Insurance costs depend on the car itself, not just how you drive
The car you own has a direct effect on what you pay for insurance—sometimes more than your driving record does. Insurance companies look at repair costs, safety ratings, theft rates, and how often that specific model ends up in claims. A Honda Civic costs less to insure than a BMW 3 Series, even if both drivers have clean records, because Civics are cheaper to fix, hold up well in crashes, and thieves steal fewer of them.
When you compare quotes, the insurer already knows what car you drive and has priced it accordingly. But understanding which vehicles cost less to insure helps you make a smarter choice before you buy. The difference between a cheap-to-insure car and an expensive one can be $500 to $1,500 per year—money that adds up over the years you own it.
Key Takeaways
- Sedans and wagons typically cost less to insure than sports cars, luxury vehicles, or SUVs, because they have lower repair costs and better safety records.
- Insurance companies charge more for vehicles that are stolen frequently, even if the model itself is reliable—the Honda Civic and Ford F-150 are among the most stolen vehicles in North America.
- Newer cars with advanced safety features like automatic emergency braking and blind-spot monitoring often may have access to for discounts that can offset their higher repair costs.
- A vehicle's engine size, horsepower, and performance rating affect insurance cost; a turbocharged engine or high-performance trim of the same model will cost more to insure.
- Checking the insurance cost before you buy is as important as checking the purchase price, because a cheaper car to buy can be expensive to insure.
Sedans and compact cars usually have the lowest insurance rates
Four-door sedans and compact hatchbacks are the cheapest vehicles to insure because they combine low repair costs, good safety ratings, and low theft rates. Models like the Toyota Corolla, Honda Civic, Hyundai Elantra, and Mazda3 appear on most insurers' lowest-cost lists. These cars are built in high volume, so parts are inexpensive and widely available. When a repair shop needs a replacement door or bumper, the cost is low, which keeps claims payable and premiums down.
Wagons—the longer-bodied versions of sedans—also insure cheaply for the same reason. A Subaru Outback or Toyota Corolla Cross costs less to insure than an SUV of similar size, even though both have comparable safety features. The difference is repair cost: wagons use sedan parts and repair procedures, while SUVs use heavier-duty components that cost more to replace.
Sports cars and performance vehicles cost significantly more
Any car marketed as a sports car or performance model will have higher insurance costs, regardless of how safely you drive. Insurance companies charge more because these vehicles are involved in more accidents—drivers of sports cars tend to drive faster and take more risks. A Dodge Charger, Chevrolet Camaro, or Ford Mustang will cost 20 to 40 percent more to insure than a standard sedan, even the same model year.
High-performance trims of ordinary cars also cost more. A Civic Si or Mazda3 Turbo will have a higher insurance rate than the base Civic or standard Mazda3, because the insurer knows the turbocharged or sport-tuned version attracts drivers who accelerate harder and brake later. The difference is usually $200 to $400 per year for the same car with a different engine.
Luxury and premium brands carry higher costs across the board
BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Audi, and Lexus models cost more to insure than mainstream brands because their parts are expensive and repair shops charge higher labor rates. A fender from a BMW costs three times what a Honda fender costs, and the technician who installs it charges more per hour. Even a minor accident that would cost $1,500 to repair on a Honda might cost $4,000 on a BMW, and the insurance company prices that risk into your premium.
Luxury vehicles also have more complex electronics and safety systems. When a sensor fails or a computer module needs replacement, the cost is high. A standard sedan might have a backup camera; a luxury sedan has a 360-degree camera system with multiple processors. The repair bill reflects that complexity.
Theft rates matter as much as repair costs
The Honda Civic and Ford F-150 are among the most stolen vehicles in North America, which means insurance companies charge more to cover the risk of theft. Even if you park in a garage and have an alarm, your insurance rate reflects the fact that your model is a theft target. Thieves steal Civics because they are common, parts are valuable, and older models lack modern anti-theft technology.
Conversely, vehicles that are rarely stolen—like the Subaru Outback, Toyota Corolla, and Hyundai Elantra—have lower theft-related premiums. If you live in an area with high vehicle theft, choosing a car that thieves ignore can save you money on comprehensive coverage, which is the part of your policy that covers theft.
Safety features and crash test ratings lower your costs
Cars with high crash test ratings from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) often may have access to for safety discounts. Features like automatic emergency braking, lane-keeping information, and blind-spot monitoring reduce accident frequency, and insurers reward that with lower rates. A newer Toyota Corolla with these features may cost less to insure than an older Corolla without them, even though the newer car is worth more.
Some insurers offer discounts of 5 to 15 percent for vehicles with specific safety technologies. Check your insurer's website or call their quote line to ask which features may have access to for discounts on the car you are considering. This can offset the higher repair cost of a newer vehicle.
SUVs and trucks cost more than sedans of the same size
Sport utility vehicles and pickup trucks have higher insurance costs than sedans because they are heavier, more expensive to repair, and involved in more severe accidents. A Ford Explorer costs more to insure than a Ford Fusion, even though both are mid-size vehicles. The Explorer's frame, suspension, and body panels are heavier and more expensive to replace. Accidents involving SUVs and trucks also tend to be more severe because of their weight and height, which increases claim costs.
Compact SUVs like the Honda CR-V or Toyota RAV4 are cheaper to insure than full-size SUVs, but they still cost more than the sedan versions of the same brand. If insurance cost matters to your decision, a Corolla will cost less to insure than a Corolla Cross, even though the Cross offers more cargo space.
Electric vehicles have mixed insurance costs
Electric vehicles (EVs) are newer to the market, so insurance pricing is still settling. Some insurers charge more for EVs because battery replacement is expensive and repair shops are less familiar with the technology. A Tesla Model 3 or Chevrolet Bolt can have higher insurance costs than a comparable gas sedan. However, some insurers offer discounts for EVs because they are involved in fewer accidents—drivers of electric cars tend to be more cautious—and they have lower operating costs overall.
If you are considering an EV, get a quote before you buy. Insurance costs for electric vehicles vary widely between insurers, so comparing quotes is more important than it is for gas cars. Some insurers specialize in EVs and offer better rates; others charge a premium.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the color of the car affect insurance cost?
No. Insurance companies do not charge different rates based on paint color. This is a common myth. The only things that matter are the make, model, year, engine size, and safety features—not how the car looks.
Will a used car cost less to insure than a new one?
Usually, yes. Older cars cost less to insure because repair costs are lower and replacement parts are cheaper. However, a very old car with poor safety ratings may cost more to insure than a newer car with advanced safety features. Get quotes on both before you decide.
Can I lower my insurance cost by choosing a different trim level of the same car?
Yes. A base model sedan will cost less to insure than a sport or performance trim of the same model. The difference is usually $200 to $400 per year. If insurance cost is a factor, choose the base engine and trim level.
Do hybrid cars cost more or less to insure?
Hybrid cars typically cost slightly more to insure because battery and hybrid system repairs are expensive. However, the difference is usually small—$100 to $300 per year—and some insurers offer discounts for hybrids because they are involved in fewer accidents.
Should I check insurance cost before I buy a car?
Yes. Get quotes from your insurer for any car you are seriously considering before you make an offer. The insurance cost over five years can be as much as the difference between two cars' purchase prices. Knowing the total cost of ownership—purchase price plus insurance—helps you make a smarter choice.