Open Face is when you admit to the facts the prosecution needs to prove guilt, but still contest the charge itself
An open face plea in a DUI case means you tell the court: "I don't dispute what happened—the officer's observations, the test results, the driving pattern—but I'm arguing those facts don't add up to the crime you're charging me with." You're not saying the breathalyzer was wrong or the officer lied. You're saying the legal conclusion they're drawing from those facts is incorrect.
This is different from a straight guilty plea, where you accept both the facts and the charge. It's also different from a not guilty plea, where you contest the facts themselves. Open face puts you in the middle: you concede the evidence but argue the law doesn't support conviction on that particular charge.
The practical effect is that you go straight to sentencing if the judge agrees with the prosecution's legal theory, or you win the case if the judge agrees with yours. There's no trial, no jury, no cross-examination of witnesses. The judge decides the legal question based on the facts everyone agrees on.
Key Takeaways
- Open face means you accept the facts but argue they don't legally amount to the charge—useful when the evidence is strong but the legal theory is weak.
- The judge decides the legal question alone; if they agree with you, the charge is dismissed; if they agree with the prosecution, you move to sentencing.
- This strategy makes sense when fighting the charge itself (like arguing impairment wasn't proven) rather than fighting what the officer observed.
- You lose the right to appeal the facts later, since you've already admitted them in open court.
- Your attorney needs to believe the legal argument is genuinely strong, because a weak one wastes your chance at trial.
When open face makes sense in a DUI case
Open face is most useful when the evidence of what happened is solid—the officer's observations are documented, the breath or blood test came back, the dashcam or body camera footage is clear—but the legal interpretation of that evidence is debatable. For example, you might concede that you were driving and that your blood alcohol was 0.09, but argue that the specific way the officer administered the field sobriety tests was flawed enough that impairment wasn't actually proven under your state's law.
It also makes sense when the prosecution's case is so strong that fighting the facts at trial would be futile, but a legal argument could succeed. Burning resources on a trial you're almost certain to lose, only to face sentencing anyway, often costs more than resolving the case on the legal question. Open face lets you take that legal shot without the expense and risk of a full trial.
The strategy requires your attorney to have genuine confidence in the legal argument. If the argument is weak, you've just handed the judge a guilty verdict without the jury safeguard of reasonable doubt. You also lose the right to appeal based on the facts, because you've admitted them under oath.
How open face differs from other plea options
A guilty plea means you accept both the facts and the charge. You're done. Sentencing happens, and appeals are limited to whether your attorney was ineffective or the sentence was illegal.
A not guilty plea means you contest the facts, the charge, or both. You go to trial. The prosecution must prove every element beyond a reasonable doubt. You can cross-examine witnesses, challenge evidence, and force the state to prove its case.
An open face plea means you concede the facts but argue the legal conclusion is wrong. No trial happens. The judge decides the law. If you lose, you go straight to sentencing. If you win, the charge is dismissed.
Some jurisdictions also allow conditional pleas, where you plead guilty but preserve the right to appeal a specific legal question (usually about whether evidence should have been suppressed). That's different from open face, which is a straight admission of facts with a legal argument attached.
What happens after an open face plea
Once you enter an open face plea, the judge reads the facts into the record—usually from the police report, witness statements, and test results. Your attorney then presents the legal argument for why those facts don't support the charge. The prosecution responds. The judge rules.
If the judge agrees with you, the charge is dismissed. You're done. No conviction, no sentencing, no probation. If the judge agrees with the prosecution, you move directly to sentencing. There's no second chance, no trial, no jury. The conviction is final on the facts you've already admitted.
Sentencing after an open face conviction follows the same process as any other DUI sentence: the judge considers your record, the circumstances, any aggravating or mitigating factors, and applicable sentencing guidelines. You may still have options like treatment programs, work-release, or reduced jail time, depending on the jurisdiction and the specifics of your case.
The risk of losing your right to appeal
When you enter an open face plea, you're telling the court under oath that the facts are true. You can't later claim the officer's observations were wrong, the breathalyzer was miscalibrated, or the blood draw was contaminated. Those arguments are gone.
You can still appeal if the judge made a legal error—for instance, if the judge misapplied the law to the facts you admitted, or if your attorney was ineffective in presenting the legal argument. But you cannot appeal the facts themselves. If the conviction stands, it stands on the facts you've already conceded.
This is why open face only makes sense when your attorney is confident in the legal argument and when the factual evidence is genuinely difficult to challenge. If there's any real doubt about what the officer observed or what the test results actually show, a not guilty plea and trial are safer.
When your attorney might recommend open face
Your attorney might suggest open face if the prosecution's factual case is airtight—multiple witnesses, clear video, reliable test results—but the legal theory has a genuine weakness. For example, your state might require proof of impairment beyond just a blood alcohol number, and the officer's notes don't document specific impaired driving behavior. Conceding the BAC but arguing impairment wasn't proven could work.
Open face also makes sense when the cost of trial is high and the chance of winning at trial is low, but the legal argument is strong enough to justify the risk. If your attorney believes there's a 30% chance of winning on the legal question but only a 5% chance of winning at trial, open face might be the better bet.
Your attorney should never recommend open face as a shortcut or a way to move the case faster. The only reason to do it is because the legal argument is genuinely strong and the factual evidence is genuinely difficult to challenge. If either of those conditions is missing, you should go to trial.
Questions to ask your attorney about open face
Before agreeing to an open face plea, ask your attorney: What is the specific legal argument, and how strong is it? What cases support it in your jurisdiction? What's the judge's track record on this particular argument? What happens if the judge disagrees—what's the likely sentence? What would the prosecution offer in a plea deal, and how does that compare to the likely sentence after open face? Is there any factual argument worth pursuing at trial, or is the evidence truly solid?
Also ask: Can we preserve the right to appeal the legal question if we lose? (Some jurisdictions allow conditional pleas; some don't.) What's the downside of going to trial instead—cost, time, risk? And be honest with your attorney about whether you're comfortable admitting the facts under oath. If you have any doubt about what actually happened, open face is not the right move.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I change my mind after entering an open face plea?
Withdrawing a plea is possible but difficult. You have to show the judge that the plea was not knowing and voluntary, or that there's a fair and just reason to withdraw it. Most judges are reluctant to allow withdrawal once the plea has been entered and the legal argument has been heard. Talk to your attorney when ready if you're having second thoughts.
Is an open face plea the same as a conditional plea?
No. A conditional plea lets you plead guilty while preserving the right to appeal a specific legal issue (usually a suppression question). An open face plea means you admit the facts but argue the legal conclusion is wrong—the judge decides that argument right away, not on appeal. Some jurisdictions allow conditional pleas; not all allow open face.
What if the judge thinks the facts are unclear?
If the judge believes the facts are genuinely disputed, they may refuse the open face plea and require you to either plead guilty straight up or go to trial. Open face only works when both sides agree on what happened and the only question is what the law says about it.
Can I still get a DUI reduced to a lesser charge with open face?
Not directly. Open face is about arguing the facts don't support the charge you're facing. If you want the charge reduced to reckless driving or wet reckless, that's usually a negotiation with the prosecution, not an open face argument. Your attorney can pursue both—negotiate a reduction and, if that fails, argue open face on the original charge.
What if I lose the open face argument—can I appeal?
You can appeal if the judge made a legal error in ruling against you, but you cannot appeal the facts you admitted. Your appeal would argue that the judge misapplied the law, not that the facts were different. Appeals on legal questions alone are harder to win than appeals that challenge the facts or the evidence.