The sandwich test and what officers are actually looking for

An open-faced turkey sandwich is not about food—it is a shorthand officers use to describe what they see when they pull someone over on suspicion of impaired driving. The term refers to the physical signs an officer observes: an open mouth (difficulty speaking clearly or slurred speech), a flushed face (redness or flushing of the skin), and the "sandwich" of observations stacked together to form reasonable suspicion.

This is not an official test or a legal standard. It is informal language that appears in some police training materials and DUI arrest reports. Understanding what officers are trained to look for—and what they are not trained to look for—matters because these observations form the foundation of the traffic stop itself. If the stop was not based on reasonable suspicion, everything that follows may be challengeable in court.

Key Takeaways

  • Officers use informal observations like speech clarity and facial flushing to form reasonable suspicion, but these signs alone do not prove impairment.
  • Many of the physical signs officers look for—red eyes, flushed face, difficulty speaking—can result from fatigue, allergies, medication, or medical conditions unrelated to alcohol.
  • The initial traffic stop must be based on reasonable suspicion of a traffic violation or impaired driving; observations made during the stop cannot justify the stop itself.
  • A defense attorney can challenge whether the officer actually observed what they claim, or whether those observations were consistent with impairment rather than other causes.

What officers are trained to observe during a DUI stop

Police academies and DUI enforcement training programs teach officers to watch for a cluster of signs during the initial contact with a driver. These include slurred or unclear speech, difficulty following instructions, an inability to maintain balance or coordination, and physical signs like red or watery eyes, flushed skin, or the smell of alcohol on the breath.

The idea behind this approach is that impairment typically shows up in multiple ways at once. A single sign—red eyes, for example—is not enough. But when an officer observes several signs together, they use that pattern to justify moving forward with field sobriety tests or a breath test.

The problem is that this cluster of signs can appear for many other reasons. Fatigue causes red eyes and slurred speech. Allergies cause watery eyes and flushed skin. Certain medications affect balance and coordination. A person who is nervous during a traffic stop may stumble or speak unclearly. None of these conditions indicate impairment by alcohol or drugs.

Why these observations are not reliable proof of impairment

Courts recognize that the signs officers observe during a traffic stop are not specific to alcohol impairment. A person can have red eyes because they did not sleep, flushed skin because they have a fever or sunburn, and difficulty speaking clearly because they are anxious or have a speech impediment. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) itself acknowledges in its training materials that many of these signs have other causes.

This is why DUI cases often turn on what happened after the initial observation. Field sobriety tests—the walk-and-turn, one-leg stand, and horizontal gaze nystagmus (HGN) test—are supposed to be more objective measures. A breath or blood test provides a chemical measurement. But the initial observations that led to the stop are subjective and easily challenged.

A defense attorney can argue that the officer misinterpreted what they saw, or that the signs the officer observed were consistent with something other than impairment. If the officer cannot clearly articulate why they believed impairment was present—beyond a general description of appearance or speech—the entire basis for the stop may be questioned.

How the initial stop affects everything that comes after

The traffic stop itself must be based on reasonable suspicion. This means the officer must have observed facts that would lead a reasonable person to believe a traffic violation occurred or that the driver was impaired. The observations made during the stop cannot be used to justify the stop itself—that is circular reasoning and violates the Fourth Amendment.

If a defense attorney can show that the officer did not have reasonable suspicion before the stop began, then the stop was unlawful. When a stop is unlawful, everything discovered as a result of that stop—including breath test results, field sobriety test performance, and any statements the driver made—may be excluded from evidence. This is called the "fruit of the poisonous tree" doctrine.

For example, if an officer pulled someone over based only on a vague description of the vehicle or a hunch, without observing any actual traffic violation or impairment, a court may rule that the stop was unconstitutional. The breath test result, even if it showed a high blood alcohol content, could be thrown out.

What reasonable suspicion actually requires

Reasonable suspicion is a lower standard than probable cause, but it is not a guess. An officer must be able to point to specific, articulable facts that led them to stop the vehicle. These facts might include:

  • Weaving between lanes or drifting within a lane
  • Driving significantly slower or faster than the speed limit
  • Failing to maintain proper distance from other vehicles
  • Running a red light or stop sign
  • Driving at an unusual time of night in an area known for impaired driving
  • A report from another person that the driver was impaired

A flushed face or unclear speech observed through a car window before the officer even approached the vehicle would not meet this standard. The officer must have a reason to stop the car before they can observe the driver's appearance or speech.

How to challenge observations in your case

If you were stopped and charged with DUI, your attorney will examine the officer's report and testimony to determine whether the observations they describe actually support reasonable suspicion. This involves asking specific questions: Did the officer describe the traffic violation they observed, or only the driver's appearance? Did they note the time of day, the road conditions, or other context? Did they document what they saw in writing, or are they reconstructing it from memory months later?

Your attorney may also challenge the officer's interpretation of what they observed. If the report says you had slurred speech, your attorney can ask the officer to describe exactly what you said and how it differed from normal speech. If the report mentions a flushed face, your attorney can introduce evidence that you have a medical condition, were taking medication, or had just come from exercise that would explain the appearance.

Body camera footage, dash camera footage, and witness statements can all contradict or clarify what the officer claims to have observed. If the video shows you speaking clearly or walking steadily, that evidence directly contradicts the officer's written observations.

The difference between observation and interpretation

Officers are trained to observe facts, but they often record interpretations instead. There is a difference. A fact is something that can be verified: "The driver's eyes were red." An interpretation is a conclusion drawn from that fact: "The driver appeared impaired." Courts care about facts, because interpretations can be wrong.

When an officer writes in a report that you "appeared intoxicated" or "showed signs of impairment," they are offering an opinion, not a fact. Your attorney can challenge that opinion by presenting other explanations for the facts the officer actually observed. If the officer observed that your eyes were red but did not document whether you had been crying, had allergies, or had been awake for 24 hours, your attorney can raise those possibilities.

This is why detailed questioning of the officer during cross-examination is so important. The more specific the officer's observations, the more specific your attorney's challenges can be. Vague descriptions like "the driver seemed off" or "something didn't seem right" are easier to attack than precise, documented facts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an officer stop me just because I look tired or have red eyes?

No. An officer needs reasonable suspicion of a traffic violation or impaired driving before they can stop your vehicle. Red eyes or tired appearance alone are not enough. The officer must observe a traffic violation, erratic driving, or other specific facts that suggest impairment—not just your appearance.

What if the officer says I was slurring my words during the stop?

Your attorney can challenge this by asking the officer to describe exactly what you said and how it differed from normal speech. Body camera footage often shows whether speech was actually slurred. Nervousness, a speech impediment, or a medical condition can all affect how someone speaks during a stressful traffic stop.

Does the smell of alcohol on my breath mean I was impaired?

No. The smell of alcohol indicates you consumed alcohol, but it does not indicate impairment. You can smell like alcohol and still be under the legal limit, or have consumed alcohol hours earlier when it is no longer affecting your driving. Breath odor alone is not proof of impairment.

If the officer's observations were wrong, can the whole case be dismissed?

It depends. If the officer lacked reasonable suspicion to stop your vehicle in the first place, the stop itself may be ruled unlawful, and evidence from the stop could be excluded. If the stop was lawful but the officer's observations were inaccurate, those observations can be challenged, but the case may still proceed if other evidence supports the charges.

What should I do if I was stopped and given a breath test based on observations I think were wrong?

Contact a DUI defense attorney as soon as possible. They can review the police report, request body camera and dash camera footage, and determine whether the stop was based on reasonable suspicion. The sooner you act, the better your attorney can preserve evidence and prepare your defense.