Costco Car Insurance Is Sold Through Kirkland, Not Underwritten by Costco
Costco does not write or underwrite car insurance itself. Instead, the company partners with Kirkland Insurance, a licensed broker, to sell policies underwritten by major carriers like Amica Mutual, Infinity, and others depending on your state and driving profile. When you buy through Costco's website or in-warehouse kiosk, you are buying from these carriers at negotiated rates, not from Costco directly.
This matters because it changes where you go if you have a claim or need to make changes. You contact the insurance company itself (Amica, Infinity, or whichever carrier you were quoted), not Costco. Costco's role ends after the sale. The rates you see are the same rates those carriers offer elsewhere, though Costco members may see slightly lower quotes because Kirkland negotiates volume discounts for the membership base.
Costco advertises this as a member benefit, but it functions like any other insurance broker — a middleman connecting you to carriers. The advantage is convenience (you can quote it while shopping) and the possibility of a modest discount. The disadvantage is that you have one fewer place to shop if you want to compare quotes, since Costco only shows you the carriers it has partnered with.
Key Takeaways
- Costco sells car insurance through Kirkland Insurance, which brokers policies from carriers like Amica Mutual and Infinity, not from Costco itself.
- Rates through Costco are the same as the underlying carrier's rates elsewhere, though volume discounts for members may lower your quote slightly.
- You contact the insurance company directly for claims and policy changes, not Costco, so Costco's role is limited to the initial sale.
- Costco only shows you the carriers it has partnered with, so you will need to quote other insurers separately to compare your full range of options.
- The carriers available vary by state, so the quote you receive depends on where you live and your driving history.
Which Insurance Companies Underwrite Costco Policies
The carriers behind Costco quotes change by state. Amica Mutual is the most common underwriter for Costco members nationally and is known for high customer satisfaction ratings in independent surveys. Infinity appears in many states and typically offers lower rates for drivers with accidents or violations on their record. Other carriers that may appear in your quote include National General, Bristol West, and regional insurers depending on your location.
You do not choose the carrier when you quote through Costco — the system shows you rates from whichever carriers Kirkland has partnered with in your state. This is different from going directly to an insurer's website, where you control which company you contact. If you want to compare Amica's rate against State Farm's or GEICO's, you have to quote those companies separately; Costco will not show you all of them in one place.
The carriers that appear in your Costco quote are licensed and regulated in your state, so they meet the same financial and claims-handling standards as any other insurer. The difference is purely which companies Kirkland has negotiated with for volume discounts.
How Costco's Rates Compare to Direct Quotes
Costco's rates are not inherently cheaper than going direct to an insurer. The rates you see are the carrier's standard rates, possibly with a small discount applied because Kirkland negotiates volume pricing for Costco's membership base. That discount varies by state and carrier — sometimes it is 5 to 10 percent, sometimes it is negligible.
The real comparison is between the specific carriers Costco shows you and the carriers you would quote on your own. If Costco quotes you Amica at $1,200 per year, you should compare that to Amica's rate if you went to Amica directly (usually the same) and to other carriers' rates for the same coverage. The Costco quote is useful as one data point, but it is not a shortcut to finding the lowest rate — you still need to quote multiple carriers to know whether you are getting a good price.
Costco's advantage is speed and convenience, not necessarily savings. If you are already a member and you want to quote quickly without visiting multiple websites, Costco's tool is efficient. If you are shopping for the absolute lowest rate, you will need to quote at least three to five carriers separately, which Costco's single-broker model does not provide.
Coverage Options and Limits You Can Choose
Costco's quote tool lets you select standard coverage types: liability (bodily injury and property damage), collision, comprehensive, uninsured motorist, and medical payments. You choose your deductibles for collision and comprehensive, typically $250, $500, $1,000, or higher. The quote updates in real time as you adjust limits and deductibles, so you can see how raising your liability limit from $100,000 to $250,000 affects your premium.
The coverage options themselves are not unique to Costco — every insurer offers these same types. What matters is whether the carrier you are quoted (Amica, Infinity, or another) offers the limits you need and at a price you can afford. Some carriers have minimum or maximum limits that differ slightly, so if you need very high liability coverage, you should check whether your quoted carrier can provide it.
Costco does not bundle car insurance with home or renters insurance the way some carriers do, so you cannot get a multi-policy discount through Costco. If you have homeowners insurance elsewhere, you may save more by bundling with that carrier than by taking a Costco car quote alone.
How to Get a Quote and What Information You Need
You can quote Costco car insurance on Costco.com or at an in-warehouse kiosk if your local warehouse has one. The online process takes 10 to 15 minutes and asks for your driver's license number, driving history, vehicle identification number (VIN), current coverage limits if you have insurance, and annual mileage. You will also enter your zip code, which determines which carriers are available in your state.
Have your driver's license and vehicle registration handy before you start. If you are switching from another insurer, having your current policy in front of you makes it faster to match your existing limits. The quote is typically valid for 30 to 60 days, depending on the carrier, so you have time to compare it against other quotes before deciding.
After you receive a quote, you can purchase online when ready or call Kirkland's phone number to discuss options with an agent. If you purchase online, you choose your start date (usually within 30 days) and payment method. The policy documents are sent by email and mail.
Claims Process and Customer Service
If you have a claim, you contact the insurance company directly, not Costco. The carrier's claims phone number is on your policy documents and insurance card. Most carriers offer 24/7 claims reporting, and many let you file a claim through their mobile app or website. The claims process — damage assessment, repair authorization, payment — is handled entirely by the carrier, not by Kirkland or Costco.
For policy questions, billing, or changes to your coverage, you also contact the carrier directly. Kirkland's role is limited to the initial sale and quote; it does not manage your account after purchase. This is important to understand because some people assume Costco handles ongoing service, but it does not.
Customer service quality depends on which carrier you are quoted. Amica Mutual consistently ranks high in customer satisfaction surveys. Infinity and other carriers have more variable ratings. You can research the carrier's customer service reputation before you buy, using independent review sites and state insurance department complaint data.
When Costco Car Insurance Makes Sense and When It Does Not
Costco car insurance makes sense if you are a Costco member, you want a quick quote without visiting multiple websites, and you are comfortable with the carriers Kirkland has partnered with in your state. It is also reasonable if you have already shopped around and found that one of Costco's carriers (usually Amica) offers a competitive rate for your profile.
Costco car insurance does not make sense if you are not a member, if you have a complex driving history and need to shop many carriers to find one that will insure you at a reasonable rate, or if you want to bundle car and home insurance for a larger discount. It also does not make sense if you are looking for the absolute lowest rate without doing any comparison shopping — Costco is one quote, not a may provide of the best price.
The decision should be based on the actual rate you receive, not on the Costco brand. If Costco quotes you $1,400 per year and GEICO quotes you $1,100, GEICO is the better choice, regardless of where the Costco quote came from. Use Costco as one of your three to five comparison quotes, not as your only quote.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to be a Costco member to buy car insurance through Costco?
Yes, you must have an active Costco membership to purchase car insurance through Kirkland. If you are not a member, you can still quote the carriers directly (Amica, Infinity, etc.) on their own websites, but you will not receive any Costco member discount.
Can I cancel my Costco car insurance policy early without a penalty?
Cancellation policies vary by carrier. Most do not charge a cancellation fee, but some may have a small administrative fee. Check your policy documents or contact the carrier directly to confirm. Costco does not handle cancellations; you contact the insurance company.
Does Costco car insurance cover rideshare driving like Uber or Lyft?
Standard personal auto policies, including those sold through Costco, do not cover rideshare driving. You need a rideshare endorsement or a separate commercial policy. Ask the carrier when you quote whether they offer rideshare coverage and what it costs.
What happens if I move to a different state after buying Costco car insurance?
You contact the insurance company to update your address and confirm your policy is still valid in your new state. Some carriers operate in all 50 states; others do not. If your carrier does not operate in your new state, you will need to switch to a different insurer and get a new quote.
Can I get a discount if I have a good driving record?
Yes, all carriers offer safe driver discounts, and the carriers behind Costco quotes are no exception. The discount is factored into your quote automatically based on your driving history. You may also be offered discounts for completing a defensive driving course or bundling with other policies, depending on the carrier.