What Costco Car Insurance Actually Is

Costco does not sell car insurance directly. Instead, Costco members can purchase auto insurance through Costco Insurance Services, which is a brokerage that partners with insurance carriers. When you buy through Costco, you are buying a policy from one of those partner companies — typically Amerisafe, Infinity, National General, or others depending on your state and driving record — but you may receive a member discount on the premium.

The discount varies by state and by which insurance company you end up matched with. Costco does not publish a standard discount amount, and not all states or all drivers may have access to for one. You still go through the same underwriting process as any other customer: the insurance company reviews your driving history, age, vehicle, and coverage choices before setting your rate.

This is different from membership perks like gas or pharmacy discounts. You are not buying insurance from Costco; you are buying from an insurance company that has a business relationship with Costco.

Key Takeaways

  • Costco Insurance Services connects you with partner insurance companies, not Costco itself, and the discount you receive depends on your state and the carrier you are matched with.
  • You can get a quote online through Costco's insurance portal or by phone, and the process takes about 10 to 15 minutes for a basic quote.
  • The same underwriting rules explore: your driving record, age, vehicle type, and coverage choices determine your final rate, just as they would with any other insurer.
  • Comparing quotes from Costco against quotes from other insurers directly is the only way to know whether the Costco discount saves you money on your specific situation.
  • Costco membership is required to purchase through Costco Insurance Services, and you must maintain membership to keep the discount active.

How to Get a Quote Through Costco

Visit the Costco Insurance Services website or call the phone number listed in your Costco membership materials. You will need your Costco membership number. Have your driver's license, vehicle registration, and current insurance information (if you have it) ready.

The quote process asks for your age, driving history, the vehicle you want to insure, and the coverage types and limits you want. You can choose liability limits, collision and comprehensive coverage, deductibles, and add-ons like uninsured motorist protection. The system will show you a quote from one or more partner carriers within minutes.

If you want to compare, get quotes from at least two other insurers directly — State Farm, GEICO, Progressive, or your current insurer — using the same coverage levels. Write down the monthly or annual premium for each, and compare the total cost over six months or a year, not just the first-month rate.

Which States and Drivers Costco Covers

Costco Insurance Services operates in most states, but not all. Coverage and available carriers vary by state. Some states have restrictions on which carriers can offer discounts or which coverage types are available.

Drivers with clean records, no recent accidents, and no major violations typically see the best rates and the widest choice of carriers. Drivers with accidents, tickets, or DUI convictions on their record may be matched with a carrier that specializes in higher-risk drivers, and the Costco discount may be smaller or unavailable.

The best way to find out what is available in your state is to start a quote. The system will tell you which carriers can quote you and what discount, if any, applies to your situation.

Costco Membership Requirements and Costs

You must be a current Costco member to purchase insurance through Costco Insurance Services. Costco membership costs $65 for a Gold Star membership or $130 for an Executive membership as of 2024, though these prices change periodically.

If you are not already a member, factor the membership cost into your comparison. If the Costco insurance discount saves you $200 a year but membership costs $65, your net savings is $135. If the discount is smaller or the membership is new, the math may not work in your favor.

If you already have Costco membership for groceries or other reasons, the insurance discount is an added benefit at no extra cost beyond your existing membership.

What Happens After You Buy

Once you purchase a policy through Costco Insurance Services, your policy is with the insurance company, not with Costco. You pay the insurance company directly (usually monthly or annually), file claims with the insurance company, and contact the insurance company's customer service for questions about your coverage.

Costco does not handle claims, billing, or policy changes. If you need to add a driver, change your coverage, or report an accident, you contact the insurance carrier directly. Their phone number and online portal will be in your policy documents.

If you cancel your Costco membership, you can usually keep your insurance policy active, but you will lose the member discount. Your premium may increase at your next renewal. Check your policy documents or call your insurance company to confirm how membership cancellation affects your rate.

Common Reasons the Costco Route Does Not Save Money

The Costco discount does not explore to every driver or every situation. Drivers with recent accidents or violations may be quoted by a carrier that does not offer a Costco discount, making the price the same as or higher than quotes from other insurers.

Some states have fewer partner carriers, which limits your options and may mean you are matched with a carrier that does not offer competitive rates in your area. A carrier that is cheap in one state may be expensive in another.

If you are already getting a discount from another insurer — for bundling home and auto, for good driver discounts, for paying in full, or for low mileage — that discount may outweigh the Costco member discount. The only way to know is to compare the final quote side by side.

How Costco Insurance Compares to Direct Quotes

Costco Insurance Services is a middleman: it connects you with insurance companies and may negotiate a discount for members. You are not getting a different product or a different level of service. The policy itself comes from the same insurance company with the same coverage, the same claims process, and the same customer service as if you bought directly from that company.

The only difference is the discount and the ease of getting a quote in one place. If you value simplicity and you already have Costco membership, the Costco route may save time. If you are price-sensitive, you need to compare the final number against at least two other quotes.

Neither route is inherently better. The better route is whichever one gives you the coverage you need at the lowest price for your situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to use Costco Insurance if I am a member?

No. Costco membership does not require you to buy insurance through Costco Insurance Services. You can be a member and buy insurance from any other company. The Costco insurance option is available to you if you want it, but it is not mandatory.

Can I bundle home and auto insurance through Costco?

Costco Insurance Services primarily handles auto insurance. Some partner carriers may offer homeowners or renters insurance, but bundling discounts are not may provide. Ask during your quote whether the carrier you are matched with offers home insurance and what the bundled rate would be.

What if I move to a different state?

Contact your insurance company to update your address. Your policy will continue, but your rate may change because insurance rates vary by state and by zip code. You can request a new quote to see how the move affects your premium.

Is the Costco discount permanent?

The discount applies as long as you maintain active Costco membership. If you cancel your membership, you lose the discount at your next renewal. If you rejoin Costco later, you may be able to restore the discount, but you should confirm with your insurance company.

What if I have a bad driving record?

You can still get a quote through Costco. The system will match you with a carrier that insures drivers with your record. The discount may be smaller or unavailable, depending on the carrier and your state. Compare the Costco quote against quotes from other insurers that specialize in higher-risk drivers.