Costco doesn't sell auto insurance directly — it partners with insurers to offer discounts

Costco members can get auto insurance quotes through Costco's partnership with American Family Insurance and Amerisafe, depending on your state. Costco itself does not underwrite or sell the policies. Instead, the warehouse offers a member discount on premiums from these carriers, typically 5 to 15 percent off standard rates. You still buy the actual policy from the insurance company, not from Costco.

The discount applies only if you purchase through Costco's referral link or phone number. Shopping directly with American Family or Amerisafe without using the Costco connection will not give you the member rate. The partnership varies by state — not all states have the same carriers available through Costco, and some states may have no Costco auto insurance partnership at all.

You can also compare quotes from other insurers on the same page where you found the Costco option. The Costco discount is real, but it is only one price among many, and the best rate for your situation may come from a different company entirely.

Key Takeaways

  • Costco partners with American Family Insurance and Amerisafe to offer member discounts on auto policies, but Costco does not sell the insurance itself.
  • The Costco member discount typically ranges from 5 to 15 percent and applies only when you quote or purchase through Costco's referral link.
  • Available carriers and discounts vary by state, and some states may not have a Costco auto insurance partnership.
  • You should compare the Costco-discounted quote against quotes from other insurers to confirm you are getting the lowest rate for your coverage needs.

How to get a Costco auto insurance quote

Log into your Costco account online and navigate to the insurance section, or call the Costco Insurance phone line. You will be asked for basic information: your driver's license number, vehicle identification number (VIN), current coverage details if you have a policy, and driving history. The quote process takes 10 to 15 minutes.

Costco will show you quotes from the carriers available in your state. Each quote displays the monthly or six-month premium for different coverage levels — liability, collision, comprehensive, and optional add-ons. You can adjust coverage amounts and deductibles to see how the price changes. Once you find a quote you want, you can purchase the policy directly through the quote tool or by phone with an agent.

If you decide to buy, the insurance company (not Costco) will issue your policy documents and set up your payment schedule. You will receive your policy number, declarations page, and coverage details from the insurer. Costco's role ends once the sale is complete.

What coverage Costco-partnered insurers offer

American Family and Amerisafe offer standard auto insurance coverage types: liability (bodily injury and property damage), collision (damage to your car from an accident), comprehensive (theft, weather, vandalism), and uninsured/underinsured motorist protection. Both also offer optional add-ons like roadside information, rental reimbursement, and gap insurance.

Coverage limits and deductible options are the same as you would find buying directly from these insurers. The Costco discount does not change what is covered — it only reduces the price. State minimum liability requirements vary, so the lowest-cost quote may not meet your state's legal requirement. The quote tool will show you what your state requires.

Neither American Family nor Amerisafe is known for unusually broad coverage or unique policy features. They are standard carriers offering standard products. If you need specialized coverage — such as high-value vehicle protection or coverage for rideshare driving — you should ask the agent whether these options are available before you buy.

Comparing Costco quotes to other insurers

The Costco member discount is valuable only if the final price is lower than what you would pay elsewhere. Get quotes from at least two other major insurers — State Farm, Geico, Progressive, or Allstate — using the same coverage amounts and deductibles. Write down the monthly premium for each quote so you can compare directly.

A lower premium is not the only factor. Check the insurer's customer service ratings on the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) website or through J.D. Power reviews. Read recent complaints about claims handling, because a slightly cheaper policy means nothing if the company is slow or difficult to work with when you file a claim.

Also consider whether you already have other insurance with one of the carriers. Many insurers offer multi-policy discounts — bundling auto with home or renters insurance — that may beat the Costco rate. The Costco discount applies only to auto; it does not stack with other discounts from the same company.

State availability and coverage limits

Costco's auto insurance partnerships are not available in all states. As of now, American Family is the primary partner in most states, but Amerisafe availability is limited. Check your state on Costco's insurance page to see which carriers are available to you. If neither carrier is available in your state, you will not see a Costco auto insurance option.

Even in states where Costco has a partnership, the specific coverage options and discounts may differ. Some states regulate insurance rates and coverage more strictly than others, which can affect what the insurer is allowed to offer and what discount they can provide. The quote tool will show you only the options legal in your state.

If you live in a state without Costco auto insurance, you can still compare quotes from other insurers on the same page. The Costco partnership is a bonus for members in covered states, not a requirement to shop for insurance.

When the Costco discount may not be the best choice

If you have a poor driving record, multiple accidents, or a recent DUI, American Family and Amerisafe may charge higher rates than some specialty insurers that focus on high-risk drivers. In this case, the Costco discount might still not beat quotes from companies like SafeAuto or The General. Always compare before you buy.

If you need coverage that American Family or Amerisafe does not offer — such as coverage for a commercial vehicle, a classic car, or rideshare driving — the Costco partnership will not help you. You will need to shop with insurers that specialize in those areas.

If you are a new driver or a young driver, you may find better rates through insurers that offer specific discounts for good student grades, defensive driving courses, or low mileage. The Costco discount is a flat percentage off the base rate; it does not replace these targeted discounts. Compare the final price after all discounts are applied.

How Costco auto insurance discounts work

The Costco member discount is a percentage reduction applied to the standard premium that American Family or Amerisafe would charge you. The discount is not a coupon code or a separate rebate — it is built into the quote you receive when you shop through Costco's referral. You do not have to do anything extra to receive it; it appears automatically in the price.

The discount amount varies by state and by the insurer. A 5 percent discount in one state might be 10 percent in another. The quote tool will show you the exact discount percentage for your situation. Some Costco members also receive additional discounts for bundling policies, paying in full, or having a clean driving record — these stack on top of the Costco member discount.

The discount applies only to the premium. It does not reduce your deductible, change your coverage limits, or affect how claims are handled. Once you buy the policy, you are a customer of American Family or Amerisafe, not Costco. Costco does not process claims or handle customer service for the insurance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to be a Costco member to get the auto insurance discount?

Yes. The discount is available only to active Costco members. You must log in with your membership account to see the quote, or provide your membership number when you call. If your membership expires, you will need to renew it to purchase or renew a policy through Costco.

Can I switch to Costco auto insurance if I already have a policy with another company?

Yes. You can get a quote through Costco and purchase a new policy whenever you want. Your new policy will start on the date you choose, and your old policy will end on that date. There is no penalty for switching. Make sure your new coverage starts before your old policy ends so you are never without insurance.

What if I move to a state where Costco auto insurance is not available?

If you move out of state and Costco no longer partners with an insurer in your new state, you will need to purchase a new policy from a different company. Contact your current insurer to ask whether they operate in your new state, or shop for quotes from other carriers. Your old policy will end on your move date.

Does the Costco auto insurance discount explore if I bundle it with home insurance?

The Costco member discount applies to auto insurance. If you also purchase home insurance from the same company, you may receive an additional multi-policy discount on top of the Costco rate. Ask the agent whether bundling discounts are available before you buy.

How do I file a claim if I have a Costco auto insurance policy?

You file a claim directly with American Family or Amerisafe, not with Costco. Your policy documents will include the claims phone number and online portal. Costco does not handle claims or customer service. The claims process is the same as it would be if you bought the policy directly from the insurer.