How long accidents stay on your driving record
An accident typically stays on your insurance record for three to five years, though the exact timeline depends on your state and your insurance company's internal policies. This is different from your driving record kept by your state's Department of Motor Vehicles — that record may hold the accident longer, sometimes seven to ten years or more.
Your insurance company uses its own database to track claims history. When you get a quote from a new insurer, they pull your Motor Vehicle Report (MVR) from the state and also check the CLUE report (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange), which is a claims history maintained by LexisNexis. The CLUE report shows accidents and claims you've filed with any insurer over the past five to seven years, depending on your state.
The key distinction: your state's driving record shows violations and accidents you were cited for or convicted of. Your insurance record shows claims you filed, regardless of fault. An accident where you were not at fault still appears on your CLUE report and can affect your rates.
Key Takeaways
- Accidents typically remain visible to insurers for three to five years on the CLUE report, though your state's driving record may keep them longer.
- An accident you were not at fault for still shows on your insurance history and can raise your rates with some insurers, though many offer accident forgiveness programs.
- The timeline varies by state — some states cap how long insurers can use accidents to set rates, while others allow longer lookback periods.
- Paying off a claim does not remove it from your record; the accident remains visible to future insurers even after you've settled.
- You can request a copy of your CLUE report to verify what insurers are seeing and dispute inaccurate information.
Why insurers look back different lengths of time
Insurance companies use accident history to predict future claims. The longer the lookback period, the more data they have — but some states have stepped in to limit how far back insurers can reach. California, for example, generally limits insurers to three years for accidents. New York allows five years. Other states have no legal limit, so insurers may look back seven years or more.
Even within the same state, different insurers set their own policies. One company might drop an accident from rate calculations after three years; another might use it for five. When you shop for quotes, you're partly shopping for companies with shorter memories.
The CLUE report itself typically shows claims for five to seven years depending on the state, but that does not mean an insurer must use all of it. Some insurers ignore older claims entirely. Others weight recent accidents more heavily than older ones but still factor them in.
Accidents you were not at fault for
Being found not at fault does not automatically protect your rates. The accident still appears on your CLUE report and your state's driving record. Some insurers will ignore not-at-fault accidents when setting your premium; many others will not.
This is where accident forgiveness programs come in. These are optional add-ons or standard features that prevent your first accident (or sometimes your first one or two) from raising your rates. Accident forgiveness typically covers accidents where you were at fault, but some programs also cover not-at-fault accidents. The catch: you usually have to purchase the program before the accident happens, and you may pay a small monthly fee for it.
If you were not at fault and the other driver's insurance paid your claim, ask your insurer whether they will exclude that accident from future rate calculations. Some will; some will not. It is worth asking directly when you shop for new quotes.
How accidents affect your rates right now
An accident typically raises your premium when ready after you file a claim. The increase varies widely — from 10 percent to 40 percent or more, depending on the severity of the accident, your state, your insurer, and your driving history. A minor fender-bender costs less in rate hikes than a major collision or accident where you were clearly at fault.
The rate increase is usually highest in the first year after the accident. In year two, the increase may shrink slightly. By year three or four, as the accident ages, the impact on your rate diminishes — but it does not disappear until the accident falls off the CLUE report entirely.
This is why shopping around matters. A new insurer may weight the same accident differently than your current one. You might find a company that ignores accidents older than three years, or one that offers accident forgiveness, or one that straightforward charges less for the same risk profile. The accident does not disappear, but your rate for it can.
Checking your own CLUE report
You have the right to request a free copy of your CLUE report from LexisNexis. Go to their consumer disclosure website or call 1-866-312-8076. You can also request it in writing. The report will show all claims you've filed with any insurer over the past five to seven years.
Review it carefully. CLUE reports contain errors — wrong dates, accidents attributed to you that were not your fault, duplicate entries, or claims you do not remember filing. If you spot an error, you can dispute it directly with LexisNexis. They have 30 days to investigate and correct or delete inaccurate information.
Correcting your CLUE report can lower your rates when ready, because insurers pull fresh reports when you get a new quote. If an accident was incorrectly listed as your fault when you were not at fault, fixing that error removes a major reason for rate increases.
State-by-state variation in accident timelines
A few states have laws that limit how long insurers can use accidents to set rates. California caps it at three years for most drivers. New York allows five years. Some states have no legal limit, meaning insurers can theoretically look back as far as they want — though most choose not to go beyond seven years because older data becomes less predictive.
Your state's Department of Motor Vehicles may also have rules about how long accidents stay on your public driving record. This is separate from your insurance record. A state might keep an accident on your DMV record for seven years while insurers only look back five years. Or vice versa.
When you shop for quotes, ask each insurer directly how far back they look and whether they have accident forgiveness. The answer varies enough that it is worth the phone call or email.
What happens when an accident finally ages off
Once an accident falls off the CLUE report — typically three to seven years after it occurred — new insurers will not see it when they pull your history. Your rate should drop noticeably, because that accident is no longer a factor in their calculation.
Your state's driving record may still show the accident, but most insurers rely more heavily on the CLUE report than on the DMV record. Once it is gone from CLUE, it stops affecting your rates with most companies.
The accident may still be visible to you in your own history, and it may still affect your ability to get certain types of coverage or to may have access to for low-risk programs. But for standard auto insurance rates, the impact ends once it ages off the CLUE report.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does paying off a claim remove it from my insurance record?
No. Paying the claim or settling it does not erase the accident from your CLUE report or your driving record. The accident remains visible to future insurers for the full timeline — typically three to seven years — regardless of whether you paid out of pocket or through insurance.
Will my rates go down after three years if I had an accident?
Probably, but not automatically. After three years, the accident may fall off some insurers' lookback periods, which could lower your rate. But other insurers look back five or seven years. The only way to know is to shop around and get new quotes. You might find a cheaper rate with a company that does not look back as far.
Can I remove an accident from my driving record?
Not directly. Your state's DMV keeps the record as a matter of public safety. However, if the accident was expunged from court records or if you were found not at fault and the case was dismissed, you may be able to request removal. Contact your state's DMV to ask about the process — it varies by state and is not may provide.
Does an accident I was not at fault for hurt my rates?
It depends on your insurer. Some ignore not-at-fault accidents entirely. Others still factor them in. Accident forgiveness programs sometimes cover not-at-fault accidents, but you usually have to buy the program before the accident happens. Ask your insurer directly whether they will exclude a not-at-fault accident from your rate.
How do I know how far back my insurer looks?
Call or email your current insurer and ask their lookback period for accidents. When you shop for new quotes, ask each company the same question. You can also request your CLUE report to see what information they are seeing about your history.