that won't hold charge is usually the battery itself failing after three to five years of use, but could also be the alternator, a parasitic drain, or corroded terminals.
- You can test whether the battery is the problem by checking the battery voltage with a multimeter when the car is off and after it has been charged.
- Corroded or loose battery terminals are the easiest fix and should be your first check before replacing anything.
- A parasitic drain (something drawing power when the car is parked) requires a mechanic to locate, but you can narrow it down by checking which fuses control which systems.
- If the alternator is not charging the battery while you drive, the battery will drain no matter how new it is.
Check the battery terminals first
Before you assume the battery is dead, look at the two metal posts on top of the battery where the cables connect. If either post is covered in white, blue, or green corrosion, or if the cable is loose, that is your problem. Corrosion blocks the flow of electricity. A loose cable means the battery is not making good contact with the rest of the car.
To clean corroded terminals, disconnect the negative cable first (the black one), then the positive cable (the red one). Mix baking soda with a small amount of water to make a paste, and scrub the posts and the inside of the cable connectors with an old toothbrush. Rinse with clean water and dry completely. Reconnect the positive cable first, then the negative cable. Tighten both connections by hand until they are snug—do not over-tighten.
If the terminals are clean and tight but the battery still will not hold charge, move to the next step.
Test the battery voltage with a multimeter
A multimeter is an inexpensive tool (usually $15 to $30) that measures electrical voltage. You can borrow one from a friend, rent one from an auto parts store, or buy one to keep. Set it to DC voltage and touch the red probe to the positive battery post and the black probe to the negative post.
A healthy battery should read between 12.4 and 12.7 volts when the car is off and has been sitting for at least three hours. If it reads below 12 volts, the battery is discharged. Charge it fully with a battery charger and test again after letting it sit overnight. If it drops back below 12 volts by morning, the battery cannot hold charge and needs to be replaced.
If the battery holds 12.4 volts or higher overnight, the problem is not the battery itself. Check whether the alternator is charging the battery while the car runs, or whether something is draining power when the car is parked.
Test the alternator by checking voltage while the engine runs
Start the car and let it idle. With the multimeter still set to DC voltage, touch the probes to the battery posts again. A working alternator should push the voltage up to between 13.5 and 14.5 volts. If the voltage stays at 12 volts or drops below it while the engine is running, the alternator is not charging the battery.
A failing alternator is a job for a mechanic—it requires removing the old one and installing a new one, which takes one to two hours depending on the car. But knowing this is the problem before you go to the shop saves you from replacing a perfectly good battery.
Find a parasitic drain by checking which systems draw power when parked
A parasitic drain is something in your car that draws power even when the engine is off and the doors are closed. The most common culprits are a faulty alternator diode, a stuck relay, a bad door switch, or an aftermarket alarm or stereo that was not installed correctly.
To narrow down where the drain is coming from, look at your fuse box (usually under the hood or under the dashboard—check your owner's manual for the location). Pull out one fuse at a time and wait a few minutes to see if the battery stops draining. When you find the fuse that stops the drain, you have found the system causing the problem. Note which system that fuse controls (the fuse box lid usually has a diagram), and have a mechanic inspect that system.
If you do not want to pull fuses yourself, a mechanic can use a clamp meter to measure the current draw and locate the drain in an hour or less.
When to replace the battery versus when to see a mechanic
Replace the battery if it fails the voltage test (drops below 12 volts after sitting overnight, even after a full charge). Batteries are straightforward to replace—most auto parts stores will install one for free if you buy it from them, and the job takes 15 minutes.
See a mechanic if the battery voltage is healthy but the car still will not start, if the alternator is not charging, or if you suspect a parasitic drain. These problems require diagnosis and repair that go beyond a battery replacement. A mechanic can also run a full charging system test, which checks the alternator, the battery, and the wiring all at once.
What to do while you are waiting for a repair
If your battery drains quickly but you need to drive the car before you can get it repaired, keep a set of jumper cables in the car and know how to use them. Connect the positive (red) cable to the positive post of the dead battery first, then to the positive post of the good battery. Connect the negative (black) cable to the negative post of the good battery, then to a bare metal surface on the engine block of the dead car (not the negative post—this reduces the risk of sparks). Start the good car, wait two minutes, then start your car. Let both run for a few minutes before disconnecting the cables in reverse order.
Avoid leaving the car parked for long periods without driving it. Even a healthy battery will discharge slowly over weeks. If you know the car will sit unused, disconnect the negative battery cable to stop any parasitic drain.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my battery is bad or if it is the alternator?
Test the battery voltage with a multimeter when the car is off—it should read 12.4 to 12.7 volts. Then start the car and test again—it should jump to 13.5 to 14.5 volts. If it stays at 12 volts or drops while running, the alternator is not charging. If the battery voltage is healthy but the car still will not start, the battery is likely bad.
Can a battery go bad overnight?
A healthy battery does not go bad overnight, but it can discharge overnight if something is drawing power (a parasitic drain) or if the alternator did not fully charge it while you were driving. If the battery is truly dead and will not hold any charge even after a full charge cycle, it has failed and needs replacement.
Is it safe to drive with a battery that won't hold a charge?
It depends on the cause. If the alternator is working, the battery will stay charged while you drive. If the alternator is failing, the battery will drain and the car may stall. If a parasitic drain is the problem, the car will start fine but may not start the next day. Have the problem diagnosed before relying on the car for long trips.
What does it mean if the battery is swollen or leaking?
A swollen or leaking battery is damaged and must be replaced when ready. Do not attempt to charge it or drive the car. Bring it to a mechanic or auto parts store for safe disposal and replacement. A swollen battery can rupture or catch fire.
Do I need to reprogram anything after replacing the battery?
Most modern cars will relearn their settings after a battery replacement, though it may take a few drive cycles. Some cars with security systems or aftermarket electronics may need reprogramming—check your owner's manual or ask the shop that installs the battery.