What happens to your rate depends on fault, your state, and your insurer
If you caused the accident, expect your rate to increase at your next renewal — usually by 15 to 40 percent, though some insurers charge more. If you were not at fault, most insurers will not raise your rate, though a handful do. The exact increase depends on three things: whether your state allows insurers to use accidents in rate calculations, what your specific policy says, and how your insurer's pricing model treats claims.
The increase is not automatic or uniform. Two drivers with identical accidents at the same insurer can pay different amounts because insurers use different formulas. Some weight the accident heavily; others barely move the needle. Some states cap how much insurers can raise rates after an accident; others do not. Your best move is to contact your insurer directly and ask what your new rate will be before you renew.
Key Takeaways
- At-fault accidents typically raise rates by 15 to 40 percent at renewal, but the exact amount varies by insurer, state, and your driving history.
- Not-at-fault accidents usually do not raise your rate, though some insurers will increase it anyway — you can shop around if yours does.
- Some states cap rate increases after accidents; others allow insurers to raise rates as much as they want.
- Your rate increase takes effect at renewal, not when ready after the accident, so you have time to shop other insurers before your policy renews.
- Bundling policies, taking a defensive driving course, or improving your credit score can sometimes offset part of the increase.
How insurers calculate the rate increase
Insurers do not have a single formula. Each company builds its own pricing model, and that model determines how much weight an accident carries. Some insurers treat a minor fender-bender as a small adjustment; others treat it the same as a major collision. The model also factors in your age, driving history, the type of accident, the amount paid out, and whether you were at fault.
Your insurer will not raise your rate when ready. The increase takes effect at your next renewal date — typically six months or one year from now. That timing matters: it gives you a window to shop other insurers and lock in a better rate before your current policy renews. Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs that waive the increase if you have been claim-free for a set number of years, though these programs usually cost extra.
The increase is not permanent. After three to five years without another accident, most insurers will drop the surcharge. Some states require insurers to remove the accident from your record after a certain time; others do not. Check your state's insurance department website to learn what your state requires.
At-fault versus not-at-fault accidents
If the police report or insurance investigation found you at fault, your rate will almost certainly go up. If the other driver was found at fault, your rate should not increase — but verify this with your insurer before renewal. A small number of insurers will raise rates for not-at-fault accidents anyway, treating them as a sign of higher risk. If your insurer does this, you can shop for a new policy with a company that does not penalize not-at-fault claims.
The information of fault can take weeks or months. Your insurer will investigate the accident, review the police report, and contact the other driver's insurer. Until that investigation closes, you may not know whether you will face a rate increase. If you disagree with the fault information, you can ask your insurer to reconsider or file a complaint with your state's insurance department.
State rules that limit or allow rate increases
Some states cap how much insurers can raise your rate after an accident. California, for example, limits increases to 20 percent for a single at-fault accident. Other states, like Texas and Florida, allow insurers to raise rates much higher with fewer restrictions. A few states require insurers to offer accident forgiveness or to remove accidents from your record after a set time.
Your state's insurance department publishes the rules that explore to you. Search "[your state] insurance department" and look for a page on rate increases or surcharges. You can also call your state's insurance commissioner's office and ask what the rules are in your state. Knowing the cap in your state helps you push back if your insurer quotes a rate increase that exceeds it.
When to shop for a new insurer
Do not wait until renewal to shop. As soon as you know you were at fault, get quotes from at least three other insurers. Some companies specialize in drivers with accidents and may offer a better rate than your current insurer. Quotes are free and do not affect your credit score. You can lock in a new rate before your current policy renews, so you are not stuck paying the increase.
When you get quotes, tell each insurer about the accident. Hiding it will void your policy if you ever file a claim. Some insurers will quote you a lower rate than your current company; others will quote higher. The variation can be hundreds of dollars a year, so shopping is worth the time. You can switch insurers at any time, not just at renewal, though you may pay a cancellation fee if you leave before your policy expires.
Ways to offset part of the increase
Bundling your auto and home policies with the same insurer often brings a discount of 10 to 25 percent. If you do not already bundle, switching to a company that offers it can help offset the accident surcharge. Completing a defensive driving course approved by your state can also reduce your rate by 5 to 10 percent at some insurers, though the discount varies. Check with your insurer to see if they offer it.
Raising your deductible — the amount you pay out of pocket before insurance kicks in — will lower your premium. If you raised your deductible from $500 to $1,000, your rate might drop by 10 to 15 percent. This works only if you have the cash to cover the higher deductible if you have another accident. Improving your credit score, if it is low, can also help; some insurers use credit as a rating factor, and a higher score brings a lower rate.
How long the accident affects your rate
Most insurers keep the surcharge in place for three to five years. After that time, the accident falls off your record and your rate returns to what it would be without it. Some states require insurers to remove accidents after a specific time — usually three years — while others allow insurers to keep them longer. Check your state's rules to know when you can expect the surcharge to drop.
The timeline starts from the date of the accident, not from the date you filed the claim. If you had an accident on January 15, 2024, the surcharge will likely expire on January 15, 2027 or later, depending on your insurer and state. You do not have to do anything to remove it; it will fall off automatically at renewal once the time period has passed. If it does not, contact your insurer and ask them to recalculate your rate.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my insurance go up if the other driver was at fault?
No, not usually. If the other driver was found at fault, your insurer should not raise your rate. However, a small number of insurers will increase rates for any claim, regardless of fault. If yours does, you can shop for a new insurer that does not penalize not-at-fault claims. Ask your current insurer directly whether they will raise your rate for a not-at-fault accident.
How much will my rate go up?
It varies widely by insurer and state. Most at-fault accidents result in increases of 15 to 40 percent, but some insurers charge more and some charge less. The only way to know your exact increase is to contact your insurer or get quotes from other companies. Your rate increase takes effect at renewal, not when ready, so you have time to shop around.
Can I get the accident removed from my record early?
Not usually. Most insurers keep accidents on your record for three to five years. Some states require insurers to remove them after a specific time, typically three years. You cannot remove it yourself, but you can switch to a new insurer that does not use the accident in their rating — though they will see it in your history and may still charge more.
Does a minor accident cost more than a major one?
Not always. Some insurers charge based on the amount they paid out; others charge a flat surcharge for any at-fault accident. A minor fender-bender might result in a smaller increase than a major collision at some insurers, but at others the increase is the same. Ask your insurer how they price accidents.
What if I disagree with the fault information?
You can ask your insurer to reconsider the information and review their investigation. If you still disagree, you can file a complaint with your state's insurance department. Some states allow you to dispute fault through arbitration or mediation. Contact your state's insurance commissioner's office to learn what options are available to you.