Your rates usually stay the same if you're not at fault for the accident
If another driver hits you and their insurance pays for the damage, your own insurance rates typically do not increase. Most insurers do not raise rates for accidents where you bear no responsibility. However, this protection has limits, and the specifics depend on your state, your insurer, and the details of the claim.
The key factor is fault. Insurance companies use fault to decide who pays and whether to raise rates. If the other driver's insurer accepts liability and covers your damages, you should see no rate increase on your policy. But if liability is unclear, disputed, or shared between drivers, your rates may go up even though you did not cause the accident.
Key Takeaways
- Most insurers do not raise your rates if the other driver is found at fault and their insurer pays your claim.
- Your rates can still increase if fault is unclear, if you live in a state that allows it, or if you have a history of claims.
- Some states prohibit rate increases for not-at-fault accidents, while others allow insurers to raise rates regardless of fault.
- Filing a claim with the other driver's insurer (a third-party claim) protects your rates better than filing with your own insurer.
- You should ask your insurer directly whether this accident will affect your rates before you decide how to handle the claim.
How fault determines whether your rates rise
Insurance rates are built on risk. If you caused an accident, your insurer sees you as a higher risk and raises your rates. If you did not cause it, you posed no additional risk, so most insurers leave your rates alone. This logic holds in most states and with most carriers.
The problem arises when fault is not clear-cut. If both drivers share blame, if the police report is ambiguous, or if the other driver disputes liability, your insurer may treat the claim differently. Some insurers will not raise your rates unless you are found more than 50 percent at fault. Others use different thresholds. A few will raise rates even for not-at-fault accidents if you have had multiple claims in a short time.
The other driver's insurer determines fault in most cases. If they accept liability quickly and pay your claim, your own insurer has little reason to raise your rates. If they deny liability or the case goes to arbitration, the outcome affects your rate decision.
State laws that protect you from rate increases
Some states have laws that prevent insurers from raising rates for accidents where you are not at fault. These are called accident forgiveness laws or not-at-fault protection rules. The specifics vary widely by state.
California, for example, prohibits rate increases for a single not-at-fault accident in your first three years as a customer. New York has similar rules. Other states leave the decision entirely to the insurer. A few states allow rate increases for not-at-fault accidents under certain conditions, such as if you have had prior claims.
You can find your state's rules by contacting your state's insurance commissioner or department of insurance. Their website usually has a consumer guide that explains rate increase rules. Your insurer is also required to tell you their specific policy on not-at-fault claims when you ask.
Filing a third-party claim versus your own insurance
How you file the claim affects your rate risk. A third-party claim means you report the accident to the other driver's insurer and let them handle it. Your own insurer may never know about it, or may learn about it only if the other insurer denies liability and you later file with your own company.
Filing a third-party claim is often safer for your rates because your own insurer has no direct involvement. The other driver's insurer pays, and your rates stay untouched. This works well when the other driver is clearly at fault and their insurer accepts liability quickly.
Filing a claim with your own insurer (a first-party claim) puts the accident on your record with your company, even if you are not at fault. Your insurer will investigate, may raise your rates depending on state law and their policy, and the claim will appear on your insurance history for years. You might file a first-party claim if the other driver is uninsured, if their insurer denies liability, or if you need faster repairs.
When your rates may increase despite not being at fault
Several situations can lead to a rate increase even though you did not cause the accident. If you live in a state with no not-at-fault protection, your insurer may raise rates straightforward because you filed a claim. Some insurers treat all claims the same way, regardless of fault.
If you have had multiple claims or accidents in the past few years, a new claim—even a not-at-fault one—can trigger a rate increase. Insurers use your claims history to assess overall risk. A pattern of claims, whether your fault or not, signals higher risk to them.
If fault is shared or unclear, you may face a rate increase. If the police report does not assign fault, or if both drivers share responsibility, your insurer may classify you as partially at fault. Even a small percentage of fault can result in a rate hike in some states.
Questions to ask your insurer before filing
Before you file any claim, contact your insurer and ask these specific questions: Will this not-at-fault accident increase my rates? Does your company have accident forgiveness? If I file a third-party claim instead, will it affect my rates? How long will this claim stay on my record?
Get the answers in writing if possible. Some insurers will confirm in an email or letter that a not-at-fault claim will not raise your rates. This protects you if your rates do increase and you need to dispute the raise later.
You can also ask whether it makes sense to file the claim at all. If the damage is minor and you have a high deductible, paying out of pocket might be cheaper than filing and risking a rate increase, even if the other driver is at fault. Your insurer can help you weigh the options.
How long a not-at-fault claim affects your rates
Even if your rates do not increase when ready, a claim stays on your insurance record for years. Most insurers keep claims on file for three to five years. During that time, if you switch insurers, the new company will see the claim and may factor it into their rate decision.
Some insurers offer accident forgiveness as an add-on or as part of a loyalty program. This means they will not raise your rates for your first not-at-fault accident, or will remove the claim from your record after a certain time. Ask whether your insurer offers this and whether you can add it to your policy.
After the claim ages off your record, it should no longer affect your rates. Until then, it may influence renewal rates or rates if you switch companies, even though you were not at fault.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my rates go up if I file a claim with the other driver's insurance instead of mine?
Not usually. Filing a third-party claim with the other driver's insurer keeps the accident off your own insurance record. Your rates should not increase unless your insurer later learns about the claim and your state allows rate increases for not-at-fault accidents. However, if the other insurer denies liability and you later file with your own company, the claim will then appear on your record.
Can an insurer raise my rates if I'm 0% at fault?
It depends on your state and your insurer's policy. Some states prohibit rate increases for not-at-fault accidents. Others allow insurers to raise rates for any claim, regardless of fault. A few allow increases only if you have had prior claims. Contact your state's insurance commissioner or ask your insurer directly about their policy.
How long does a not-at-fault accident stay on my insurance record?
Most insurers keep claims on file for three to five years. During that time, the claim may affect your rates at renewal or if you switch insurers, even though you were not at fault. After it ages off, it should no longer influence your rates.
Should I file a claim if the damage is minor and I'm not at fault?
Consider the cost of repairs versus your deductible and the risk of a rate increase. If repairs cost less than your deductible plus the potential rate hike over several years, paying out of pocket may be cheaper. Ask your insurer whether this specific claim will raise your rates before you decide.
What if the police report doesn't say who was at fault?
Your insurer and the other driver's insurer will investigate and make their own fault information. A police report is one piece of evidence, but insurers also use witness statements, photos, and damage patterns. If fault remains unclear, your insurer may classify you as partially at fault, which could result in a rate increase depending on your state and policy.