Dairyland is a regional insurer that specializes in high-risk drivers
Dairyland Insurance is a Wisconsin-based company owned by Nationwide that focuses on drivers who have trouble finding coverage elsewhere. If you have a poor driving record, no prior insurance history, or a suspended license, Dairyland will often write a policy when standard insurers won't. The trade-off is that premiums are typically higher than what you'd pay with a mainstream carrier.
The company operates in about 20 states, concentrated in the Midwest and South. Availability depends on your state and driving history. Dairyland doesn't compete on price for clean-record drivers—it competes on willingness to insure people mainstream companies reject. That focus shapes everything about how the company works: faster underwriting, fewer discounts, and a straightforward rate structure.
Key Takeaways
- Dairyland insures high-risk drivers that most other companies will decline, including those with DUIs, suspensions, or multiple accidents.
- Rates are higher than standard insurers because you're in a riskier category, but you can still compare quotes from other high-risk specialists before committing.
- The company offers basic liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage, but fewer discount options than larger carriers.
- You can get a quote online or by phone, and Dairyland typically issues policies faster than traditional insurers because the underwriting process is simpler.
- If your driving record improves, you may may have access to for lower rates with a standard insurer after a few years of clean driving.
What coverage Dairyland actually offers
Dairyland sells the standard types of car insurance: liability (bodily injury and property damage), collision, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist coverage. The difference from a mainstream insurer is not in what's available—it's in what's bundled and how discounts work.
You can customize your deductibles and coverage limits, but Dairyland doesn't offer the long list of add-ons that larger carriers do. There's no accident forgiveness, no disappearing deductible, no new-car replacement. The company keeps the product straightforward because its customers are focused on getting insured, not optimizing discounts. If you need roadside information or rental car coverage, you can add those, but they're not standard.
How Dairyland's rates compare to other high-risk insurers
Dairyland is one option in a small category of companies that specialize in high-risk drivers. Others in that space include SR-22 specialists like Acceptance Insurance, Bristol West, and some regional carriers. Rates vary significantly by state, driving history, and vehicle type, so a quote from Dairyland might be lower or higher than a competitor depending on your specific situation.
The only way to know is to get quotes from multiple high-risk insurers. Dairyland's website lets you quote online, and most competitors do the same. Spend 15 minutes getting three or four quotes before you commit. Even within the high-risk category, a 20 or 30 percent difference between carriers is common. If you're required to file an SR-22 form (proof of insurance for the state), confirm that the insurer you choose will handle that filing—most do, but it's worth asking.
When Dairyland makes sense versus when it doesn't
Dairyland is the right choice if you've been declined by standard insurers or if you have a recent DUI, suspension, or multiple at-fault accidents. The company will write you a policy when others won't, and it does so without the long wait times that some high-risk specialists have.
Dairyland is not the right choice if you have a clean driving record. You'll pay a premium for being in the high-risk pool even though you don't belong there. If you've had one accident five years ago and nothing since, or if you're a young driver with no violations, shop with mainstream carriers first. Geico, State Farm, and Progressive all have programs for drivers with less-than-perfect records, and their rates for clean-record drivers are substantially lower than Dairyland's.
How to get a quote and what information you'll need
You can get a Dairyland quote online at dairyland.com or by calling 1-800-334-6541. The online process takes about 10 minutes. You'll need your driver's license, vehicle identification number (VIN), and current insurance information if you have it. If you don't have current insurance, that's fine—Dairyland will still quote you.
The company will ask about your driving history, including accidents, violations, and any license suspensions. Be honest. Dairyland's underwriting is designed to handle these situations, and misrepresenting your record will void your policy later if you file a claim. Once you submit the quote request, you'll get a rate estimate when ready online or a call from an agent within a few hours.
What happens after you buy a Dairyland policy
Dairyland issues policies quickly—often the same day you explore. You'll receive your declarations page (proof of insurance) by email, which you can use when ready if you need to show proof to the state or your lender. Your physical ID card arrives by mail within a few days.
Billing is typically monthly, and you can pay online, by phone, or by automatic bank draft. If your driving record improves over time—no accidents or violations for three to five years—you may become may be able to access for standard insurance at a lower rate. At that point, shop around with mainstream carriers. Your improved record is an asset, and you should use it to get better pricing elsewhere.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Dairyland file SR-22 forms for you?
Yes. If your state requires an SR-22 as proof of insurance (usually after a DUI or suspension), Dairyland will file it with the state on your behalf at no extra charge. Confirm this when you get your quote, and ask how long the filing takes—it's usually within one business day.
Can you cancel a Dairyland policy early without a penalty?
Dairyland allows you to cancel at any time, though some states require a short notice period (usually 10 days). If you cancel mid-month, you'll receive a refund for unused premium. There's no early termination fee, but check your state's rules—a few states have specific requirements for high-risk policies.
What if you get into an accident while insured with Dairyland?
File a claim the same way you would with any insurer: call the claims line (1-800-334-6541) or file online. Dairyland will assign an adjuster, and the process works like any other carrier. Your rates may increase after an at-fault accident, depending on your state's rules and your policy terms.
Is Dairyland owned by a larger insurance company?
Yes. Dairyland is a subsidiary of Nationwide, one of the largest insurers in the United States. That ownership means Dairyland has the financial backing to pay claims, but it operates independently with its own underwriting and pricing. Being part of Nationwide doesn't change your rates or coverage options.
Can you switch from Dairyland to a standard insurer later?
Yes. Once your driving record improves—typically after three to five years with no violations or at-fault accidents—you become may be able to access for standard insurance at lower rates. Shop around with mainstream carriers at that point. Your improved record is valuable, and you should use it to get better pricing.