Insurance costs depend on what the car is, not just how much it costs
The cheapest car to buy is rarely the cheapest car to insure. A used Honda Civic might cost $8,000 but have lower repair costs and theft rates than a $6,000 Dodge Charger. Insurance companies don't charge based on purchase price—they charge based on repair costs, accident frequency, theft risk, and safety ratings for that specific make, model, and year.
The cars with the lowest insurance rates tend to be sedans and hatchbacks from mainstream manufacturers: Honda, Toyota, Mazda, and Subaru models from recent years. These vehicles have moderate repair costs, good safety records, and low theft rates. A 2019 Honda Accord or 2018 Toyota Camry will almost always cost less to insure than a 2019 Dodge Challenger or 2018 Infiniti Q50, even if the sports cars are older or have higher mileage.
Your own driving record, age, location, and coverage choices matter more than the car itself. A 25-year-old with two accidents will pay more to insure a Civic than a 45-year-old with a clean record will pay to insure a Mustang. But within your own situation, choosing a low-insurance-rate car can save hundreds of dollars per year.
Key Takeaways
- Sedans and hatchbacks from Honda, Toyota, Mazda, and Subaru typically have the lowest insurance rates because they cost less to repair and have fewer theft claims.
- Insurance companies base rates on repair costs and safety data for each specific year and model, not on the car's purchase price.
- Sports cars, luxury vehicles, and trucks usually cost more to insure, even used ones, because parts are expensive and repair shops charge more labor.
- A car's safety rating, theft history, and accident frequency for that model matter more than engine size or horsepower.
- Your age, driving record, and location affect your rate far more than the car—but the car choice still makes a measurable difference.
Why repair costs drive insurance rates up and down
When an insurance company sets a rate for a car, they look at what it costs to fix that model after an accident. A Honda Civic fender-bender might cost $1,200 to repair. The same damage on a BMW 3 Series might cost $3,500 because BMW parts are more expensive and the repair work takes longer. Over thousands of claims, those differences add up, and the insurance company passes the cost to you.
Luxury brands—BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Audi, Lexus—have high insurance rates partly because parts are expensive and specialized. A single headlight assembly on a Mercedes can cost $1,500 new. A Honda headlight costs $200. Even when the damage is identical, the Mercedes owner's insurance company pays more, so they charge higher premiums to all Mercedes owners.
Japanese manufacturers keep repair costs down because parts are widely available and affordable. A Toyota Corolla door panel costs a fraction of what a Cadillac door panel costs. Repair shops compete on price for common cars, which keeps labor costs reasonable too. That translates directly to lower insurance rates.
Theft rates and safety ratings affect what you pay
Insurance companies track which cars get stolen most often. If a model is frequently targeted by thieves, the insurance company charges everyone who owns that model a higher rate to cover the theft claims. Dodge Chargers and Challengers, Chevrolet Camaros, and older Honda Civics have high theft rates in many regions, which pushes their insurance costs up even if repair costs are moderate.
Safety ratings matter because they predict injury claims. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) crash-test vehicles and publish ratings. Cars that score well in frontal crash, side crash, and rollover tests have fewer serious injury claims. Insurance companies reward this with lower rates. A Subaru Legacy typically has excellent safety ratings and lower theft rates, which keeps its insurance cost down.
Some cars are stolen for parts rather than resale. Older Honda Civics and Acura Integras are common targets because their parts fit many other Honda models and are valuable on the aftermarket. Even if the car itself is cheap, the insurance company knows it will pay more theft claims, so the rate goes up. A 2005 Civic might have a higher insurance rate than a 2015 Civic, partly because of this parts-theft history.
Specific car models with consistently low insurance rates
Honda Civic, Honda Accord, and Honda CR-V rank among the lowest across most age groups and regions. These cars have affordable parts, good safety ratings, moderate theft rates, and a large repair network. A 2018 or 2019 Civic or Accord will typically cost $100 to $200 less per year to insure than a comparable sports car or luxury sedan.
Toyota Camry, Toyota Corolla, and Toyota RAV4 also have low rates. Toyota's reputation for reliability means fewer accident claims overall, and parts are inexpensive. A Camry is one of the safest bets for low insurance costs across age groups.
Mazda3, Mazda6, and Subaru Outback round out the list of consistently affordable-to-insure vehicles. Mazda parts are reasonably priced, and Subaru's safety focus keeps injury claims down. A Subaru Outback costs more to insure than a Civic, but less than a comparable Jeep Grand Cherokee or Ford Explorer.
Pickup trucks vary widely. A Ford F-150 or Chevrolet Silverado costs more to insure than a Civic because repair costs are higher and they're involved in more accidents per capita. A Toyota Tacoma or Honda Ridgeline is cheaper to insure than a full-size truck, but still more expensive than a sedan.
Cars that cost significantly more to insure
Sports cars carry high insurance rates because they're involved in more accidents and have higher repair costs. A Dodge Challenger, Chevrolet Camaro, or Ford Mustang will cost 30 to 50 percent more per year to insure than a comparable Honda Accord, even if they're the same age. Insurance companies know sports car owners drive faster and take more risks, and the claims data backs that up.
Luxury vehicles—BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Audi, Porsche, Jaguar—have the highest rates. A 2018 BMW 3 Series costs roughly twice as much to insure as a 2018 Honda Accord. Parts are expensive, labor rates are high, and specialized technicians are required. Even minor damage runs up the bill quickly.
High-end SUVs like the Cadillac Escalade, Range Rover, and Porsche Cayenne fall into the same category. A Range Rover Evoque costs significantly more to insure than a Toyota RAV4, even though they're similar in size and purpose. The difference is repair cost and parts availability.
How to use car choice to lower your insurance costs
If you're shopping for a car and insurance cost matters to you, check insurance quotes before you buy. Most insurance companies let you get a quote online by entering the vehicle identification number (VIN) or the year, make, and model. Spend 15 minutes comparing quotes for two or three cars you're considering. You might find that one choice saves you $300 to $500 per year.
Focus on mainstream sedans and hatchbacks from Honda, Toyota, Mazda, and Subaru if low insurance is a priority. These cars also tend to hold their value and have lower maintenance costs, so the savings extend beyond insurance. A used 2018 Honda Civic will cost less to insure, maintain, and repair than a used 2018 Dodge Charger at the same price point.
If you want a truck or SUV, compare specific models. A Toyota Tacoma costs less to insure than a Ford F-150, and a Subaru Outback costs less than a Jeep Grand Cherokee. The difference isn't huge, but it adds up over time. A $200-per-year difference is $2,000 over a decade of ownership.
Avoid high-theft models in your region if possible. Ask your insurance agent which cars have the highest theft rates in your area. In some cities, older Honda Civics are stolen constantly. In others, Dodge Chargers are the target. Knowing this before you buy can save you money and hassle.
Safety features and discounts that offset higher insurance rates
Some cars with higher base insurance rates may have access to for discounts that bring the total cost down. A car with automatic emergency braking, lane-keeping information, or adaptive headlights may may have access to for a safety discount. A 2020 Subaru Outback might have a slightly higher base rate than a 2020 Honda CR-V, but Subaru's standard safety features might earn you a discount that narrows the gap.
Ask your insurance company what discounts explore to the specific car you're considering. Some insurers offer discounts for vehicles with certain safety ratings or features. A car with a high IIHS rating might may have access to for a 5 to 10 percent discount. Over a year, that can offset a higher base rate.
Bundling home and auto insurance, paying in full rather than monthly, and maintaining a clean driving record all matter more than the car itself. But the car choice is one lever you can pull, and it's worth pulling before you sign the paperwork.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a newer car always cost more to insure?
Not always. A 2015 Honda Civic might cost more to insure than a 2010 Honda Civic because newer cars have more expensive parts and electronics. But a 2015 Honda Civic will cost less to insure than a 2015 Dodge Challenger, regardless of age. The make and model matter more than the year.
Will buying a used car instead of new save me on insurance?
Yes, usually. Older cars cost less to insure because parts are cheaper and the car itself is worth less. A 2015 Honda Accord costs less to insure than a 2024 Honda Accord. But a 2015 Dodge Charger still costs more to insure than a 2024 Honda Accord. The model choice matters more than the age.
Can I get a lower rate by adding safety features to my car?
Some insurers offer discounts for aftermarket safety features like dash cams or anti-theft devices, but the discount is usually small—5 to 10 percent at most. Buying a car with built-in safety features is more effective than adding them later. A Subaru with standard safety tech will have a lower rate than a Dodge with aftermarket features.
Why do insurance companies charge more for red cars?
They don't. This is a common myth. Insurance companies don't have data showing that red cars are in more accidents. The rate is based on the make, model, year, and your driving record—not the color. A red Honda Civic costs the same to insure as a blue Honda Civic.
If I buy a car with a high insurance rate, can I lower it by changing my coverage?
You can lower your bill by raising your deductible or dropping optional coverage, but that increases your out-of-pocket cost if you have an accident. The insurance rate itself—what the company charges per dollar of coverage—is set by the car model and your driving record. Choosing a lower-rate car is the only way to reduce the rate itself.