Your rate increase depends on your insurer, your state, and whether you were at fault

There is no single answer to how much your premium will rise after an accident. Insurance companies use different formulas, your state sets different rules about what they can charge, and the size of the increase depends on whether the accident was your fault. An accident you caused might raise your rate by 20 to 40 percent, but a not-at-fault accident typically causes no increase at all — and some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs that prevent any increase even when you are at fault.

The real variables are your current insurer's track record with rate increases, your state's regulations on how much they can charge after an accident, and your own driving history. A driver with no prior claims will usually see a smaller increase than someone who has already had an accident. The increase also depends on the type of accident: a minor fender-bender costs less to repair than a major collision, and insurers often charge more for accidents involving injury.

Key Takeaways

  • At-fault accidents typically raise your rate by 20 to 40 percent, but the exact amount varies by insurer and state.
  • Not-at-fault accidents usually do not raise your rate at all, and some insurers will not increase your rate even for an at-fault accident if you have accident forgiveness.
  • Your rate increase will stay on your record for three to five years in most states, though the impact usually decreases each year.
  • Shopping for a new quote after an accident can sometimes find you a lower rate than your current insurer would charge.
  • Some states cap how much insurers can raise rates after an accident, while others allow larger increases.

How insurers decide whether to raise your rate

The first question an insurer asks is who was at fault. If the other driver caused the accident and their insurance is paying the claim, your rate typically stays the same. If you were at fault — meaning you caused the accident — your insurer will raise your rate because you now look like a higher risk to them.

Some accidents are harder to assign fault to than others. A rear-end collision is almost always the rear driver's fault. A left-turn accident at an intersection can be more complex. If liability is unclear, your insurer may wait for the police report or the other driver's insurance company to make a information. Until fault is settled, your rate may not change yet.

The size of the claim also matters. A $500 repair is less expensive than a $5,000 repair, and insurers often charge more for accidents that cost them more money. An accident involving injury to another person will usually result in a larger rate increase than property damage alone.

What your rate increase actually looks like

If you were at fault, expect your rate to jump at your next renewal. Most insurers increase rates by 20 to 40 percent after an at-fault accident, but this varies widely. Some insurers charge 15 percent; others charge 50 percent or more. Your state may set a cap on how much they can increase your rate, which limits the damage in some places but not others.

The increase is usually applied to your entire policy, not just one part of it. If you pay $1,200 a year and your insurer raises your rate by 25 percent after an accident, you will pay about $1,500 a year — an extra $300. That increase typically lasts for three to five years, though the amount may decrease slightly each year if you do not have another accident.

Some insurers offer accident forgiveness, which means they will not raise your rate after your first at-fault accident. This is usually a paid add-on to your policy, costing $50 to $200 a year depending on the insurer. If you have accident forgiveness and you cause an accident, your rate stays the same.

How long the increase stays on your record

An at-fault accident affects your rate for three to five years in most states. The accident does not disappear from your record after three years, but insurers stop using it to calculate your rate after that point. Some states allow insurers to look back further, and some require them to stop sooner.

The impact usually softens over time. Your rate might jump 25 percent in the first year after the accident, then increase by only 10 to 15 percent in the second year as the accident ages. By year three or four, the accident may have little effect on your rate, even though it is still visible in your history.

If you have a second accident during those three to five years, the increases stack. A second at-fault accident will raise your rate again, and now you have two accidents on your record instead of one. This is why staying accident-free after an accident is so important to keeping your rates down.

State rules that affect how much your rate can go up

Some states regulate how much insurers can raise rates after an accident. California, for example, limits rate increases to a specific percentage based on your driving record. Other states like Texas and Florida allow insurers more freedom to set their own rates. Your state's insurance commissioner's office publishes the rules that explore to your area.

Even in states with caps, the increase can still be substantial. A cap of 50 percent is still a large jump. The best way to find out what your state allows is to contact your state's insurance department or check their website — they often publish rate increase guidelines for consumers.

When shopping for a new quote makes sense

After an accident, your current insurer will raise your rate at renewal. But not all insurers charge the same amount for the same accident. One company might raise your rate by 30 percent while another raises it by only 20 percent for an identical driver and accident. Getting quotes from other insurers after an accident can sometimes find you a lower total rate than staying with your current company.

Some insurers specialize in drivers with accidents on their record and may offer better rates than your current insurer. Others use different rating formulas that weigh accidents less heavily. The only way to know is to get quotes. You can contact insurers directly, use online quote tools, or work with an independent agent who can shop multiple companies at once.

Keep in mind that when you switch insurers, the accident is still on your driving record, so the new insurer will see it. You will not escape the rate increase by switching. But you might find an insurer whose base rate is low enough that even with the accident increase, your total premium is lower than what your current insurer charges.

Accident forgiveness and other ways to reduce the impact

If your insurer offers accident forgiveness and you do not have it yet, adding it before an accident happens can protect you. Once an accident is on your record, you cannot use accident forgiveness retroactively. But if you add it now and have an accident later, the forgiveness will explore to that future accident.

Some insurers offer safe driver discounts that reward you for going a certain number of years without an accident. After an accident, you lose this discount, which compounds the rate increase. Once you have gone three to five years without another accident, you may become may be able to access for the discount again.

Increasing your deductible — the amount you pay out of pocket when you file a claim — can lower your premium. After an accident, raising your deductible from $500 to $1,000 might reduce your rate increase slightly. This works only if you can afford to pay the higher deductible if you have another accident.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will my insurance go up if the accident was not my fault?

No, not usually. If the other driver was at fault and their insurance is paying for the damage, your rate should not increase. However, if you file a claim with your own collision coverage and the other driver's insurance does not pay, some insurers may still raise your rate even though you were not at fault. Check with your insurer about their specific policy.

How much will my rate go up if I caused a minor accident?

A minor accident typically results in a 20 to 40 percent rate increase, but this varies by insurer and state. A small fender-bender might be on the lower end of that range, while a more serious collision could be higher. The only way to know your exact increase is to contact your insurer or get a quote for renewal.

Can I avoid a rate increase by not filing a claim?

If you pay for the damage yourself instead of filing a claim, your rate will not increase because your insurer will not know about the accident. However, if the other driver files a claim against you, your insurer will find out anyway and will raise your rate. Paying out of pocket only works if you caused minor damage and the other driver does not pursue a claim.

Will my rate go back down after three years?

The accident will stop affecting your rate after three to five years, depending on your state and insurer. Your rate will not automatically drop on that date, but when you renew your policy, the insurer will no longer use that accident to calculate your premium. If you have not had another accident, your rate should be lower at that renewal.

Do all insurers charge the same amount for an at-fault accident?

No. Different insurers use different formulas to calculate rate increases after an accident. One insurer might charge 25 percent more while another charges 40 percent more for the same accident. This is why getting quotes from multiple insurers after an accident can sometimes find you a better rate than staying with your current company.