What Farmers Mutual Insurance Is
Farmers Mutual Insurance is a member-owned insurance company that sells auto, home, life, and farm coverage through independent agents. Unlike stock insurance companies owned by shareholders, Farmers Mutual is structured as a mutual company — policyholders are the owners, and profits are returned to members as dividends or rate reductions rather than paid to outside investors.
The company operates in multiple states, though availability varies by location. You cannot buy directly from Farmers Mutual online; you work with a licensed independent agent who represents the company in your area. This means the agent can also show you quotes from other insurers, which is useful when you are comparing options.
Farmers Mutual has been in business since 1916 and focuses heavily on rural and agricultural customers, though it also insures suburban and urban drivers. The company is rated A+ (Superior) by A.M. Best, a financial strength rating agency that measures whether an insurer can pay claims.
Key Takeaways
- Farmers Mutual is a member-owned company, so you own a share and may receive dividends or rate reductions as a policyholder.
- You buy through independent agents, not directly online, which means one agent can quote you against other companies.
- The company offers auto, home, life, and farm insurance, with stronger presence in rural areas but availability that varies by state.
- Farmers Mutual's A+ financial rating means the company has the reserves to pay claims, which is the most important measure of insurer stability.
- Comparing quotes from Farmers Mutual against other carriers helps you see whether the mutual structure and dividend potential actually save you money in your situation.
Auto Insurance Coverage Through Farmers Mutual
Farmers Mutual auto policies include liability (which pays for damage you cause to others), collision (which covers damage to your car from hitting something), comprehensive (which covers theft, weather, and vandalism), and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage (which protects you if hit by a driver without insurance or without enough insurance).
The company also offers optional add-ons like roadside information, rental car reimbursement, and gap insurance (which covers the difference between what you owe on a loan and what the car is worth if it is totaled). Deductibles — the amount you pay out of pocket before insurance kicks in — are customizable, usually ranging from $250 to $1,000 or higher.
Farmers Mutual discounts for auto insurance vary by state and agent, but commonly include multi-policy bundling (home and auto together), good driver discounts, safety feature discounts (anti-theft devices, airbags), and completion of defensive driving courses. Some agents also offer usage-based programs where a mobile app monitors your driving habits and can lower your rate if you drive safely.
Homeowners and Property Coverage
Farmers Mutual homeowners policies cover the structure of your house, personal property inside it, liability if someone is injured on your property, and additional living expenses if you cannot stay in your home due to a covered loss like fire. You choose coverage limits for each category, and the insurer will ask about your home's age, construction type, roof condition, and distance from fire hydrants — all of which affect your rate.
The company also writes farm and ranch policies that cover barns, equipment, livestock, and farm liability — this is where Farmers Mutual has historically been strongest. Farm policies are more specialized than standard homeowners coverage and account for the unique risks of agricultural operations.
Like auto policies, homeowners coverage includes optional add-ons such as scheduled personal property (which covers high-value items like jewelry or art at their full replacement cost rather than a percentage of your home's value) and water backup coverage (which pays for damage from sump pump failure or backed-up sewers).
Life Insurance and Other Products
Farmers Mutual offers term life insurance (coverage for a set number of years at a fixed rate) and whole life insurance (permanent coverage with a cash value component that builds over time). Term life is typically cheaper and is what most people use to protect their family's income if they die; whole life is more expensive but does not expire and can be borrowed against.
The company also writes annuities, which are investment products that pay you income over time, usually in retirement. Annuities are complex products with fees and surrender charges, so you should understand what you are buying before committing.
How Farmers Mutual's Member-Owner Structure Affects Your Rate
Because Farmers Mutual is member-owned, the company does not need to generate profits for shareholders. Instead, any surplus at the end of the year can be returned to policyholders as a dividend or used to hold rates steady while competitors raise theirs. This is a real financial advantage, but it is not automatic — you have to be a policyholder to receive a dividend, and the amount varies based on the company's underwriting results and investment returns.
In years when claims are high or investment returns are low, Farmers Mutual may not pay a dividend. Conversely, in profitable years, the dividend can be substantial. Over a multi-year period, the mutual structure often results in lower net cost than a stock company, but this depends on the specific company's claims experience and your own risk profile.
When you are comparing quotes, ask the agent whether Farmers Mutual has paid dividends in recent years and what the average amount was. This gives you a realistic picture of what the mutual structure might save you, rather than assuming a dividend is may provide.
Availability and How to Get a Quote
Farmers Mutual operates in roughly 20 states, concentrated in the Midwest and Great Plains but with presence in other regions. Availability is not nationwide, so your first step is confirming whether the company writes policies in your state. You can do this by searching online for "Farmers Mutual Insurance agents near me" or by contacting your state's insurance department, which maintains a list of licensed insurers.
Once you confirm availability, you contact an independent agent licensed to sell Farmers Mutual policies. The agent will ask about your home, vehicles, driving history, and coverage needs, then provide a quote. Because the agent represents multiple insurers, you can ask them to quote you against other companies in the same conversation — this is one advantage of working through an independent agent rather than going directly to a company website.
The quote process typically takes a few days to a week, depending on how quickly the agent gathers information and the insurer processes it. You do not pay anything to receive a quote.
Comparing Farmers Mutual Against Other Insurers
Farmers Mutual is not the cheapest insurer for every driver or homeowner — rates depend on your age, location, driving record, home value, and dozens of other factors. The best way to know whether Farmers Mutual is competitive for you is to get quotes from at least two or three other companies and compare the total cost, not just the premium.
When comparing, look at the coverage limits you are getting for the price, not just the lowest number. A cheaper quote with a $1,000 deductible and no uninsured motorist coverage is not the same as a slightly higher quote with a $500 deductible and full uninsured motorist protection. Also factor in any dividends Farmers Mutual has paid in recent years — this lowers your effective cost.
Independent agents can show you multiple quotes side by side, which saves time and makes comparison easier than visiting each company's website separately. This is a practical reason to start with an agent rather than online quotes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Farmers Mutual operate in my state?
Farmers Mutual is licensed in roughly 20 states, mostly in the Midwest and Great Plains. Search online for "Farmers Mutual Insurance [your state]" or contact your state's insurance department to confirm. If the company does not write policies where you live, your agent can quote you from other insurers instead.
What does the A+ rating from A.M. Best mean?
A.M. Best rates insurance companies on financial strength — their ability to pay claims even during economic downturns. A+ (Superior) is the second-highest rating and means Farmers Mutual has substantial reserves and a low risk of insolvency. This matters because the cheapest quote is worthless if the company cannot pay your claim when you need it.
Can I buy Farmers Mutual insurance online?
No. Farmers Mutual sells only through independent agents, not directly online. You contact an agent in your area, provide information about your home or vehicles, and receive a quote. The agent can also quote you from other companies, making it straightforward to compare.
How often does Farmers Mutual pay dividends?
Dividends are not may provide and depend on the company's financial results each year. Farmers Mutual has paid dividends in most recent years, but the amount varies. Ask your agent what the company paid in the last three to five years to get a realistic sense of what you might receive.
What is the difference between Farmers Mutual and Farmers Insurance?
Farmers Mutual and Farmers Insurance are separate companies. Farmers Insurance is a large stock company owned by Zurich Insurance and operates nationwide. Farmers Mutual is smaller, member-owned, and operates in about 20 states. They are not affiliated, so do not assume one quote applies to the other.