The three rental companies that dominate the market, and what each charges

U-Haul, Penske, and Home Depot's truck rental program are the three largest options for one-way and local moves. U-Haul operates the most locations (over 20,000 nationwide) and typically charges the lowest base rates, but adds fuel surcharges and mileage fees that can push the total higher. Penske generally charges more upfront but includes mileage in most quotes and often has lower fuel costs because their trucks run on diesel. Home Depot's program is a partnership with U-Haul, so pricing and availability mirror U-Haul's closely.

The actual cost depends on truck size, distance, day of the week, and season. A 10-foot truck for a local move might cost $20 to $40 per day with U-Haul, while the same truck from Penske could run $35 to $60 per day. One-way moves (renting in one city and dropping off in another) cost significantly more because the company has to reposition the truck. A one-way rental from New York to Boston might cost $400 to $600, while a local round-trip for the same distance could be $150 to $250.

Key Takeaways

  • U-Haul has the most locations but charges per mile; Penske includes mileage but costs more per day; compare both for your specific route before booking.
  • Renting mid-week and mid-month is cheaper than weekend and month-end moves, which can save $100 to $300 on a single rental.
  • Fuel costs vary by truck size and engine type—diesel trucks (Penske) often cost less to fill than gasoline trucks (U-Haul) even though diesel per gallon is higher.
  • Insurance through the rental company typically costs $15 to $30 per day; check your personal auto policy and credit card coverage before paying for it.
  • Reservation prices are not may provide—confirm the final quote 24 to 48 hours before pickup, as rates can change based on local demand.

How mileage and fuel charges stack up differently between companies

U-Haul charges a base daily rate plus a per-mile fee that ranges from $0.59 to $1.29 per mile depending on truck size and location. On a 200-mile move, that mileage charge alone could add $118 to $258 to your bill. Penske includes unlimited mileage on most rentals, so you pay the daily rate and fuel only. For long-distance moves, Penske's model often wins; for short local moves under 50 miles, U-Haul's lower daily rate may be cheaper even with mileage fees.

Fuel is a separate line item on both invoices. You can return the truck empty (and pay their fuel charge, which is marked up 30 to 50 percent above retail), or you can fill it yourself before returning it. Filling it yourself is almost always cheaper. A 10-foot U-Haul truck holds about 25 gallons; if you return it empty and their fuel charge is $4.50 per gallon, you pay $112.50 for fuel you could have bought for $80 to $90 at a gas station. Penske trucks run diesel and hold 30 to 40 gallons depending on size, so the math is similar.

When to book and what day of the week saves the most money

Friday through Sunday and the last week of the month are peak demand periods, and rental rates climb 20 to 40 percent above weekday rates. A 10-foot truck that costs $25 per day on a Tuesday might cost $35 to $40 on a Saturday. If your move is flexible, shifting it to a Wednesday or Thursday can save $50 to $150 on a three-day rental. The first two weeks of the month are also cheaper than the 20th through the end of the month, when people are moving to new apartments or houses.

Booking timing matters less than you might think. Rental companies adjust prices based on local demand, not how far in advance you book. A reservation made two months early and one made two days before can have the same price if demand hasn't changed. However, booking early does lock in your truck size and location, which matters if you're renting during a busy season. If you book late and the truck you want is gone, you may have to upgrade to a larger (more expensive) truck or use a less convenient location.

Insurance, damage waivers, and what your own policy covers

Rental truck companies offer damage waivers (sometimes called Loss Damage Waiver or LDW) that cost $15 to $30 per day and cover collision, theft, and vandalism. Before you buy it, check three things: your personal auto insurance policy, your credit card's rental car coverage, and whether you're renting for business or personal use. Most personal auto policies extend to rental trucks, and many premium credit cards (American Express Platinum, Chase Sapphire Reserve) cover rental damage if you charge the rental to that card. Business rentals are often not covered by personal policies, so if you're moving for work, the rental company's waiver may be necessary.

Read the waiver terms carefully. Some waivers exclude damage from off-road use, towing, or hitting low-clearance structures like parking garage ceilings. If you're renting a 10-foot or larger truck, overhead clearance is a real risk—many parking garages, drive-throughs, and residential streets have 10-foot-6-inch or lower clearance. A roof strike can cost $500 to $2,000 in repairs, so if your credit card and personal policy don't cover it, the rental company's waiver is worth the $20 to $30 per day.

Truck size and how to avoid renting bigger than you need

Moving truck sizes range from 10 feet (holds about 3,000 cubic feet, roughly a one-bedroom apartment) to 26 feet (holds about 17,000 cubic feet, roughly a four-bedroom house). Renting a truck one size larger than you need adds $10 to $20 per day and uses more fuel, but renting one size too small means a second trip or leaving items behind. Most rental companies let you see the truck before you commit, so if you're unsure, ask to look at both sizes and load a few items to test the fit.

A practical rule: a 10-foot truck fits a studio or one-bedroom apartment; a 15-foot truck fits a two-bedroom; a 20-foot truck fits a three-bedroom; a 26-foot truck fits a four-bedroom or larger. If you're moving a single room or office, a 10-foot truck is usually overkill—consider a cargo van (which costs $30 to $50 per day) or a pickup truck with a cargo trailer. U-Haul and Penske both rent cargo vans and trailers, and they're often cheaper and easier to drive than a full-size truck.

One-way moves versus round-trip rentals and when each makes sense

A round-trip rental means you pick up and drop off at the same location. A one-way rental means you pick up in one city and drop off in another. One-way rentals cost more because the company has to move the truck back to a high-demand location or pay to reposition it. A round-trip 10-foot truck rental for three days might cost $75 to $100 total; the same truck rented one-way from a small city to a major city could cost $400 to $600.

One-way rentals are worth the premium if you're moving permanently and don't need the truck to return. If you're moving 50 miles or less and could theoretically make two trips, a round-trip rental is almost always cheaper. If you're moving 200 miles or more, a one-way rental saves you the drive back empty and is worth the higher cost. Check both options in the rental company's system—sometimes a one-way quote is surprisingly close to a round-trip quote, especially if the destination is a city where the company has high demand for trucks.

Hidden fees and what to watch for on your final invoice

Beyond the base rate, mileage, and fuel, rental companies add equipment fees (dollies, furniture pads, ramps), late return fees (usually $40 per hour after the grace period), and fuel surcharges. Some locations charge a drop-off fee for one-way rentals, and some add a cleaning fee if you return the truck dirty. The rental agreement lists these, but they're often in small print or presented as separate line items at checkout.

The most common surprise is the late return fee. Most companies give you a grace period (usually one to two hours), but after that, you're charged a full day's rental rate or an hourly fee—whichever is higher. If you rent a truck for $40 per day and return it three hours late, you might pay $40 to $60 in late fees. Plan your return time conservatively and call the location if you think you'll be late; some will extend your reservation without penalty if you ask before the important date.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I rent a truck if I'm under 25?

Yes, but most companies charge an underage driver fee of $15 to $25 per day for drivers under 25. Some locations have a minimum age of 18; others require 21. Call the specific location where you plan to rent, because policies vary by branch and by state.

What happens if I damage the truck and I don't have the damage waiver?

You're responsible for repair costs, which can range from a few hundred dollars for minor dents to several thousand for major damage. The rental company will bill you directly or through your credit card. If you dispute the charge, the company has photos and repair estimates to back it up, so disputing rarely succeeds.

Do I need a special license to drive a large moving truck?

Most rental trucks (up to 26 feet) do not require a commercial driver's license in most states. However, some states require a CDL for trucks over a certain weight (usually 26,000 pounds Gross Vehicle Weight Rating). Check your state's DMV website or ask the rental company before you book—if you need a CDL and don't have one, you cannot legally rent that truck.

Can I rent a truck and have someone else drive it?

The person whose name is on the rental agreement is the only one legally permitted to drive it. If someone else drives and is in an accident, the insurance may not cover it. You can add an additional driver for a fee (usually $10 to $15 per person per day), and they must present a valid driver's license at pickup.

Is it cheaper to rent from a local moving company instead of U-Haul or Penske?

Sometimes. Local companies often have lower daily rates and no per-mile fees, which makes them competitive for short moves. However, they typically have fewer locations, so one-way moves are harder to arrange. Get quotes from both national and local companies for your specific route—the cheapest option varies by location and distance.