Filing a claim with Infinity Insurance

Infinity Insurance handles claims through their customer service line at 1-800-555-0156 or through your online account if you have one set up. When you call, have your policy number ready and be prepared to describe what happened, when it happened, and whether anyone was injured or property was damaged. The representative will create a claim number on the spot and tell you what documents they need from you.

You can also start a claim online through the Infinity Insurance website if you have an active account. The online process walks you through the same questions — incident date, type of loss, and damage description — and generates a claim number when ready. Either way, you'll receive written confirmation of your claim number by email or mail within one business day.

Infinity typically assigns a claims adjuster to your case within 24 to 48 hours. The adjuster's job is to inspect the damage (if it's a property claim), review your policy coverage, and determine what Infinity owes. They will contact you to schedule an inspection or request additional documents like repair estimates, photos, or police reports.

Key Takeaways

  • Call Infinity at 1-800-555-0156 or file online through your account to start a claim; you'll get a claim number when ready.
  • Have your policy number and details about the incident ready when you contact them.
  • An adjuster will be assigned within 24 to 48 hours and will contact you to schedule an inspection or request documents.
  • Infinity's timeline for claim resolution varies by type of loss, but most auto claims are resolved within 7 to 14 days.
  • You can check your claim status anytime by calling your adjuster or logging into your online account.

What documents Infinity will ask for

The documents you need depend on the type of claim. For an auto accident, Infinity will ask for the police report (if one was filed), photos of vehicle damage, contact information for other drivers or witnesses, and your driver's license. If you have repair estimates from body shops, send those along — Infinity often uses them to speed up the process.

For a homeowners claim, expect to provide photos of the damage, a list of damaged or destroyed items with their approximate age and value, receipts if you have them, and proof of the loss (like a fire department report for fire damage or a weather service report for storm damage). If you hired a contractor to assess the damage, their written estimate helps too.

Infinity may also ask for your mortgage statement or proof of occupancy. Send documents by email to your adjuster if they provide an email address, or by mail to the address on your claim paperwork. Keep copies of everything you send.

How Infinity calculates what they owe you

Infinity uses your policy's coverage limits and deductible to determine the payout. If you have collision coverage on an auto policy, Infinity pays for damage up to your vehicle's actual cash value (what it was worth before the accident) minus your deductible. If you have a $500 deductible and the damage is valued at $3,200, Infinity pays $2,700.

For homeowners claims, Infinity typically pays based on the cost to repair or replace the damaged property, minus your deductible. Some policies cover replacement cost (what it costs to rebuild or replace today), while others cover actual cash value (replacement cost minus depreciation). Your policy documents spell out which one applies to you.

Infinity's adjuster will provide a written estimate of what they're paying and why. If you disagree with their valuation, you can request a second opinion or hire an independent appraiser. Some policies allow you to dispute the amount through a process called appraisal, where you and Infinity each hire an appraiser and a third party breaks the tie if they disagree.

Timeline for claim resolution

Most auto claims are resolved within 7 to 14 days if the damage is straightforward and you provide all requested documents promptly. Complex claims — those involving multiple vehicles, injuries, or disputes over fault — can take 30 days or longer. Homeowners claims typically take 10 to 21 days for standard damage like roof leaks or broken windows, but major losses like fire or flood can take 60 days or more.

The clock starts when Infinity receives your claim, not when you file it. If you file on a Friday evening, the 24-hour window for adjuster assignment begins on Monday. If your adjuster requests documents and you don't send them for two weeks, that delay extends the timeline.

Infinity is required by state law to acknowledge your claim within a set timeframe (usually 5 to 10 days, depending on your state) and to keep you informed of progress. If you haven't heard from your adjuster in more than a week, call the claims line and ask for a status update using your claim number.

Tracking your claim status

Log into your Infinity Insurance online account to see real-time updates on your claim. The account shows your claim number, the date it was filed, the assigned adjuster's name and phone number, and the current status (under review, awaiting documents, inspection scheduled, and so on). This is the fastest way to check progress without making a phone call.

You can also call your adjuster directly using the phone number on your claim paperwork. Adjusters typically return calls within one business day. Have your claim number ready and be specific about what you want to know — for example, "I sent photos on Tuesday; did you receive them?" rather than "What's the status?"

If you can't reach your adjuster after two attempts, call the main claims line at 1-800-555-0156 and ask to speak with a supervisor. Provide your claim number and explain that you've been unable to reach your assigned adjuster. The supervisor can pull up your file and give you an update or reassign your claim if needed.

What to do if Infinity denies your claim

Infinity will send you a written denial letter explaining why they're not paying. Common reasons include the loss not being covered under your policy, the damage occurring before your policy started, or the claim being filed after your policy lapsed. Read the denial letter carefully and check it against your policy documents.

If you believe Infinity made a mistake, you can request a review. Call your adjuster or the claims line and ask for a formal reconsideration. Provide any new evidence — additional photos, repair estimates, or documentation you didn't include the first time. Infinity will assign someone to review your case again, which usually takes 10 to 15 business days.

If Infinity still denies the claim after reconsideration, you have the right to file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner or department of insurance. You can also hire an attorney or pursue appraisal if your policy includes that option. Before taking either step, contact Infinity one more time in writing (email or certified mail) to document your position and ask them to reconsider.

Common reasons Infinity claims are delayed

Missing documents are the number-one reason claims take longer than expected. If Infinity asks for a police report and you don't provide it, they can't move forward. Get the report from the police department's non-emergency line or online portal, and send it to your adjuster as soon as you have it.

Weather can also delay inspections. If your claim involves storm damage and more storms are in the forecast, Infinity may wait to schedule an inspection until the weather clears. This is standard practice because adjusters can't safely assess a roof or foundation in active rain or snow.

Disputes over fault or coverage can slow things down too. If Infinity believes the loss isn't covered under your policy or that you're partially at fault for an accident, they'll investigate more thoroughly before making a decision. This investigation can add 10 to 20 days to the timeline.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I choose my own repair shop, or does Infinity require me to use one of theirs?

You can use any repair shop you want. Infinity cannot require you to use a specific shop, though they may have preferred vendors who give them discounts. If you use a non-preferred shop, Infinity will still pay based on their estimate of the repair cost. Get multiple estimates if you want to show Infinity that your chosen shop's price is competitive.

What happens if I disagree with Infinity's damage estimate?

Request a second estimate from another repair shop or appraiser and send it to your adjuster. If the estimates differ significantly, ask about the appraisal process in your policy. Appraisal lets you and Infinity each hire an appraiser; if they disagree, a neutral third party decides. This process costs money upfront but can resolve disputes faster than negotiating back and forth.

Do I have to pay my deductible before or after Infinity pays?

You pay your deductible when you get the repair done or when Infinity issues payment, depending on how you handle the claim. If Infinity pays you directly, they subtract the deductible from the check. If you pay for repairs upfront and submit receipts, you're responsible for the deductible amount out of pocket.

How long does Infinity keep my claim on file?

Infinity keeps closed claims in their system for at least three to five years. You can request copies of your claim file anytime by calling the claims line with your claim number. This is useful if you need documentation for tax purposes, legal disputes, or future insurance applications.

What if Infinity's adjuster and I can't agree on the damage amount?

Start with a written request for reconsideration, including new estimates or photos that support your position. If that doesn't work, check your policy for an appraisal clause. If your policy includes appraisal, you can invoke it to have a neutral third party review both estimates and make a binding decision. If your policy doesn't include appraisal, you may need to consult an attorney or file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner.