Most insurance policies will not pay for damage or injuries you cause while driving under the influence
If you cause an accident while driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs, your insurance company can deny your claim. This is true even if you have collision or comprehensive coverage. The reason is straightforward: your policy almost certainly contains a clause that excludes coverage for accidents that result from illegal activity, and driving under the influence is a crime in every state.
The denial applies to both property damage (damage to other vehicles or structures) and liability claims (injuries to other people). Your insurance company is not required to pay for the consequences of your own illegal conduct. This means you could be personally responsible for thousands or tens of thousands of dollars in damages, medical bills, and legal costs.
The only exception is damage to your own vehicle from a collision caused by your impaired driving. Some insurers will cover your own car's damage under collision coverage, though they may raise your rates or drop you afterward. You should contact your insurer directly to ask whether they will cover your vehicle in this specific situation, because practices vary.
Key Takeaways
- Insurance companies can deny claims for accidents caused by driving under the influence because it is illegal activity excluded by your policy.
- Liability coverage will not pay for injuries or property damage you cause to others while impaired, leaving you personally liable.
- Your own vehicle damage may be covered under collision coverage depending on your insurer, but you should confirm this before assuming.
- A DUI conviction or arrest can result in your policy being cancelled or non-renewed, even if your current claim is paid.
- You may still owe the other driver's damages through a civil lawsuit or wage garnishment, regardless of what your insurance does.
How insurance companies determine whether you were driving under the influence
Your insurer will investigate your accident using police reports, arrest records, and blood alcohol test results if they are available. If you were arrested at the scene or shortly after, the police report will document the arrest and any test results. If you were convicted of DUI or pleaded guilty, that conviction is public record and your insurer can find it.
You do not have to tell your insurer you were impaired for them to discover it. The police report alone is often enough. If you were arrested but not yet convicted, the insurer may still deny your claim based on the arrest and the facts in the police report, without waiting for a trial outcome.
If there is no police report or arrest, your insurer may still deny the claim if they find evidence of impairment through witness statements, medical records from the hospital, or your own statements to the claims adjuster. Telling the adjuster you had been drinking is one of the fastest ways to trigger a denial.
What happens to your policy after a DUI-related accident
Even if your insurer pays your claim (which is rare), they can cancel or non-renew your policy after a DUI accident. Non-renewal means they straightforward will not offer you a new policy when your current one expires. Cancellation means they end your coverage when ready, though state law usually requires them to give you notice first—typically 10 to 30 days depending on your state.
After a DUI-related accident, you will likely be placed in the high-risk insurance market, where rates are much higher and coverage options are limited. Some insurers specialize in high-risk drivers, but they charge significantly more than standard insurers. You may also be required to file an SR-22 form (or SR-50 in a few states), which is a certificate of financial responsibility that proves you carry the minimum liability insurance required by your state.
The SR-22 requirement typically lasts three years from the date of your conviction or the date you paid any fines, depending on your state. During this time, if your policy lapses or is cancelled, your insurer must notify the state, which can result in license suspension or other penalties.
Your personal liability for damages caused by impaired driving
When your insurance company denies your claim, you become personally responsible for all damages. This includes medical bills for injured people, vehicle repair or replacement costs, property damage, and lost wages if someone cannot work due to injuries. In a serious accident, these costs can easily exceed $100,000.
The other driver or their insurance company can file a civil lawsuit against you to recover these costs. If they win, the court can order you to pay through wage garnishment, bank account levies, or a judgment lien on your property. This debt can follow you for years and affect your ability to borrow money, rent housing, or find employment.
Some states allow the other driver to pursue punitive damages in addition to actual damages if your conduct was reckless or intentional. Punitive damages are meant to punish you rather than straightforward compensate the other party, and they can be substantial.
What to do if your claim is denied for DUI-related driving
First, request a written explanation from your insurer stating the specific reason for the denial. They are required to provide this under state insurance law. Read your policy carefully to confirm that the exclusion they cite actually appears in your contract.
If you believe the denial is incorrect—for example, if you were not actually impaired or if the insurer misread the facts—you can file a complaint with your state's Department of Insurance. This is a free process and does not require a lawyer. The department can investigate whether the insurer followed state law and your policy terms correctly.
You should also consult a lawyer who handles insurance disputes or personal injury cases. Many will review your situation at no cost. A lawyer can tell you whether you have grounds to challenge the denial and what your options are for recovering damages from the other driver or their insurer.
Whether the other driver's insurance will pay you
If the other driver caused the accident and you were the one driving under the influence, their liability insurance will still pay for your injuries and vehicle damage. Your impairment does not prevent their insurer from covering their driver's liability. However, their insurer may investigate whether you were also at fault for the accident, and if so, they may reduce your payment based on your state's comparative fault rules.
If you were both at fault—for example, if the other driver ran a red light but you were impaired and could not react in time—your recovery may be reduced by your percentage of fault. In some states, if you are found to be more than 50 percent at fault, you cannot recover anything at all.
You will still need to file a claim with the other driver's insurer and provide documentation of your damages. The fact that you were impaired does not automatically bar you from recovering, but it may complicate your claim and reduce what you receive.
State variations in DUI coverage exclusions
All states allow insurers to exclude coverage for accidents caused by illegal activity, and DUI is illegal everywhere. However, a few states have specific rules about how insurers must handle DUI-related claims. Some states require insurers to pay the other driver's damages through the insured's liability coverage even if the driver was impaired, though the insurer can then pursue recovery from the driver or cancel the policy afterward.
A small number of states have laws that limit an insurer's ability to deny collision coverage (damage to your own vehicle) based on DUI alone, though this is uncommon. Your state's Department of Insurance website will have information about your state's specific rules, or you can call them directly to ask.
Regardless of your state, you should assume that your liability coverage will not pay for a DUI-related accident unless you have confirmed otherwise with your insurer in writing. Do not rely on assumptions about what your policy covers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I be denied coverage if I was arrested for DUI but not convicted?
Yes. Your insurer does not have to wait for a conviction. If a police report documents an arrest and shows signs of impairment, many insurers will deny your claim based on the arrest alone. However, some insurers may wait for a conviction before denying. Contact your insurer to ask their specific policy.
What if I was not arrested but the police report says I may have been impaired?
Your insurer can still deny your claim if the police report contains evidence of impairment, such as failed field sobriety tests, observations of slurred speech, or statements from witnesses. You do not have to be arrested or convicted for the insurer to use the report as grounds for denial.
Will my insurer tell me they are denying my claim because of DUI before I file?
No. You will not know the claim will be denied until after you file and the insurer investigates. This is why you should not volunteer information about impairment to the claims adjuster. If you were arrested, the police report will likely surface during the investigation regardless.
Can I sue my insurance company if they deny my claim?
You can file a complaint with your state's Department of Insurance for free. If you want to pursue a lawsuit, you will need a lawyer. A lawyer can review your policy and the insurer's denial letter to determine whether the insurer violated state law or your contract terms.
What happens if I cannot pay the damages the other driver is suing for?
The court can order wage garnishment, bank levies, or a judgment lien on your property. The other driver can also pursue collection through a collection agency. The debt can remain on your credit report for seven years and may affect your ability to borrow money or rent housing.