A wreck typically stays on your insurance record for three to five years, but the exact length depends on your state, your insurer, and whether you were at fault

Insurance companies use a tool called the CLUE report (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange) to track claims you have filed. When you report an accident, that claim gets recorded in your CLUE history. Your insurer checks this history when you renew your policy or explore elsewhere, and it directly affects your rates and whether a company will insure you at all.

The length of time a wreck stays visible varies. Most insurers look back three to five years when calculating your premium. Some states regulate how far back insurers can look — California, for example, limits it to five years for most claims. Other states have no legal limit, which means an insurer can technically see older claims, though most do not use them in rate calculations. Your own insurer may keep the claim on file longer than they use it to set your rate.

A wreck where you were found at fault stays on your record longer and costs you more than one where you were not at fault. An accident where you were not responsible may still appear on your CLUE report, but many insurers do not raise your rates for not-at-fault claims, or they raise them less. Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs that prevent your first at-fault accident from raising your rate at all — but you have to ask whether your policy includes this, because it is not automatic.

Key Takeaways

  • Most insurers look back three to five years when setting your rate, though some states legally limit how far back they can look.
  • An at-fault accident stays on your record longer and raises your rate more than a not-at-fault claim, which some insurers ignore entirely.
  • Your CLUE report is a separate record from your driving record; a wreck can appear on your insurance history even if it does not show on your DMV record.
  • When you switch insurers, the new company pulls its own CLUE report and may rate you differently based on the same accident.
  • Accident forgiveness programs prevent your first at-fault wreck from raising your rate, but you must have the coverage before the accident happens.

How the CLUE report works and who sees it

The CLUE report is maintained by LexisNexis and contains a five-year history of claims you have filed with any insurer. When you file a claim for a wreck, your insurer reports it to LexisNexis within a few days. That claim then appears on your CLUE report, along with the date, the type of loss, and the amount paid out.

Your current insurer uses your CLUE report when you renew your policy. If you have filed multiple claims in the past three years, your rate will go up — sometimes significantly. When you shop for a new insurer, that company pulls your CLUE report before quoting you. Some insurers will not quote you at all if your report shows too many recent claims. This is why a wreck can follow you even when you switch companies.

You can request your own CLUE report for free from LexisNexis once per year. You can also dispute information on it if you believe a claim was reported incorrectly. Disputing takes time — usually 30 to 60 days — so if you are shopping for insurance soon, request your report early.

The difference between at-fault and not-at-fault claims

An at-fault accident is one where the insurance company determined you were responsible for the wreck. This information usually comes from the police report, witness statements, or the other driver's account. An at-fault claim raises your rate significantly — often 20 to 40 percent, though the exact increase varies by insurer and state. This higher rate typically lasts three to five years.

A not-at-fault accident is one where the other driver was responsible, or where liability was unclear and your insurer chose not to pursue a claim against the other party. Many insurers do not raise your rate for a not-at-fault claim at all. Some raise it slightly, or only if you have multiple not-at-fault claims in a short period. Not-at-fault claims also stay on your CLUE report, but they do less damage to your rates.

The police report is not the final word on fault. Your insurer makes its own information based on the accident details. If you disagree with your insurer's fault decision, you can file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner, though this does not may provide the decision will change. Some states allow you to request an independent appraisal or arbitration.

How rate increases work after a wreck

After you file a claim for a wreck, your insurer will raise your rate at the next renewal. The increase depends on the severity of the accident, whether you were at fault, your driving history, and your state's regulations. A minor at-fault accident might raise your rate 15 to 25 percent. A major accident or one involving injury can raise it 30 to 50 percent or more.

The rate increase does not happen all at once and then disappear. Instead, your rate stays elevated for the entire period that the wreck is on your CLUE report — typically three to five years. Some insurers explore a larger increase in the first year and then reduce it slightly each year. Others keep the increase flat. You will see the higher rate every time you renew until the wreck ages off your report.

After the wreck ages off your CLUE report, your insurer should reduce your rate back to what it would be without that claim. However, you have to renew your policy for this to happen — the reduction does not explore retroactively. If you have been with the same insurer for years, ask them to re-quote you once the wreck falls off your report, because the system does not always automatically adjust your rate.

Accident forgiveness and other ways to limit the damage

Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs that prevent your first at-fault accident from raising your rate. If you have this coverage and you get into a wreck, your rate will not go up — the wreck still appears on your CLUE report, but your insurer agrees not to use it to set your premium. Accident forgiveness is usually available only if you have been with the insurer for a certain period (often three to five years) and have a clean driving record before the accident.

The catch is that you must have accident forgiveness before the wreck happens. You cannot add it after an accident and have it cover that accident. Some insurers include it automatically in certain policy tiers; others charge a small fee for it. When you are shopping for insurance, ask whether accident forgiveness is available and what it costs, because it can save you hundreds of dollars over the years following a wreck.

If you do not have accident forgiveness, you can still reduce the financial impact by raising your deductible. A higher deductible lowers your premium, which can offset some of the rate increase from the wreck. You can also shop around — different insurers rate accidents differently, and a company that would raise your rate 40 percent might raise it only 25 percent. Getting quotes from three to five insurers after a wreck is worth the time.

Your CLUE report versus your driving record

Your CLUE report and your driving record are two separate things. Your driving record, maintained by your state's Department of Motor Vehicles, shows traffic violations, accidents you reported to the police, and license suspensions. Your CLUE report shows insurance claims you have filed. A wreck can appear on one, both, or neither.

If you were in a wreck and reported it to your insurer but not to the police, it will appear on your CLUE report but not on your DMV driving record. If you reported it to the police but did not file an insurance claim, it may appear on your driving record but not on your CLUE report. If you reported it to both, it appears on both. This matters because insurers look at both records when setting your rate.

Some states require you to report accidents to the police if they cause more than a certain amount of damage (often $500 to $1,000). Even if your state does not require it, reporting to the police creates an official record that can help you later if the other driver disputes fault. However, reporting to the police does not automatically mean the accident will stay on your driving record for a specific length of time — that varies by state.

What happens when you switch insurers

When you move to a new insurance company, the new insurer pulls its own CLUE report on you. They see the same wreck that your old insurer saw, and they may rate it differently. Some insurers are more forgiving of accidents than others. One company might raise your rate 30 percent for an at-fault wreck; another might raise it 45 percent. This is why shopping around after an accident can save you money.

The new insurer also sees how long ago the wreck happened. If it was four years ago and you are switching to a company that only looks back three years, the wreck may not affect your rate at all with the new insurer — even though it still appears on your CLUE report. This is another reason to get quotes from multiple companies if you have had a recent accident.

Some insurers also offer discounts for switching or for bundling multiple policies. These discounts can sometimes offset part of the rate increase from a wreck. When you are shopping, ask about all available discounts, not just the base rate, because the final premium is what matters.

How to check your CLUE report and dispute errors

You can order your CLUE report free once per year from LexisNexis by visiting their website or calling their consumer disclosure line. The report shows all claims filed in the past five years, the date of each claim, the type of loss, and the amount paid. Review it carefully for errors — claims can be reported incorrectly, or claims that were not yours can appear on your report by mistake.

If you find an error, you can dispute it directly with LexisNexis. You will need to provide documentation showing the claim was reported incorrectly — for example, a letter from your insurer stating that the claim was withdrawn, or proof that the accident date is wrong. LexisNexis has 30 days to investigate and respond. If they agree the information is wrong, they will correct it and send you an updated report.

Disputing takes time, so if you are planning to shop for insurance soon, request your CLUE report at least two months in advance. That way, if there are errors, you have time to dispute them before you start getting quotes. A corrected report can make a real difference in the rates you are offered.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a wreck stay on my insurance record if I was not at fault?

Yes, the wreck appears on your CLUE report either way. However, many insurers do not raise your rate for not-at-fault claims, or they raise it much less than for at-fault claims. When you file a claim, ask your insurer whether the not-at-fault status will affect your rate.

Can I remove a wreck from my insurance record before three years?

No, you cannot remove it. The wreck stays on your CLUE report for five years, though most insurers only use the past three to five years when setting your rate. After that period, the claim ages off and stops affecting your premium. You can dispute the claim if it was reported incorrectly, but you cannot delete an accurate claim.

Will my rate go down after the wreck ages off my record?

It should, but only at your next renewal. The reduction does not happen automatically mid-policy. When you renew, your insurer should re-rate you without the wreck factoring in. If you have been with the same company for years, call and ask them to re-quote you once the wreck falls off, because the system does not always adjust automatically.

If I switch insurers, will the new company see my wreck?

Yes, the new insurer pulls its own CLUE report and will see the wreck. However, they may rate it differently than your old insurer did. Some companies are more forgiving of accidents, and some only look back three years instead of five. Getting quotes from multiple insurers after a wreck can save you money.

What is accident forgiveness and how do I get it?

Accident forgiveness prevents your first at-fault wreck from raising your rate. You must have it before the accident happens — you cannot add it after. Ask your insurer whether it is available, what it costs, and what requirements you must meet (usually a clean driving record and a minimum time with the company).