What an underinsured motorist claim covers
An underinsured motorist (UIM) claim is a separate claim you file with your own insurance company when the other driver's liability coverage is not enough to pay for your injuries or vehicle damage. If the at-fault driver has $25,000 in liability coverage but your medical bills and lost wages total $60,000, your UIM coverage bridges that gap — up to your policy limit.
UIM coverage is optional in most states, but required in a few. It protects you when the other driver carries the state minimum (which is often low) or when their insurer denies or delays payment. You do not pursue this claim against the other driver's insurance company; you file it with your own insurer, which then may try to recover money from the at-fault driver's policy later.
UIM claims are separate from your uninsured motorist (UM) coverage, which applies when the other driver has no insurance at all. Some policies combine them into a single UIM/UM limit; others keep them separate. Check your declarations page to see what you carry.
Key Takeaways
- You file a UIM claim with your own insurance company, not the other driver's, and you must have UIM coverage on your policy to use it.
- The other driver's liability limit must be lower than your damages for a UIM claim to pay anything; if their coverage is enough, your claim is denied.
- You typically must settle or get a judgment against the at-fault driver's insurance first, then file the UIM claim for the remaining balance.
- Most states require you to notify your insurer within a set time window — often 30 to 90 days — or you may lose the right to file.
- Your own insurer may require you to submit medical records, repair estimates, and proof of the other driver's liability coverage limits before they will review your claim.
When you have a UIM claim instead of a full recovery
A UIM claim arises when the at-fault driver's liability insurance is insufficient. For example, you are hit by a delivery truck; the driver is clearly at fault; but their employer's policy has a $50,000 limit. Your injuries required surgery, physical therapy, and three months off work. Your total damages are $120,000. The at-fault driver's insurer pays their full $50,000 limit. You now have a $70,000 gap. If your policy includes UIM coverage with a $100,000 limit, your own insurer may cover that $70,000.
UIM does not explore if the other driver's coverage is sufficient to pay your full claim. It also does not explore if the other driver is uninsured — that is when UM coverage takes over. Some drivers carry no liability coverage at all; others carry coverage but it lapses or the insurer denies the claim on a technicality. In those cases, you use UM, not UIM.
The order matters: you must exhaust the at-fault driver's liability coverage first. You cannot skip their policy and go straight to your own UIM coverage. Most insurers will not even accept a UIM claim until you have settled with or obtained a judgment from the other driver's insurer.
Steps to file a UIM claim with your insurer
Start by notifying your own insurance company as soon as possible after the crash. Many policies require notice within 30 to 90 days, though some allow longer. Call the claims number on your insurance card and tell them you were in a crash and may have a UIM claim. They will assign a claims adjuster.
Gather and submit the following documents to your adjuster: a copy of the police report, photos of vehicle damage, medical records and bills, proof of lost wages, repair estimates or invoices, and the other driver's insurance information including their policy limits. Your adjuster will verify that the other driver was at fault and confirm their liability limit is lower than your damages.
Next, you or your attorney must resolve the claim against the at-fault driver's insurance. This means either negotiating a settlement or, if they refuse to pay fairly, filing a lawsuit and obtaining a judgment. Once that is settled or judged, you submit proof of that settlement or judgment to your own insurer along with your UIM claim. Your insurer will then calculate what they owe: your total damages minus what you received from the other driver's policy.
Your insurer may offer a settlement on the UIM portion. You can accept it, negotiate for more, or reject it and pursue a lawsuit against your own insurer. This is rare but happens when the insurer undervalues your claim or disputes liability.
Documents your insurer will ask for
Your insurance company needs proof of three things: that the other driver was at fault, that their liability limit is insufficient, and that your damages are real and documented. Below is what they typically request:
| Document Type | Why They Need It |
|---|---|
| Police report | Establishes fault and provides the other driver's insurance details |
| Other driver's insurance card or declarations page | Confirms their policy limits and whether coverage is active |
| Medical records and bills | Proves injury and calculates your economic damages |
| Wage loss documentation from your employer | Proves lost income due to the crash |
| Vehicle repair estimate or invoice | Establishes property damage amount |
| Settlement agreement or court judgment from the other driver's insurer | Shows how much you received from their policy |
| Photos of vehicle damage and crash scene | Corroborates the severity of the crash |
If you do not have all of these, ask your adjuster which ones are essential to move forward. Some can be obtained later; others must be submitted before they will review your claim.
How your UIM limit affects what you recover
Your UIM coverage limit is the maximum your own insurer will pay on a UIM claim. If you have a $100,000 UIM limit and your damages are $150,000, and the at-fault driver's insurer paid $50,000, your own insurer will pay up to $100,000 on the UIM claim — not the full $100,000 gap.
Many people carry UIM limits that match their liability limits. If you have $100,000 in liability coverage, you may also have $100,000 in UIM coverage. Some carry higher UIM limits; others carry lower ones. The limit you chose when you bought the policy is what applies now.
If your UIM limit is lower than the gap between your damages and the other driver's payment, you will not recover the full amount. For example, if your damages are $100,000, the other driver's insurer paid $30,000, and your UIM limit is $50,000, you will receive $50,000 from your own insurer — leaving a $20,000 shortfall. This is why some people carry UIM limits higher than their liability limits, especially if they have significant assets to protect.
State variations in UIM claims
UIM rules vary by state in ways that affect how much you can recover. Some states use stacking, which allows you to add multiple UIM limits together if you have more than one vehicle or policy. Other states prohibit stacking. A few states require UIM coverage by law; most make it optional.
Some states follow a pro-rata rule, which reduces your UIM recovery by your percentage of fault. If you are found 20% at fault and your UIM claim is $50,000, you recover $40,000. Other states do not explore this reduction to UIM claims. A handful of states allow you to file a UIM claim without first settling the other driver's liability claim, though this is uncommon.
Your state's insurance commissioner's office or your state bar association can tell you the specific rules in your state. Your adjuster should also explain how your state's rules explore to your claim, but it is worth verifying independently.
When to hire an attorney for a UIM claim
You do not need an attorney to file a UIM claim, but you may want one if the claim is large, your insurer disputes liability, or the gap between your damages and the other driver's coverage is significant. An attorney can negotiate with your own insurer, challenge their valuation of your damages, and file a lawsuit if needed.
Many personal injury attorneys work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of what you recover rather than charging an hourly fee. This makes it easier to afford representation. However, your insurance policy may require you to notify your insurer if you hire an attorney, and some policies limit how much an attorney can charge.
If your damages are under $10,000 or the other driver's coverage is close to your total damages, an attorney may not be cost-effective. If your damages exceed $50,000 or your insurer is resisting your claim, an attorney often pays for itself by securing a larger settlement.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to use UIM coverage or can I just sue the other driver?
You can sue the other driver directly, but they may not have assets to collect from. UIM coverage is faster and more reliable because you are claiming against your own insurer, which has money set aside. Most attorneys recommend exhausting UIM first, then pursuing the other driver personally if there is still a shortfall.
What if the other driver's insurer denies their claim?
If the other driver's insurer denies liability or refuses to pay, you can still file a UIM claim with your own insurer. You will need to prove the other driver was at fault — usually with a police report, photos, or witness statements. Your insurer may then pursue the other driver's insurer on your behalf.
Can I file a UIM claim if I do not have medical bills yet?
You can file the claim, but your insurer will not settle it until your treatment is complete and you have final medical bills. If you file too early, you risk undervaluing your claim because you do not yet know the full cost of your injuries. Most attorneys recommend waiting until you have finished treatment before filing.
Will filing a UIM claim raise my insurance rates?
Filing a UIM claim should not raise your rates because you were not at fault. However, if you file a claim against your own insurer for any reason, some companies may increase your premium at renewal. Ask your agent whether a UIM claim counts as a claim on your record in your state.
What if my UIM limit is lower than the gap?
Your insurer will pay up to your UIM limit and no more. If the gap is larger, you have a shortfall. You can then pursue the other driver personally for the remaining amount, though collecting from an individual is often difficult. This is why carrying a UIM limit equal to or higher than your liability limit is recommended.