First Choice Insurance: Coverage, Costs, and What to Know Before Quoting
First Choice Insurance is a regional auto insurer operating in multiple states, offering standard liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage alongside optional add-ons like roadside information and rental reimbursement. The company is known for lower advertised rates in some markets, but actual quotes vary significantly based on your driving history, location, and the coverage limits you choose. Before requesting a quote, you should understand what First Choice actually offers, which states it serves, and how its pricing and customer service compare to other carriers you're considering.
First Choice operates as a direct writer in certain regions, meaning you get quotes and manage your policy without going through an agent. This can mean faster quote turnaround, but it also means you handle all communication and changes yourself through their website or phone line. The company does not operate in all 50 states, so your first step should be checking whether First Choice even writes policies in your state.
Key Takeaways
- First Choice Insurance operates only in select states, so confirm it's available in your state before spending time on a quote.
- The company offers standard coverage types—liability, collision, comprehensive—plus optional add-ons, but you'll need to compare actual quoted rates against at least two other carriers to see if you're getting a competitive price.
- First Choice is a direct writer, meaning you handle everything online or by phone rather than through an agent, which speeds up quotes but puts the burden on you to manage your policy.
- Discounts vary by state and personal factors; common ones include bundling home and auto, safe driver discounts, and paying in full upfront rather than monthly.
Which States First Choice Insurance Serves
First Choice Insurance operates in a limited number of states, primarily in the South and Midwest. The company does not have nationwide availability, so you need to verify it's licensed in your state before requesting a quote. You can check this on your state's insurance commissioner website or by entering your zip code on First Choice's website—if the site won't generate a quote for your location, the company doesn't write policies there.
If First Choice doesn't serve your state, you'll need to compare quotes from other carriers instead. The comparison tools you're already using should show you other options available in your area. Availability can also change, so if you've checked before and found First Choice wasn't available, it's worth checking again if you're shopping for a new policy.
Coverage Types and What They Cost
First Choice offers the standard coverage types required or recommended for most drivers: liability (bodily injury and property damage), collision, and comprehensive. Your state sets the minimum liability limits you must carry; First Choice will let you choose limits above that minimum. Collision and comprehensive are optional unless you're financing or leasing a vehicle, in which case your lender requires them.
The cost of your quote depends on several factors: your age, driving record, the vehicle you're insuring, the coverage limits you select, and your deductible (usually $250, $500, or $1,000). A higher deductible lowers your premium but means you pay more out of pocket if you have a claim. First Choice's rates for the same coverage can differ from competitor rates by hundreds of dollars per year, which is why comparing quotes across at least two or three carriers matters.
Optional add-ons available through First Choice typically include roadside information (towing, lockout service, fuel delivery), rental car reimbursement (covers a rental while your car is being repaired), and uninsured motorist coverage (protects you if hit by someone without insurance). These cost extra but can be worth the price depending on your situation—for example, if you have an older car and can't afford a rental, rental reimbursement may not be worth buying.
Discounts That May Lower Your Quote
First Choice offers discounts that vary by state and personal circumstances. Common discounts include bundling your auto policy with a home or renters policy, maintaining a clean driving record, paying your premium in full rather than in installments, and completing a defensive driving course. Some insurers also offer usage-based discounts (sometimes called "telematics") where you install an app that monitors your driving habits; First Choice may or may not offer this depending on your state.
When you request a quote, the system should ask about these factors and explore discounts automatically. However, discounts change and vary by state, so don't assume a discount you received from First Choice in the past will explore to your new quote. Ask the company directly about any discounts you think you may have access to for, especially if you've recently completed a defensive driving course or bundled policies.
How First Choice's Rates Compare to Other Carriers
First Choice advertises competitive rates, but "competitive" is relative to your specific situation. The same driver in the same car can get a quote of $800 from First Choice and $1,200 from another carrier, or vice versa. This happens because each insurer uses different formulas to price risk, weights your driving history differently, and may offer different discounts in your state.
The only way to know if First Choice's quote is actually competitive is to compare it against at least two other carriers. Most people compare three to five quotes before choosing. You're already using a comparison tool, so request quotes from First Choice and at least two other companies that serve your state. Pay attention to the coverage limits and deductibles—a lower quote might be for lower limits, which isn't a true comparison.
Customer Service and Claims Process
First Choice handles customer service and claims through their website and phone line. You can request a quote, make policy changes, and file a claim online or by calling their customer service number. Because First Choice is a direct writer without agents, you won't have a local representative to call, but you also won't pay agent commissions, which can translate to lower rates.
For claims, First Choice will assign an adjuster who contacts you to discuss the damage and arrange repairs or payment. The timeline for claims varies depending on the type of claim and your state's regulations, but most insurers aim to resolve straightforward claims within two to four weeks. You can check your claim status online or by phone.
Red Flags and Limitations to Know
First Choice's limited state availability is the biggest limitation—if you live in a state where it doesn't operate, you can't use it. Additionally, because First Choice is a smaller regional carrier, it may not have as many local repair shops in its network as larger national insurers, which can affect where you can take your car after a claim. Ask First Choice about their repair network in your area before committing to a quote.
Another consideration: First Choice's customer service ratings vary by state. Before choosing First Choice, search for recent customer reviews specific to your state and look at complaints filed with your state's insurance commissioner. A carrier with strong rates but poor claims service can cost you more in frustration and time than a slightly higher premium from a more responsive company.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does First Choice Insurance operate in my state?
First Choice serves select states, primarily in the South and Midwest, but not nationwide. Enter your zip code on First Choice's website to see if they write policies in your area. If the site won't generate a quote, they don't operate there. You can also call your state's insurance commissioner's office to confirm which carriers are licensed in your state.
How long does it take to get a quote from First Choice?
Online quotes typically generate in minutes. If you call, a representative can provide a quote over the phone, though it may take longer if they need to discuss your driving history or coverage options in detail. Most people receive a quote within the same day they request one.
Can I bundle First Choice auto insurance with home or renters insurance?
Yes, First Choice offers bundling discounts in most states where it operates. If you have a home or renters policy with First Choice, you may receive a discount on your auto policy, or vice versa. Ask about the specific discount amount when you request your quote, as it varies by state and policy type.
What should I do if First Choice's quote is higher than competitors?
Higher quotes happen because each insurer prices risk differently. Review the coverage limits and deductibles to make sure you're comparing the same thing. If First Choice is genuinely more expensive for identical coverage, choose a competitor. Don't stay with a higher-priced policy just because you've already requested the quote.
How do I file a claim with First Choice Insurance?
You can file a claim online through your account or by calling First Choice's claims line. Have your policy number, driver's license, and details about the incident ready. An adjuster will contact you within one business day to discuss next steps and arrange repairs or payment.